SUBMITTED: Thursday, July 17, 2008
POSTED: Thursday, July 17, 2008
I work for a major reporting firm and before I bought an extended warranty. I did my homework and research. I asked a lot of questions and read a lot of posts before putting any money out. This is what I found.
Laws vary from state to state regarding extended warranties.
Almost all warranty companies take on vehicles sight unseen. The companies who say call back any time probably won't be around when you need them. Warranty Gold is a good case in point. That's why Continental Warranty states they don't have open enrollment, because if they did, what would stop someone from waiting until their car broke down before they purchased a warranty? However, I did find out that Continental Warranty wants you to enroll the first time they talk to you because of incentives, like 0% financing, roadside assistance, car rental, etc. They claim to give you more benefits the first time they talk to you. Which is not true, the incentives are the same whether it's the 1st, 2nd or 3rd time.
One consumer from a different post wrote: Consumer rights to a 30 day cancellation are already in place under the consumers rights laws. If not mistaken, that's a federal law to protect consumers.
Answer: This is absolutely correct, with the exception of Florida which allows 60 days.
Same consumer from a different post wrote: Solely based upon having been told by a sales rep, you'll have the ability to cancel within 30 days. A common sales ploy used to earn a commission on a sale.
Answer: I asked the agent the same question. I was told the Sales Agent DOES NOT get a commission until after the 30/60 days have elapsed, and only if the customer does not cancel and has made the first monthly installment.
Same consumer from a different post wrote: In order for the article to be more informative, it needs to be stated how the Continental Warranty was able to immediately charge your credit card? What you failed to note was, in order for Continental to do that, you had to have given them the card number.
Answer: Not only must the credit card be given in order for the transaction to be processed, but all customers are sent through to the “Verification Dept.â€. A verification agent reads from a script and the call is digitally recorded to protect both the consumer as well as the company. Throughout the call the verification agent asks “Do you have any questions so farâ€? At the end of the verification process the agent asks “Do I have your permission to charge $ X to your X Credit Card today? Your credit card cannot be charged without your express permission.
As far as California law regarding the power train warranty. It is not any better or any worse than any other extended California warranty. That is not to say it's a good warranty. It's called a “Product Warrantyâ€. What that means is they are guaranteeing when you add the product, which is a coolant additive to your radiator, if any of the parts listed on the warranty breakdown as a direct result of the product not working as stated, they'll repair it. But this type of warranty is iffy at best as it only covers certain components. Read this plan carefully before your 30 days is up, and definitely BEFORE your add the product. They DO NOT have to give you your deposit back after the product has been added, and from what I understand, most times won't give it back (unless you make a big stink and get a reporting agency involved). Although that goes for all warranty companies, not just Continental. If you decide to go forward with this type of warranty and the component(s) which is covered does fail, the warranty will pay 100% parts and labor up to $4500 which can be a very good investment on your part. I do not recommend this type of warranty for either a high end vehicle (BMW, Mercedes, Lexus etc) or a new car with virtually no mileage, buy a “Full Coverage†warranty from the dealer BEFORE you drive off the lot.
By the way, there's no such thing as a bumper to bumper warranty. Bumpers are cosmetic as is the glass, upholstery, trim etc. Warranties also do not cover maintenance like oil changes or tune-ups, or wear and tear items like your battery, brake pads, light bulbs, etc.
Which leads me to the question of; Is it a good idea to buy a warranty from the dealership?
Depends on what state you're in. In California the laws are much different than in other states. Think of it this way. Dealerships specialize in selling cars, warranties are up sells for the finance dept. Dealerships do not sell you the warranty at their wholesale rate, they add on a mark up amount, which can be ½ the cost of the warranty. If you financed the vehicle and the warranty is included in the financing it means your warranty is accruing charges at whatever interest rate you're paying. Some time's a good thing; but only if it's on a new car with a low interest rate and the warranty lasts as long as the financed payments. On a used vehicle you've financed for 5 years, and the warranty is only good for 3 years, you'll be paying interest on a warranty that expired 2 years before the loan is paid off! Not a good deal.
As far as Continental Warranty goes, they're brokers, They sell warranties, no more, no less. The company has been around for years but it's the underwriter who'll be paying your claims. A lot of warranty companies do not use underwriters, they're self insured companies, many have also been around for years and pay your claims too, others close their doors before they have to put out any money. Do your homework. Ask a lot of questions.
Does Continental Warranty give you the facts? Yes, but you need to ask the right questions and be willing to listen to the answers all the way through. Can you call back? They'll tell you “Yes, but you won't be eligible for a certified planâ€. That's not true, you can call back and get certified coverage, however keep in mind since you'll driving your car, your mileage will go up which may change the plan you're originally eligible for.
Were the Continental Warranty Agents I spoke with rude? Not at all. The 3 different agents I spoke with were very firm in their policy about not calling back and willing to explain in detail “why†I needed to put down a deposit today (which I didn't do till the 3rd time, so the “First Time Applicant†rule isn't true) I did not find any inconsistency in what they were telling me about underwriters or Risk Retention Groups. They were patient, informative, and yes, at times they put me on the spot about having let my warranty lapse. They also called me on some excuses I made about speaking with my wife before I gave them the deposit by reminding me I had given them permission to submit my Vin #. Several times during all three calls, I too felt my integrity was being questioned. But the bottom line was, looking at it from their point of view, as the woman explained to me; she couldn't see my car from her office (I live in another state) and if the Ins. Co. was willing to take on my car sight unseen I would need to give them the same amount of trust with a “small†refundable deposit on a secured credit card.
People, this is how all sales work. Just like any other company they want to earn your business. But in order to earn it, you must first read the fine print, and DO read the fine print, however you've got to get the contact into your hands first so you “can†read the fine print, and the only way you can read the fine print is to put down a refundable deposit.
Whichever company you decide to purchase from, read the contract until you understand what you're getting, and if you have questions, call and ask someone to explain (I called as there were a few questions I had after I got the paperwork). A warranty like any other insurance based product is something you'd probably rather not spend your money on, yet it sure is a great investment when your car breaks down! I know, I'm the guy who didn't think I needed one until I ended up sending $3800 I didn't have (I had to put it on 3 different credit cards), on a repair for my last car.
Will I keep this warranty or return it within the next few days? I still have a bit more reading to do, but one thing's for sure, I'm at least well informed and if I decide I don't want it I'll ask for my money back.
Thank you for taking the time to do your research as I did, and that is why I came back to post this so I could share my experience.