Just how big was the gun they held to your head forcing you to buy the car?
It is apparent that you do not know how financing works. EVERY car loan has a majority of the payments in the beginning go toward interest. You loan payments are based on you paying on or before the due date, each and every month. If you pay after that you are assessed additional interest and possibly late fees.
If your $17,000 number is even close you are well short of what you should have been paying. Because figuring that you should have been paying Nov 2005 through Aug 2009 that is 46 payments. At $491.87 that means you should have paid over $22,000. This puts you about $5,000 short of what you should have paid. So it is quite normal that you would still owe the amount you do especially if you add in additional interest.
"I refuse to pay them anymore. I have already spoke to a attorney and plan to file a law suit against them."
- If the Attorney is taking any money from you that is the REAL RipOff because there is no grounds for a suit. If you do not continue to pay on the car they will eventually reposess the car.