• Report: #1054015

Complaint Review: Flatbush Addiction Treatment Center - Unethical Practices

  • Submitted: Sun, May 26, 2013
  • Updated: Tue, July 01, 2014

  • Reported By: CivilRights718 — Brooklyn New York
Flatbush Addiction Treatment Center - Unethical Practices
1463 Flatbush Ave Brooklyn, NY 11210 brooklyn, New York USA

Flatbush Addiction Treatment Center Unethical Practices Flatbush Addiction Treatment Center Unethical Practices brooklyn New York

*Consumer Comment: FATC is one of the most ethical and helpful organizations that anyone could hope to find

What's this?
What's this?
What's this?
Is this
Ripoff Report
About you?
Ripoff Report
A business' first
line of defense
on the Internet.
If your business is
willing to make a
commitment to
customer satisfaction
Click here now..

Does your business have a bad reputation?
Fix it the right way.
Corporate Advocacy Program™

SEO Reputation Management at its best!

Catholic Charities Flatbush Addiction Treatment Center - Unethical Practices

 I am one of the many victims of Catholic Charities Flatbush Addiction Treatment Center. May 23rd, 2013 I have witnessed several lives including my own being put at jeopardy and strain by Gene Kemmer for profits by the so called non profit organization.

 My story is no other than the ones I have heard today; except I noticed the pattern and others have not until we began to discuss our current situations.

 On May 2nd of 2013 I had been pulled over by the 63rd precinct. As the police officers began to interrogate everyone in the car they were in unpleasantly surprised to find nothing.  At the last point, they decided to present me with a breathalyzer test. After all the hassle they have put me through, I simply refused it as it was given to me as an option. Being a United States citizen of America, I have the right to refuse it and hire an attorney to defend me.

 At the time of court, the judge  suspended my driving privileges in the state of New York. Additionally, the judge mandated an alcohol and substance abuse screening or better known as assessment. This is all standard for New York City.

 At the end of the court date, I was given paperwork that included a toll free number in assistance of obtaining a local “assessment” facility. The judge has given me a deadline date of the 10th of May.  That is a total of 5 days after the court date. I have immediately called the toll free number on the 3rd and was given a contact to Catholic Charities Flatbush Addiction Treatment Center. I constantly repeated myself stating that I need an assessment immediately in request of the judge. They completely did not care and advised me that the only date available was 16th of May. I called my lawyer and he advised me that he would present this information during next court date.

 After patiently waiting for the big “assessment” day, I arrived at a dingy second floor place on Flatbush Avenue in Brooklyn where I met Gene Kemmer. His first question was how are you paying and cash is preferred. When I replied that I have insurance he took my card and was extremely glad to hear that they are in the “network” with my insurance company. This means guaranteed payment. After a few minutes of conversation he scrabbled and had the front desk find necessary paperwork for what he called “abuse screening.”

 We began the screening with varies questions of background, past, pastime (hobbies), personal interests, and yes how often I drink, weather or not I do drugs. After replying to all the questions with “I have had a normal and fulfilled childhood, in college, have not nor do I plan on doing drugs” the screening was done. At the end of the question assessment, he calculated all my responses in a point table, which showed “zero.” This means that I am not even close to any sort of abuse whatsoever. Furthermore, after the verbal screening Gene has presented me with urine test, which also reflected no abuse of any substance.

 On the 21st of May, I have filled out all the necessary documentation for the reclaim of my seized vehicle. Immediately day after, Gene Kemmer called me his standardized sales pitch. The conversation began professional with him stating his name and organization followed by, “your urine results have come back negative and you have passed the verbal assessment. However, your court date is a month away and we still have time. We have had a meeting about your case and our staff is recommending and mandating abuse treatment.” My only response was WHAT? What treatment if my urine is absolutely clean, as I do not do drugs or drink. Additionally my scorecard for the verbal “screening” was “assessed” to zero. I immediately asked to speak to a supervisor or who ever is “recommending” substance abuse treatment. Gene’s response was to try to tell me that I can only make an appointment for the following end of week.  That was not an option I was willing to take. I pressured until he gave me an appointment for the following day (May 23rd).

 The following day, I arrived at the appointed date and time, I asked for a supervisor, by no surprise no one to speak to at the present time. I asked for a name and business card, the response I received was “the supervisor does not have a business card but her name is Sarah Suman.”

 While I waited to speak to someone to explain how they “assessed” my case to mandate a substance abuse treatment program I have seen Francis John Capalbo run into an office directly next to the waiting room to give the same exact sales pitch I have hear one day prior. His words have been verbatim of “all has been passed, however we recommend treatment and will state that on paperwork to court.” The gentlemen that sat closer to the door just started smiling and said “that’s funny because this is exactly what I heard three weeks ago and the judge sent me in for treatment.”

 At this point, I just said to myself I resent my case. Catholic Charities Flatbush Addiction Treatment Center is practicing unethically.

 Within a few minutes later, Gene Kemmer approaches me with a smile on his face congratulating me for arriving on time as if he expected or hoped for me not to arrive on time to dodge having to explain his sales pitch again.

 As soon as we walked into his office, his first question of “so how can I help you,” sounded as if he was startle and shocked that for the first time someone actually stood up for themselves and questioned their unethical practices.

 I began to question how, who and reason for my case to be classified as a mandatory substance treatment program. He carefully reworded it to “you have an option of not attending.” However, this assessment is sent to coust and the judge will view it, as “needs treatment,” nothing less thus will be mandated at next court date. I repeated myself asking how they came to the conclusion and what bases they had to request a “substance abuse treatment” from court. Gene Kemmer’s response was “first due to the fact that you declined the breathalyzer and secondly due to the fact that the police officer stated you have exceeded the speed limit.”

 In response to both of these professional reasons; I am classified as an individual that needs treatment for substance abuse due to speeding and practicing my legal right of refusing a breathalyzer? I was pulled over at a red light in justification to speeding and was never issued a summons for speeding. Even if I have exceeded the speed limit, how does that factor into a reason for substance abuse treatment, on which grounds? As for refusing the breathalyzer, I as an American citizen of the United States of America have the legal right to refuse it for any personal reason.

 The verbal examination that has been presented by the State of New York, which Gene Kemmer has assessed me by, has shown no treatment is necessary.  Additionally, my urine results have shown no substance whatsoever.

 Catholic Charities Flatbush Addiction Treatment Center is manipulating the perfected fraudulent scheme. They are using the force of New York State judicial system to gain revenues while harming the public for their own financial benefit.

 Easy two step process Catholic Charities Flatbush Addiction Treatment Center follows:

A)   Give a later assessment date to violate the judge’s request of a specific date

B)   Regardless, of urine and written/verbal screening, everyone at this organization is trained to the sales pitch.

C)   Then they fax the paperwork to the DA stating that “substance abuse treatment” is required.


This report was posted on Ripoff Report on 05/26/2013 03:39 PM and is a permanent record located here: http://www.ripoffreport.com/r/Flatbush-Addiction-Treatment-Center-Unethical-Practices/brooklyn-New-York-11210/Flatbush-Addiction-Treatment-Center-Unethical-Practices-Flatbush-Addiction-Treatment-Cen-1054015. The posting time indicated is Arizona local time. Arizona does not observe daylight savings so the post time may be Mountain or Pacific depending on the time of year.

Ripoff Report has an exclusive license to this report. It may not be copied without the written permission of Ripoff Report.

Click Here to read other Ripoff Reports on Flatbush Addiction Treatment Center - Unethical Practices

Search for additional reports

If you would like to see more Rip-off Reports on this company/individual, search here:

Search Tips
Report & Rebuttal
Respond to this report!
What's this?
Also a victim?
What's this?
Repair Your Reputation!
What's this?
0Author 1Consumer 0Employee/Owner
Updates & Rebuttals

#1 Consumer Comment

FATC is one of the most ethical and helpful organizations that anyone could hope to find

AUTHOR: Rescue2 - ()

First off let me ssy the the person making the complaint sounds bitter and angry for being ticketed by the police. Wheter or not you were speeding or drinking no one will eer know except yourself. You are correct in stating that you have a right to refuse a breathalyzer test however you should also be aware that refusal to submit to a breathalyzer is by law an automatic failure of the test. This was your choice. FATC, Catholic Charities  or any other organization that deals with substance abuse has no ability whatsoever to mandate anyone to anything at all. Your mandation was a result of a decision of the court based on your refusal to submit to the breatalyzer. The intake interview given by Mr. Kemmer who is a consumate professional may very well have shown no substance abuse tendencies. However no matter what was in contained in your assessment in the eyes of NYS DMV and the courts by law you were under the influence while operating a motor vehicle. If you opted to take the breath test that would have been the end of the story. Gene Kemmer and Sara Suman are total professionals in their field. They do not make more money by increasing the number of clients at FATC, they only increase their workload. Mr Kemmer was most likely glad for YOU that your insurance was accepted as that saved you out of pocket expenses. It is the rare client of FATC that pays cash and I have to doubt the veracity of your statement "cash is preferred".  In NY state all people who are guilty of DUI (which you were by failing to take the test) are mandated into an abuse program. We all make choices and must live with the consequences. Your choice was not to take the test. FATC had nothing to do with that choice. You also had the option of not attending the program. No one forced you to. FATC has saved dozens of people's lives including my own by the services that they provide and Mr. Kemmer is one of their most experienced counselours. Why did you refuse the breathalyzer? why are you so angry at FATC for a decision made by you and the courts? Maybe next time if you actually are sober you will opt to take the test. Ms. Suman, Mr. Capalbo. Mr. Kemmer and the other CASAC and LMSW workers at FATC work for so little money because they actually care. Man up and live with the results of the choices that you and only you made. FATC is a blessing to those who need help.....including assistance with anger management. And for the last time they have no power whatsoever to mandate treatment....they come into the picture after you have been mandated by the courts. They are an up and up honest and wonderful group of people. I know this personally.

Respond to this report!
What's this?
Report & Rebuttal
Respond to this report!
What's this?
Also a victim?
What's this?
Repair Your Reputation!
What's this?