During the week ending June 26, 2005, I received a call from a representative from Educational Sales and Marketing, his name was Jason. He was screening me to see if I would be a good candidate to participate in their “Success” program. This program would essentially create a success story for an Internet marketing program and course I had purchased in mid-June called CB Mall and the Internet Protégé Program. I am trying to develop a part time income in Internet marketing.
Participation in this success program would help me generate a substantial income using specialized and proprietary software and tools if I was chosen as a good candidate. Part of the deal was that I had to spend at a minimum, 10 – 15 hours a week working with the program. I assumed it would be in marketing and advertising since special customized software would take care of the technical aspects.
I then received a follow-up call from Eric McCormick (with ESM) who stated I met all the criteria to buy into their “success” program. He stated that my investment in proprietary Software and tools should be 10% of the annual salary I would require to leave my full-time job and derive an income to replace it. We derived at a figure of $10,100. It was explained very clearly that my investment was for software and tools only; all mentoring and coaching would be free of charge. The program consisted of 12 mentor/coaching sessions to be completed over a 14 week time frame..
As a little background information, I had just accepted a new full-time job in Minnesota and had left my position as GIS Coordinator with the City of Longmont, Colorado. We were scheduled to move (my family and I ) on July 18 – 21 from Colorado to Minnesota.
On June 29 I paid a down payment of $2100 to ESM, Inc. to hold my position in the success program since it was decided that it would only make since to begin once the move was completed and I had a chance to settle into my new home. Eric and I agreed to wait and have the software package shipped to my new address in Minnesota the week of July 18th. I highlight the terms “software package” because that is what Eric explained I would be receiving, so I was expecting a package of software, CD's, manuals, etc.
On July 18th I made the final payments from my Visa debit (checking) card totaling $8,000, making my final purchase of $10,100. I did in fact receive via FedEx, a package (letter sized document package). Inside were documents that needed my signature for the shipment of the actual software (I assumed). The package was described as follows:
Advanced training session (please note: it was explained to me, adamantly, that all mentoring and coaching was to be free) and that my $10,100 was paying for software and tools only, so I was a bit surprised to see this as part of what I was purchasing)
Link software
Website and keyword analysis
Link request form
Link directory template
Web ring traffic swarm
Entity structuring CD
There was also a congratulations letter and certificate for becoming a member of the “Personalized Training and Mentoring Program”. I signed and initialed the paperwork and faxed back to ESM as requested, still assuming the software would be shipped soon. I even got confirmation from Eric McCormick that my package would be shipped out.
I then received an e-mail from Jacob Sowers with Advance Business Development (ABD) on or about the 22nd of July, stating that he was my coach and to schedule our first session (1/2 hour session, 1 of 12). My immediate replied to him was that I hadn't received my software package yet, so how could I begin. He assured me that I didn't need anything for the first session anyway, so we scheduled it for Tuesday, July 26. As it turns out, ESM out sources the coaching and mentoring to ABD. I begin to think that if all mentoring and coaching is free of charge, how can ESM outsource this task: who is really paying for this.
During my first coaching session with Mr. Sowers he explained that the CB Mall product was not a good program to work with and achieve success with. This really got my attention since it was the successful promotion of CB Mall that I signed up for. Nothing else. He further explained the program he was mentoring me on was nothing more than Search Engine Optimization (SEO), to create a search engine friendly web site that could be used to promote any product and be successful. This was completely different than the program explained to me and that which I paid for. Jacob even mentioned I would need to purchase a web page building program for $29.95 per month (or something like this), and use it to begin building a clean, from scratch, web site to begin optimizing. He also mentioned to me that the only software program needed was Arelis, which can be purchased on the Internet for $99.
This immediately sent up a red flag that I had been deceived into purchasing something that was completely different than what was described to me. I frantically began researching ESM and then the terms (Link software, Website and keyword analysis, Link request form, Link directory template, Web ring traffic swarm and “Entity structuring CD”) to see if I could find any cases of Internet fraud or scams.
CLICK here to see why Rip-off Report, as a matter of policy, deleted either a phone number, link or e-mail address from this Report. I called the gentleman that posted this site and he confirmed with me that the same merchant account had charged his credit card as mine; The Shanklin Group or Shanklin International. Even though he had dealt with a different company. After researching banking merchant accounts I discovered that for different companies to use the same merchant account they must be affiliated in some way.
I immediately contacted Eric McCormick with ESM, who stated he had been on vacation and would look into the matter of why I was being coached by Jacob Sowers. That's funny because I had spoken with him just a few weeks earlier. I looked at the Utah Better Business web site and found there had been a complaint against ESM in the spring, 2005, and it had been resolved. From this web site I also retrieved the e-mail address for ESM (customersupport@infowest.com) and the CEO's name, Cameron Montgomery.
I called ESM and spoke with Niki, the customer service representative, and asked for a complete refund. She then sent me an e-mail stating that no refund could be honored since ESM had done nothing wrong. I sent an e-mail to Nikki describing my situation, and that I wanted her to forward to Mr. Montgomery. This was just last Friday, August 19. She replied that he wasn't in and would take care of it on Monday (08/22). On Monday I received an e-mail from Nikki that Cameron was not in the office and that she took it upon herself to read my correspondence and that any further communication should be with their lawyer, Steven Beckstrom, 1-435-634-1940.
I thought to myself, why is she getting so defensive if ESM had done nothing wrong?
So it is now Thursday, August 25. I have asked my bank in Colorado to send me the appropriate regulation E, dispute form/resolution request. I will be submitting these forms claiming fraud. I authorized charges to my account but never received what I paid for, customized proprietary software and tools. I have opened a case with the Utah Better Business Bureau and I have also posted this information on the web site: www.ripoffreport.com, for all to see.