I stated...
"Opting out means that the debit card transaction will be DECLINED
at any point of sale or ATM if the funds are truly unavailable...hence
NO MORE OVERDRAFT FEES.....EVER...period done end of conversation. "
You replied...
"NOPE! Afraid NOT. Your statement is WRONG as regards POINT OF SALE
transactions. Your "at ANY point of sale or [any] ATM is INCORRECT.
All the "regulations" from the Fed isn't going to change it either
because the INFRASTRUCTURE for real time data transfer/verification
DOES NOT EXIST (via the ACH.)"
You are misunderstanding the entire point to "opting out" and why the banks are against it. The policies of overdraft protection and re-sequencing were put in place years ago to protect check users..the policies are designed for CHECKS..such as to cover a mortgage payment if there were insufficient funds.
What turned the tables on many customers, and have cost them a FORTUNE in fees..is the banks using these same policies for debit card users.
Now think about it..what does the bank encourage EVERY customer to do?
1) use the debit card for everything
2) enroll in online banking
3) automatically enroll EVERY customer (and many banks never gave a choice) in mandatory courtesy overdraft protection.
4) Resequence and MANIPULATE the TIME and ORDER of transactions.
Put those all together..and it is a recipe for overdraft fee-ing many debit card using customers into the poorhouse.
Agreed, that "currently" there are no provisions for check and ACH transactions if opted out..which can lead to trouble. (there is talk of different policies for check/ACH vs. debit card but for now the consumer must utilize caution)...However if you read MOST of the complaints about overdraft fees on this sight (which is a very very small percentage of victims..most do not report here), they were due the BANK continually allowing the debit card to be used AFTER the account balance reached zero..with no notification in most cases, and then the resequencing compounded it..and as well caused MANY additional fees to incur..even on transactions that DID have the funds available FREE AND CLEAR at the time of the transactions..but the banks manipulations altered the times in order to charge additional fees.
So for example..lets say a customer is opted out. They fall sucker to some on line merchant who charges 49.99 to the card but the customer thought the charge was only going to be 5.99. Now..being opted out can actually "protect" this consumer.
First of all..if there was not 49.99 in the account to begin with..the transaction would be declined..nightmare avoided.
Buts lets say for the sake of argument the account covered the 49.99. The customer thinks the charge is only going to be 5.99 and enters that into the register. Now what happens if this causes the customer to overdraft? Need I say? Not to mention that the bank most likely will continue to allow this card to be used after it is overdrafted..so all the coffee is 35 dollars a cup etc..well we all know the horror stories.
Bottom line is WHATEVER the reason an overdraft was to occur..the transaction WILL BE DECLINED at a point of sale or an ATM is the funds are TRULY unavalable..regardeless of what the register says..what the decieving untrustworthy unreliable online statement says..regardless of what the teller at the banks says..and regardless of what the bank defenders say...the transaction WILL be DECLINED..and hence NO overdraft FEE is possible. Not too hard to understand no..is it? Or should I type slower?
"What WILL happen is that merchants (especially small merchants that
process BATCHES) will REFUSE to accept bank cards/check cards for
purchases altogether. Got that Ronnie?"
I never heard of this one before..but you know what???? That is still BETTER then then getting charged 35 dollars for diapers..and then the bank manipulating transactions. This is a serious recession we are in and people have dangerously low balances..perhaps the merchants should take precautions as well.
"The PROPOSED federal rules for notifying the consumer that a POINT
OF SALE transaction is going to cause an OD/NSF fee is NOT GONNA FLY
-overdrafts will still occur unless the merchant REFUSES to accept the
atm/check card altogether."
I have no idea what you ae talking about. If anyone EVER makes a purchase with a debit or credit card (or even a check these days)..at the time of the swipe the card/check is either accepted..or rejected..right? So what makes anything different with the new policies other then better protecting the customers account..and helping to prevent overdrafting? That is the point to this..you are clutching at straws in a feeble attempt to discredit the changes SO MANY customer have wanted for so long..and they are fair..to the consumers..to the merchant..and to the bank. No one rips anyone off this way..why is it such an issue with you? As far as ach and bouncing checks..always was illegal..and always was forgiven if the customer makes good and pays the NSF fee..if not..they face criminal charges and destroyed credit rating..that is still the case after the changes..consumers must STILL spend and use the account responsibly...only difference..the banks TACTICS will not be in place to fleece the debit card users..so they will find other ways...bet on that.
"Your "no more overdraft fees" is wishful thinking at best, or a
deliberate attempt to mislead folks at worse. Either way, YOU ARE
MISTAKEN."
I am not misleading anyone..this is the very words from the banks themselves..do some research before you rebut me please..you are the one horribly mistaken. You do not understand how opting out works at all.