I worked for the company as a seasonal employee and was very impressed with their customer service in handling any complaint. Any item received damaged was replaced NO questions asked and the attempt was to give the customer complete satisfaction.This service was given to both the buyer and recipient of any item.
This story does not ring true from what I witnessed in my month of seasonal work with the company. They have exceptional products and although it seems expensive at first glance, the abundant coupon deals providing everything from 25% off and free shipping provide a very convenient and quality gift giving/receiving experience. They have many loyal customers that shop by phone and online with them year after year and in doing so they avoid crowds, the hassle of the post office and get a great deal.
My only suggestion to the company would be to train their employees more thoroughly before they put them into action and pay them better so that they can retain a good core group of quality employees to help them achieve their mission. In doing that they might avoid what appears to be a rogue situation as described.