Hawaiian Airlines HawaiianMiles Hawaiian Airlines canceled upgrade behind my back reversing HawaiianMiles transaction Honolulu, Hawaii

I did read the report and I agree that you have a reason to be upset. We will never know why a reservation confirmation that clearly stated "First" was cancelled by a manager and the airline obviously won't tell you the name of the manager. I'm sure that First became full though and it would be interesting to know just how many seats were filled with upgrades. The refusal of the airline to assign a seat however would bother me.

I doubt seriously that Hawaiian or any other airline holds out as many as 4 seats in First for upgrade passengers but that is just supposition.

I've always liked Hawaiian for its customer service, in flight amenities and general friendliness. I have Hawaiian Miles but it is probably stupid because we only fly to Hawaii every couple of years. I guess judging from your experience that Hawaiian is getting to be like all the rest of the airlines.

Karl, I am under the impression that you did not read the report: this was about an upgrade, not the initial reservation. We both had valid, confirmed reservations and one segment was upgraded after I called HA. When I printed the reservation out after having requested the upgrade it was clearly showing "First" for the segment HNL - PHX. At no point in time I was told "this is a standby upgrade ...

if we find a cashpayer we will kick your fiancee back into economy". I have never seen something like that and several supervisors were totally confused about what happened. A supervisor at the HNL airport printed out the complete booking records and she was only able to explain to us that a manager had reversed the upgrade. She did not mention anything like "Sorry, your upgrade was reversed because it was only conditional ..."

Any reputable airline would have disclosed their actions, especially at the point were the upgrade was reversed. Hawaiian Airlines had our email addresses and the manager could at least have informed us about what he did. Obviously he did not even leave a note for other airline employees in the records that's why we are under the impression that he needed the First Class seat for his brother in law or his baseball buddy. A note like "Upgrade reversal because seat was needed for employee family member" would not look that good, so probably he just preferred not to leave any explanations at all.

I've been flying for more than 50 years and I discovered early on that if you don't have a specific seat assignment you aren't guaranteed to go on the flight regardless of what some clerk tells you on the phone. Probably First was sold out when you made the reservation and the airline hoped that everybodywouldn't show up. If First was light when you called you probably would have gotten a specific seat number.

It may not be called "standby" but what it means when you are told that a seat will be assigned at the airportis that the flight was oversold andyour ability to get on that flight depends on how many people who have assigned seats don't show up. The airline will tell you not to worry -that you are guaranteed to be on that flight -but when the flight is full you will be apologized to and will recieve a "free" ticket plus a seat on the next flight -perhaps even an upgrade.

Of course your "free" ticket is capacity controlled which means that it will never be available for use. In the case of the Honolulu-Phoenix flight the next flight is the next day so you were lucky that coach was available. ALWAYS get an assigned seat number when flying or take another airline that can give you one if you MUST fly on a certain day. Don't believe what some clerk tells you on the phone.

I'd like to see a response from Hawaiian concerning the "4 seats always held" in First. If Hawaiian can sell a seat they will just like everybody else. When I recieve the "your seat will be assigned at the airport" bullshit I pick another flight where I can get an assigned seat -a real seat -22A, 4B etc.

All of the airlines seem to make it as difficult as possible to use FF miles. I once spent 2 hours on the phone with American trying to use miles for a trip to Hawaii. Nothing available on any flight or any connection from March to October (I gave up then). Back in the '80's I didn't have much problem getting a seat but now it is really hit and miss. I'm sure that a seat is available on the 10 PM flight from Detroit to Chicago but forget about any tourist destinations. Sorry you had a problem but Hawaiian was probably full in First and you got put into coach. You are lucky coach wasn't full. At least you got to travel alongside your fiancee (I hope).

As a result I don't bother with FF miles anymore except for Southwest which according to a poll lets you use the free flight 97% of the time. As I recall some airlines were as little as 17%. If you ever decide to give up a seat ALWAYS take the $200 or $300 rebate for your next trip. NEVER take a "free" flight coupon.  You will never get to use it. Your flight will always be non-available.