• Report: #331907

Complaint Review: Combined Insurance Company Of America

Thank You

Read how Ripoff Report saves consumers millions.

  • Submitted: Sat, May 10, 2008
  • Updated: Thu, July 05, 2012

  • Reported By:Louisville Kentucky
Combined Insurance Company Of America
www.combinedinsurance.com Louisville, Kentucky U.S.A.

Combined Insurance Company Of America Don't become an agent of this company! Louisville Kentucky

*UPDATE EX-employee responds: Not the Devil just Morons

*UPDATE EX-employee responds: charles cachia

*UPDATE Employee: Not a bad company

*UPDATE EX-employee responds: DEALIN WITH THE DEVIL

What's this?
What's this?
What's this?
Is this
Ripoff Report
About you?
Ripoff Report
A business' first
line of defense
on the Internet.
If your business is
willing to make a
commitment to
customer satisfaction
Click here now..

Does your business have a bad reputation?
Fix it the right way.
Corporate Advocacy Program™

SEO Reputation Management at its best!

I interviewed in the city where I live with the District Manager and Regional Manager at a Hotel. They told me that I would be selling their insurance policies to new and existing policy holders. They told me the income figures for agents at each level of the organization. They were fairly impressive. I specifically asked them how much travel was involved with the job and whether I could work mostly in and around the city where I lived. They said I would mostly be working in the city where I lived and that there wasn't much travel involved.

For my second interview I rode with the District Manager in a fairly rural area far from where I lived. He didn't sell anything, but mostly renewed existing policies, from which he received a 14% commission. He ended up making about $150 dollars that day, and I figured that was pretty good for an off day. I figured most days would be better than that.

I got the job and went to licensing and sales training the next week. It was 2 weeks of licensing training and one week of sales training. They put me and all the other trainees up at a pretty decent hotel in a large city which was the divisional headquarters. They paid for lodging and food, but I still had to pay for the gas to make the 6 hour roundtrip each week between the training and my home city. After the licensing training, which was pretty top notch (I aced the licensing test in like 15 minutes) the sales training began. They taught us the sales presentation, which we were just supposed to read and the close: "so...if you don't mind... I'd like to write it for you...too...may I do that for you? They even taught us what they called the McCabe nod (invented by a successful agent who would nod his head on the close-pretty creepy)

Then came the high pressure part which made me feel uncomfortable. They taught us that pretty much everyone says no after the close. They taught us to memorize ver batim the response for every reason they could possibly give for not wanting the policy. You're not supposed to take no for an answer. At least 3 responses should be given before giving up.

So after I passed the test I had a few days off before starting my first week in the field. To my shock I would be spending my first entire week in a medium small city 3 hours away from where I lived. I only found this out a day and a half before I was supposed to be down there. They put all the agents and managers up in a hotel where we would stay for the week. Every morning there was an hour of sales training for the agents and then out into the field to work in pairs agents with managers. I put in like 60 hours that first week and only made about $350 dollars. I had to split the income that my manager and me earned. Little did I know that that would be the most I would make in one single week my entire time at the company.

I was tired after my first week. Putting in 10-12 hour days and then having to sleep on a hotel bed in the same room with a guy that snores loud takes its toll on you. Some time towards the middle of that first week in the middle of nowhere (let's just say it was very mountainous and there was little to no economic activity except coal) my manager suggested that I should spend the next week on the road again in a similar setting.

First he suggested and then he basically told me I had to. This despite what he had told me in the first interview that I would mostly be working in and around my own city. For the short time I was with the company I split time between spending entire weeks working in remote rural areas far from my home and working out of my home city, but having to work in areas that were 1-4 hour round trips from my home city. This is what pissed me off the most about this company. They flat out lied to my face about a deal breaker issue: travel. Despite specifically asking about how much travel was expected I didn't find out until my second week in the field how much of the job was traveling and staying in sub-standard rural motels for a week at a time.

But by that point I had already put 3 weeks training in and quit my old job. Plus I didn't want to put on my resume that I quit this job without giving it a shot. That looks horrible on a resume. At the same time I never would have taken the job if I'd known about the travel. I found out about a month in that most of my training class mates had already quit. The few agents there were in my district quit by my third month in. They were smarter than me.

Gas was about 40% cheaper than it is now, but still gas expenses cut deeply into what little amount of money I was making selling and renewing. I can't imagine how new agents could possibly survive now that gas is pushing $4 a gallon. I wasn't very good at selling, so I guess my poor income was partially due to my lack of aptitude for selling, but then again my manager didn't train me very well. He spent all kinds of time recruiting new agents to replace the ones that quit.

My last week in the field I spent in a remote area that was a 6 hour (cost me about $50) round trip from where I live. I worked 60 hours that week and made an income of about $100. That was a net profit of $50 for 60 hours of work. One of the new agents, who was so new that she still had the bs cult like enthusiasm that they put into us in training school, told me that she actually lost money that week after gas expenses. She worked more hours than I did, but she was undeterred. She was gonna give it another try the next week for her little girl, who was probably at home wondering where her mommy had been all week.

I often wondered how anyone could make money at this job. I asked my manager about the income structure, but he was evasive as usual. He spoke little, and what I could get out of him was mostly lies and half truths. I asked some of the more forthcoming managers why I should keep working for the company if I wasn't making much money. When I phrased it like that they told me about the incentive system.

Once you sell enough policies and get your awards knocked out you become Sales Manager. SM's, on top of their commissions, get a percentage of the income of their district and what's called overrides. When a policy is sold a small chunk of the selling agent's commission is held back and put in an account. When policy holders cancel their policies money is withdrawn from the override account of the agent that sold the policy, and I guess that money goes to the company. When a policy stays on the books for a certain period of time the override that was put away for that policy gets withdrawn and becomes a part of the income of the District where it was sold no matter whether the agent who sold it still works there.

Considering the high rate of turnover at Combined, I would guess that a significant chunk of the income of any given District Manager, Sales Manager, or Regional Manager comes from overrides from policies sold by people that are no longer with the company.

Even an inept salesman's policy has as good a chance of staying on the books as one sold by a veteran because those premiums that don't come straight from the policy holders bank account are collected in person by agents. What if the policy holder doesn't want to renew when the agent comes to collect? They got renewal responses too. Most people don't want to stand there and argue with you. They just write the check.

The people who can sell and put up with the bs for the longest time do get well compensated. Regional Managers especially got the cush jobs. They don't even have to go out and sell, but they make 6 figures cause they've put in the work. Those people who are lied to and made to think that they can sell when they have no aptitude for it don't last, but it's no skin off the Company's back. Agents are paid no salary or compensation for gas. They are paid on commission only.

All the time you are doing the company's bidding renewing existing policies in person to make sure people don't cancel and selling the occasional policy. Even people who lack selling skill run into the occasional sale ass backwards. The Company will hire anyone who can pass a background check and the licensing test, which they make you study like hell for to make sure you pass.

Like I said, the main reason I feel ripped off is that I was lied to about travel. I also wish I had been told about how few new agents actually have what it takes to get into management and make the real money. If you can sell a ketchup pop sickle to a woman in white gloves and don't mind lots of travel to remote areas, then you can make a lot of money at Combined. Most people just don't fit this description and thus shouldn't bother.

Anonymous
Louisville, Kentucky
U.S.A.

Click here to read other Rip Off Reports on Combined Insurance

This report was posted on Ripoff Report on 05/10/2008 05:57 PM and is a permanent record located here: http://www.ripoffreport.com/r/Combined-Insurance-Company-Of-America/Louisville-Kentucky-40218/Combined-Insurance-Company-Of-America-Dont-become-an-agent-of-this-company-Louisville-Ke-331907. The posting time indicated is Arizona local time. Arizona does not observe daylight savings so the post time may be Mountain or Pacific depending on the time of year.

Ripoff Report has an exclusive license to this report. It may not be copied without the written permission of Ripoff Report.

Click Here to read other Ripoff Reports on Combined Insurance Company Of America

Search for additional reports

If you would like to see more Rip-off Reports on this company/individual, search here:

Search Tips
Report & Rebuttal
Respond to this report!
What's this?
Also a victim?
What's this?
Repair Your Reputation!
What's this?
REBUTTALS & REPLIES:
0Author 4Consumer 0Employee/Owner
Updates & Rebuttals

#1 UPDATE EX-employee responds

Not the Devil just Morons

AUTHOR: Anyways11 - (USA)

I wouldnt call Combined Insurance the Devil. I would say their employees are morons who can't think for themselves, thus the MCCabe nod (no insurance agent in their right mind uses it) PMA (every good agent has it otherwise they are out of a job of course you don't need to be reminded of it every 10 seconds) and of course let's not forget Clement Stone (stealing everything he could including other people's sayings).

Yup, Combined Insurance is the butt end of most jokes my colleagues talk about in sales meetings at real insruance companies selling real products to people who can afford it. Probably why there aren't 103 bad reports on this site about us with 103 + rebuttals by employees who were probably ordered to do so by management. Pathetic company with pathetic losers in it. Feel much better you're no longer there.
Respond to this report!
What's this?

#2 UPDATE EX-employee responds

charles cachia

AUTHOR: worldcloser - (Australia)

I'm sorry to hear about your bad experience with Combined Insurance Company of America. I worked for Combined in Sydney, Australia, in the 70's. I experienced similar challenges as you at the beginning. It wasn't easy. The difference is, I persisted with them, and earned a good income for the ten years that I was with them. More importantly, with their training and motivation, I developed into one of the best salesman in this country. Their training was exceptional. I owe all of my sales success to them. I take my hat off to them. My name is Charles Cachia, I am proud to say I was associated with them.
Respond to this report!
What's this?

#3 UPDATE Employee

Not a bad company

AUTHOR: Kevin - (U.S.A.)

I have worked for combined for about a month, I also had to get my licenses, and Combined taught me how to get them. I also passed first time. I am 42 and done automotive all my professional career, since I was 18. For me to learn this new trade was very hard. Combined has done what they promised me. DO NOT LISTEN TO ALL THE LIES OTHERS ARE SAYING. Combined is a great company to work for, if you put the work into it, you get rewards. I am making more then I have ever made. Yes gas is a issue, put then you sell more or collect more premiums. Any job will reward you if you put the time and work ethics into it. PMA positive mental attitude is the company's motto and it is a way of life also. I have nothing but good to say about the company and any one else that says other wise is totally wrong.
Respond to this report!
What's this?

#4 UPDATE EX-employee responds

DEALIN WITH THE DEVIL

AUTHOR: Dablues - (U.S.A.)

I am really surprised that you made it all with the interview process after the COMBINED DEVIL INSURANCE COMPANY was sold to ACE INS. CO. There is no peace or goodwill any where in this company at this time, only egotistical cult leaders with hell bent ways of brain-washing the AMERICAN PUBLIC that answer some ad in a newspaper....should be out-lawed and an immediate sentence to a chain gang for anyone stupid enough to still be trying to hire someone to this DEVIL company all in the idea of being an "insurance agent"... what kind of "insurance agent/mgr" really needs to scam a hotel lobby out of their facilities for interviews, McDonalds as a "meeting" site, etc. (just a bunch of damn leaches)
Respond to this report!
What's this?
Report & Rebuttal
Respond to this report!
What's this?
Also a victim?
What's this?
Repair Your Reputation!
What's this?

Advertisers above have met our
strict standards for business conduct.



Ripoff Report Legal Directory