• Report: #279030

Complaint Review: Area Circulaion

Thank You

Read how Ripoff Report saves consumers millions.

  • Submitted: Tue, October 16, 2007
  • Posted: Sun, October 12, 2008

  • Reported By: Caramelcuteness — woodbridge Virginia U.S.A.
Area Circulaion
5656 Shell Rd Virginia Beach, Virginia U.S.A.

Area Circulation Tricked me talked way to fast! Won't let me cancel most importantly! Virginia Beach Virginia

*UPDATE EX-employee responds: Ex employee with the real scoop

*UPDATE EX-employee responds: Ex employee with the real scoop

*UPDATE Employee: glad you got service

*Author of original report: I got my money back!

*UPDATE Employee: 2nd response

*UPDATE Employee: Area Circulation Employee Response

*Author of original report: I made a mistake in my report!

What's this?
What's this?
What's this?
0Author 7Consumer 0Employee/Owner

Does your business have a bad reputation?
Fix it the right way.
Corporate Advocacy Program™

SEO Reputation Management
at its best!

I received a phone call on 10/16/07. The lady told me I had entered a contest sweepstakes and that I had won a 2 nights 3 day vacation to any city of my choice like palm springs, or cancun, etc. Then she said I would be in the contest where the winner walks away with $1,000,000.

The next part begins where I should have just hanged up quickly! She said she was calling from a company Area Circulation and she would do all this if I paid 2.99 a week, $74 for 12 months for some magazines like Glamour, Marie Claire, etc.! I said WOW! Okay $74 dollars a month is really nothing! She said every other customer she spoke to agreed with the offer. I'm very hesitant about offers like this, but these people really TRICKED ME GOOD! So I said, "OKAY," then she said can you verify your credit card information and birthdate. I gave her my debit card information. I told her my birth date. She said well, your only 20 years old, you have to be 21 and then she said well it's okay I'll put you on here that your 21. That was a red flag for me but I just ignored it.
If this would have been legitimate no one would've let me pass by due to my age.

Then she said she needed to transfer me to a supervisor to confirm the order. She told me to put in a good word for her. The supervisor came on and said that the first woman I was talking to was fairly new. To my impression the first woman I spoke to seemed very well spoken and didn't seem new to me whatsoever.

The supervisor revised everything with me and confirmed everything. She was speaking ridiculously fast that I couldn't keep up with what she was saying. She told me that they would charge $74 to my account right away. I said okay. In my head was saying to myself "okay I paid $74. I got that squared away. No more payments and I will receive my magazines and the trip" So I hung up with her.

I'm very curious so I googled Area Circulation and all I see is RipOff Report. So I click on it and read all these reports about what somewhat has happened to me in the conversation I had with these people. I quickly call the company back and I tell them that I want to cancel, and my tone is very nervous, scared, and angry. They quickly change the subject and say that they can lower my payments to 37.50. I tell them I want to cancel and they won't let me. This lady I spoke to named Pamela was so rude and she would hang up on me everytime. She told me I was selfish and I was playing games. As soon as I agreed again to the 37.50 she quickly changed to being nice.

I went to my bank and the lady there gave me a dispute form so I will fill that out. I'm very scared and I don't know what is going to happen because I don't want my name to go to the credit bureau and have it mess up my credit!

Maria
woodbridge, Virginia
U.S.A.

This report was posted on Ripoff Report on 10/16/2007 10:06 AM and is a permanent record located here: http://www.ripoffreport.com/r/Area-Circulaion/Virginia-Beach-Virginia-23455-3725/Area-Circulation-Tricked-me-talked-way-to-fast-Wont-let-me-cancel-most-importantly-Virg-279030. The posting time indicated is Arizona local time. Arizona does not observe daylight savings so the post time may be Mountain or Pacific depending on the time of year.

Ripoff Report has an exclusive license to this report. It may not be copied without the written permission of Ripoff Report.

Click Here to read other Ripoff Reports on Area Circulaion

Search for additional reports

If you would like to see more Rip-off Reports on this company/individual, search here:

Search Tips
Report & Rebuttal
Respond to this report!
What's this?
Also a victim?
What's this?
Repair Your Reputation!
What's this?
REBUTTALS & REPLIES:
0Author 7Consumer 0Employee/Owner
Updates & Rebuttals

#1 UPDATE EX-employee responds

Ex employee with the real scoop

AUTHOR: Cheritol28 - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Sunday, October 12, 2008
Call them and make a lawyer threat and they have to cancel your service. At that point I would request a full refund. Don't let them tell you anything else about doing a service inquiry or anything that they may offer. You want a full refund by credit card.
Respond to this report!
What's this?

#2 UPDATE EX-employee responds

Ex employee with the real scoop

AUTHOR: Cheritol28 - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Sunday, October 12, 2008
Call them and make a lawyer threat and they have to cancel your service. At that point I would request a full refund. Don't let them tell you anything else about doing a service inquiry or anything that they may offer. You want a full refund by credit card.
Respond to this report!
What's this?

#3 UPDATE Employee

glad you got service

AUTHOR: Burt With Area Circulation - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Monday, November 19, 2007
You didn't need the lawyers advice, as I explained we don't make money from unhappy customers, and in fact only make money from happy customers that renew.

You must still be convinced that we are not reliable, as you didn't respond to me as I requested, to help you with your situation. I've failed there, and am sorry to hear you believe we didn't want to help you.

We did, we do, and as I mentioned in my other replies, we didn't seek any action against you in the first place, but only wanted to help.

Remember, you hung up during the verification phase, where we make sure you understand everything, and make a recording that our QA people double check to make sure the sale went through properly.

That messed everything up... and when you didn't respond to me, I made sure our manager tried to find your account and fix it.

Anyone who has problems, as I said, is welcome to write to accountant@areacirculation.net and I'll take care of you. Please don't slip through the cracks.

Sincerely,

Burt Bellows
Area Circulation
Director of IT
Respond to this report!
What's this?

#4 Author of original report

I got my money back!

AUTHOR: Caramelcuteness - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Thursday, November 15, 2007
Well, since I work at a law firm I got a little bit of advice. I wrote Area Circulation a letter of cancellation telling them if they didn't cancel I would pursue further legal action. The bank somehow returned my money back and I changed my credit card number so that Area Circulation never ever tries to use that charge my account! I haven't received any phone calls or bills YET! I hope it stays this way!
Respond to this report!
What's this?

#5 UPDATE Employee

2nd response

AUTHOR: Burt With Area Circulation - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Thursday, November 15, 2007
I saw your 2nd response, and I see how this happened now. If you hung up you missed the 'verification' phase where we ask you to repeat back what you heard us say. We record that for legal reasons (to protect us, it's surprising how many people don't remember saying $74 per month for one year, but everyone does, or we explain it until they do understand and can repeat it).

Secondly, we did not report anything about your credit. You can get a free credit check online to help you sleep at night!

In this case we would have a good customer if these complaints didn't exist. That's why I'm replying...

Thanks again,


Burt Bellows
Respond to this report!
What's this?

#6 UPDATE Employee

Area Circulation Employee Response

AUTHOR: Burt With Area Circulation - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Thursday, November 15, 2007
Maria,

This is the second complaint I've seen that makes me very glad to rebut the complaints that scared you away from us. Please contact me and I'll personally explain everything to you.

Please read my generic reply below, but I wanted to say something personal to the people who were concinved we were scammers because other people accused us of that on the web.

We are for the first time repairing our web reputation, and if you read below you will get the full story.

Thank you!

Hello, I'm Burt Bellows, and I'm the Director of IT from Area Circulation.

My story is very simple in that while researching information to increase our web presence, I discovered some complaints that surprised me.

Our customer service department runs from a strict script like most telemarketing companies, because we have to make sure the govt. regulations aren't broken. How these complaints can occur is now an ongoing investigation in our company.

Some of the complaints I've read seemed very legitimate, but when reviewing the person's file, I have found things like, 'no contact with customer, they just stopped paying', or 'we cut payments by 75%', and things that didn't jive with the complaint. I'd like to find out the whole story and just fix it.

It seems most of these things can be fixed simply by communicating, so that's what we would like to offer.

I'm sorry this is a generic note, but after replying to 6 personally, I realized my IT network managing isn't getting the focus it deserves and requires, so I am making a generic request for contact via a special e-mail account I've set up.

accountant@areacirculation.net is the place to write to, and I will give you my personal attention. So far I've been able to fix everything in one day, but we are making huge changes in our infrastructure that require my attention, and are trying to expand our web presence. So please understand my time is limited, but I WILL get to everyone eventually.

If you don't mind, to help me keep track of e-mails, please put 'complaint' in the subject line so I can do searches and make sure I've gotten to everyone.

We handle hundreds of thousands of customers, and our goal is 100% satisfaction. But there is human error, or misunderstandings in that kind of volume, and apparently not everyone is getting the time and attention they should have.

So please let me fill in that gap and see what I can do to help you. One young man wrote to me yesterday, and I fixed him up in 5 minutes. We simply didn't have his cancellation form on record, and he was in the wrong queue. I can only assume it was our mistake, so I fixed it and canceled his account. He is quite happy and after hearing the deal we make in the e-mail, said he would consider doing this once he could afford it.

For those who were confused or did not understand how we work let me explain.

Our main 'deal' is awesome, but only if you can afford it! We don't want you to buy something you can't afford.

We offer 5 magazines per week, for 5 years, at a rate equal to $3.64 a week. At less than a dollar per mag for weekly mags (some are monthly, etc.), many people find this unbeatable. People Magazine, for instance, is $2 a week even for a direct subscription.

If you do the math, our deal is $900, compared to 5 magazines at $2, which would come to $2600. That's nearly triple our price.

Because we pay the magazine companies and our affiliates up front, we lose a lot of money when a customer 'buys' and then refuses to pay.

We literally don't make money on the initial sales. We try desperately to just break even.

The place we make money is where in renewing a HAPPY Customer, that wants to get in on things like the free tickets to London, Paris, etc., and wants to get an even better deal on magazines.

So for us to create complaining unhappy customers, makes no sense at all. We couldn't possibly make money. We would never have lasted 20 years.

But let me finish the math and describe where the greatest complaint seems to come in.

First, it takes 8-12 weeks to get the magazine's first delivery. We dislike that timeframe, but can't do anything about it. Many customers don't like paying a bill and seeing no results. They become worried they were scammed, cancel, and we lose money.

Secondly, we spend a great deal of effort explaining the math, but it doesn't always get past the simple $3.64 a week price.

That is the cost if you divide it up by week, but we can't get this super deal from the magazines and our affiliates without paying up front. So we invest a huge amount of money, trusting our customers to likewise fulfill their part of the bargain, paying off what we invested, within one year.

Since most people don't have $900 they want to put out initially for 5 years, we tell everyone that the cost is $74 per month for one year, and when we hear them agree to the deal, we transfer them to a verification department that tries to make this as clear as possible, by asking the person to repeat back to us the cost per month and other details such as the 8-12 week waiting period.

We record this, and I was very surprised to find that some customers called back saying they never agreed to it. We go at incredible lengths to make sure to repeat and even have our customers repeat it, that by far most people simply accept the deal and the only time we hear from them is when they want to change from one magazine to another (which is a FANTASTIC plus in working with us, you can change any time you like to any other magazine).

One other point to consider is that the credit card companies would not have kept us as customers if we didn't meet STRINGENT policies. True rip off companies lose their credit business within a year, usually less.

Feel free to write, I'm here and listening.

I am honored to work at Area Circulation, and I come from a background that does not stand for dishonesty or corruption.

Mistakes are made when you deal in hundreds of thousands of people. To those people that slipped through the cracks, we are sorry, and we are seeking to make things right.

We want you to be happy so you recommend us to your friends.

I am working on this, and will eventually answer, fix, and resolve every case. Reply back to me and you will get helped.

We risk a lot for our customers to get them a fantastic deal on magazines. Please understand we have no motivation whatsoever to rip you off. We simply don't make money until you are happy!

And we lose horribly when you are unhappy... so if you do the math you see why I am trying to fix all complaints, even though my main job here is IT in nature.

The owner was just shocked at these complaints and wants them fixed as soon as possible. Please help me by contacting me so we can make you happy.

Write to accountant@areacirculation.net, and I promise you I will get to you as soon as possible.

Burt Bellows
Area Circulation
Director of IT
Respond to this report!
What's this?

#7 Author of original report

I made a mistake in my report!

AUTHOR: Caramelcuteness - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Wednesday, October 17, 2007
I actually meant to type $74 a year! instead of $74 a month! oops
Respond to this report!
What's this?
Report & Rebuttal
Respond to this report!
What's this?
Also a victim?
What's this?
Repair Your Reputation!
What's this?

Advertisers above have met our
strict standards for business conduct.

judgments