Wasatchcoin.com Jeremy Carr Jeremy stole my returned Gold coin Clearfield Utah

I purchased a high end 2015-W 100 dollar Gold Liberty PCGS MS70 High Relief coin from coin dealer Jeremy Carr from Wasatchcoin.com on about 8/25/15 for $1,950.00. I checked out the coin and I noticed all this funny mold dot build up on the inside reverse of the plastic slab holder plus 2 large dots on the coin itself. I returned the coin to Jeremy after he told me that he would swap it with PCGS whom graded the coin and to just send it back to him. I then returned it using USPS mail with this tracking number 9500 1111 8511 5265 3513 90. After a few days I emailed Jeremy asking him how is he making out with the swap. Jeremy then said " what are you talking about I never received the coin in his mail PO Box. Tracking and his post office claim that they handed Jeremy my package over the counter. Jeremy told me that he had his Post office look all over for my return package and even told me that maybe one of their clerks put it in their pocket. I called John the Post Office manager at  801-779-2347  and he told me that Jeremy received my package over the counter and my package did not fit into any PO box like Jeremy said it should have been in and he also said the post office might have put it in the wrong PO Box. My package was given to him over the counter in a white plasic tote box. Because I didn't have Jeremy sign for it he is pulling a fast one on me and saying that he never received it. Jeremy even wants me to buy more and more coins from him to make it up to me. Now I just either want the bad looking gold coin or a refund. Jerremy refuses to do anything but lie about this whole thing that he never got the package. The package was delivered to him. Jerremy is acting like a big jerk changing his stories around and acting very imature and now just deleting my emails. He doesn't have his phone number listed on his web site. His email is jeremy@wasatchcoin.com. I have just reported him not only to the Better Business Bureau but to his local police dectectives to investigate him. Jeremy also is a dealer name in Ebay where he sells coins. Please beware of this big phony crook liar. Jeremy also keeps changing his story to me in all his nervous email writing. I must take him to small claims court also. Sorry I dealt with this funny duck.