Report: #1487965

Complaint Review: Law Office of Barton R. Resnicoff - Lake Success NY

  • Submitted:
  • Updated:
  • Reported By: Dan — Lake Success NY United States
  • Law Office of Barton R. Resnicoff 3000 Marcus Avenue, Suite 3W2 Lake Success, NY United States

Law Office of Barton R. Resnicoff Bart Resnicoff gave me false legal advice as to how to retain legal custody of my children. He missed court appointments and conferences to the detriment of my children and I. He was a terrible advocate for my family. Lake Success NY

*Consumer Comment: Bart Resnicoff Wasted my Money, Mishandled my Case, Dishonest

*REBUTTAL Individual responds: Bart Resnicoff Ripped me Off, Lied, was Negligent, and provided Poor Advice

*Consumer Comment: Divorce Isn't Cheap

Show customers why they should trust your business over your competitors...

Is this
Report about YOU
listed on other sites?
Those sites steal
Ripoff Report's
We can get those
removed for you!
Find out more here.
How to fix
Ripoff Report
If your business is
willing to make a
commitment to
customer satisfaction
Click here now..

Barton Resnicoff Bart Resnicoff BARTON R RESNICOFF PC Barton Robin Resnicoff Resnicoff Barton Barton R Resnicoff Resnicoff Bart Barton R. Resnicoff Law Bart Resnicoff Family Law Barton R. Resnicoff Divorce Attorney The Law Office of Barton R. Resnicoff bartonresnicofflaw bartonresnicofflaw.com Registration Number 1430149 Barton R. Resnicoff Matrimonial and Family Law Barton Resnicoff Family Law Trial Specialist

Bart Resnicoff offered a free consultation regarding my divorce and child custody case where he told me that his many years in family law, especially representing fathers, made him an excellent legal advocate for me. He lured me in and I took his bait. I told him that I cannot afford his rate ($500 at that time). He said he would lower and keep his hourly rate at $350 per hour and would only charge me a $5000 retainer.  He burned through that 5000 dollars in just two weeks.

His statement showed many charges so it was hard to single out an odd off-hour charge. It later became clear that he was delegating his work to underlings. That explained how I was being charged for legal expenses at a time that he was unavailable due to getting medical treatment.

When I asked him for advice, based on his years of experience settling legal family matters out of court, on how to persuade my wife and her attorney on easing up on some of the time restrictions I have with my kids, Bart told me that I should hire a private investigator. With the help of Bart's office, I was printing out all correspondences I had with my then-wife, and collecting what the private investigator was giving us. I told Bart that I would go through the materials on my own because I couldn't afford his firm to do it.

I pointed out a number of inconsistencies between my wife's words and actions. Bart said he knew what to do with it. She was horrified and angered. Matters escalated when she responded by hiring another private investigator. Debts accrued. I barely saw my kids anymore.

Finally...Bart advises me it is time to cool things down and negotiate. I was back to where I started - but just poorer and estranged from my kids. Now, Mr. Resnicoff is gone. He has left a heap of financial damage, debt, and very limited visitations (less than in the beginning) with my kids. The way Bart advised me to escalate matters with a private investigator has now, that the hearings are over, there is complete and utter distrust with the co-parent of my kids. I regret ever walking into Bart Resnicoff's office for that initial consultation.

This report was posted on Ripoff Report on 11/18/2019 01:29 PM and is a permanent record located here: https://www.ripoffreport.com/report/law-office-barton-r-resnicoff/lake-success-ny-esnicf-esnicf-1487965. The posting time indicated is Arizona local time. Arizona does not observe daylight savings so the post time may be Mountain or Pacific depending on the time of year. Ripoff Report has an exclusive license to this report. It may not be copied without the written permission of Ripoff Report. READ: Foreign websites steal our content

Search for additional reports

If you would like to see more Rip-off Reports on this company/individual, search here:

Report & Rebuttal
Respond to this report!
What's this?
Also a victim?
What's this?
Repair Your Reputation!
What's this?

Updates & Rebuttals


#3 Consumer Comment

Bart Resnicoff Wasted my Money, Mishandled my Case, Dishonest

AUTHOR: Jessica - (United States)

POSTED: Wednesday, November 27, 2019

Divorce lawyer, Barton R. Resnicoff Esq, made me feel at ease when he heard my dire situation and promised me results. He went on and on about life lessons and similar cases to mine that he supposedly had in the past.  After he received his retainer, his demeanor and approach changed drastically.  He was very difficult to reach on the phone or email and returned my messages very late. 

He initially advised me not to agree to a settlement agreement while making a plan to threaten to go to trial, and then receiving a better deal from the settlement.  This assinine plan backfired and we ended up in court. 

Bart forgot numerous times to file information with the court and made us look like complete idiots in front of the judge and my ex.  My ex and his lawyer took advantage of my having hired the fraudulent Barton Resnicoff as my hairy nose in the air lawyer.  It was too late to fire Bart and I realized that I would have to revisit my case later on with a decent attorney.

If I knew that Bart Resnicoff would be a foul-mouthed dishonest Scrooge that would so badly handle my case, I would have represented myself, taken the settlement and saved a great deal of precious time with my children, assets, and the ability to move on with my life sooner.

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#2 REBUTTAL Individual responds

Bart Resnicoff Ripped me Off, Lied, was Negligent, and provided Poor Advice

AUTHOR: Dan - (United States)

POSTED: Friday, November 22, 2019

Divorce is not cheap but it does not need to bankrupt you and make you complete enemies with the other parent of your children.  About half of marriages end in divorce.  You do not need to have extreme animosity after you were unable to altogether cohabit AND be intimate, AND share all assets AND agree with most matters.  Your personal experience, Jim, is not representative of all divorced or unmarried parents or co-parents.  Yes, people can maturely co-parent children with an ex-spouse or former partner.  However, that relationship can be immensely shaped for a long period of time by the manner in which custody was resolved and how shared possessions were apportioned. 

The main reason I arrived at this understanding was when our case was revisited.  I hired an attorney who had comparable credentials and length of experience but was more rational and realistic about negotiating outcomes for custody and assets.  She told me what it was to "fight the good fight" in legal maneuvers and how much each "fight" would cost.  At that point, the animosity between my ex-spouse and I was even worse than immediately after our divorce.  However, this more diplomatic approach ended up in a settlement in, which neither of us was happy, but we were content.  Yes, the way you end things matters.  Two people who were married, but especially two people who share children must end a marriage in a way that they can parent their children and move on with their lives. 

This is why I wish that the unrealistic, aloof and aggressive, and irresponsible original attorney, Bart Resnicoff, never represented me for monetary assets and MOST IMPORTANTLY: MY CHILDREN.

Barton Resnicoff knew of my assets, earnings, and my BUDGET for this case.  I told Bart Resnicoff my budget at the beginning of every conversation in person, on the phone, and email.  I asked for the amount I owed and he would brush it off, telling me that someone else in his firm would give me an updated statement, which took a great deal of time.  The statements I did receive appeared to have many discrepancies with reality when I would end up having to show evidence several times to his own firm that I could not have had a conversation in person with him when I was not on the same continent with Barton Resnicoff at the time.  He did not individualize my legal strategy numerous times when I told him what the range of my end goals were and the means I had to achieve.  Despite knowing my monetary constraints, he put me on an aggressive scorched earth legal strategy.

Bart Resnicoff was a cold, untruthful, incompetent, aloof, aggressive, untrustworthy legal representative whose traits I learned years after my divorce.

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#1 Consumer Comment

Divorce Isn't Cheap

AUTHOR: Jim - (United States)

POSTED: Monday, November 18, 2019

It's pretty expensive and in a divorce situation, there is only one loser.  In this case, that was you.  It seemed very clear to me, just based on what you wrote, that the lawyer you hired was aggressive.  In some divorce cases, an aggressive lawyer is a good thing. 

The strategy he carried out was consistent with that philosophy.  The problem wasn't with your attorney.  The problem was with your ex-wife.  Had you chosen an attorney who was less aggressive, you'd likely be in the same situation. 

You cannot look at a divorce with a what-if attitude.  Had the PI found evidence that your wife placed your children in some danger, then you could argue for greater custody using the PI's report as an example.  Simple inconsistencies between word and action aren't worth bringing up in the first place simply because such inconsistencies don't result in increased visitation for you. 

You didn't want to have the lawyer go through the papaerwork because of the rate he charged.  However, that would have been money well spent had you done so.

The way Bart advised me to escalate matters with a private investigator has now, that the hearings are over, there is complete and utter distrust with the co-parent of my kids.  Yeah, well, had you decided to have the firm go through the report, it is more than likely the attorney may not have seen fit to go through with confronting your wife's attorney about the PI's report.  However, you should also know that's the way a divorce generally goes, regardless of whether you chose this attorney, or someone else, PI, or not. 

Finally, she isn't a co-parent either; that is a ridiculous term I wish people would bury!  She is your ex-wife who will have primary custody of the kids.  You will never earn any trust with her, again, regardless of what happened.  Treasure the time you have with your kids and do right by them.  If you do, they won't resent the time you couldn't be with them.  Trust me, I know.

Respond to this report!
What's this?

Advertisers above have met our
strict standards for business conduct.

What do hackers,
questionable attorneys and
fake court orders have in common?
...Dishonest Reputation Management Investigates Reputation Repair
Free speech rights compromised

Segment Now