Enchanted Ridge Min Pins - Anna Goodnoe A variation of the baby adoption scams This breeder leads families on and then breaks their hearts Mekinock North Dakota

Another one Anna? And you say you don't breed often at all, only when you have people on your waiting list on this quality minpins page at a dot com. Isn't this a NEW procedure for your breeding practices? I will admit that on a different page, the home page, you say this is a new practice as of 2009. You do provide a different impression on the upcoming litter pages though. Wow Anna. Do you provide an individual health check for each puppy which indicates that the vet has examined the Heart, Lungs, Eyes, Joints, Ears and Skin/Coat and what they found signed by the vet aside from the health certificate? A puppy will pass for a health certificate if anything found is not contagious, is not clinically ill or is not likely to kill the puppy during the traveling generally. Passing for a health certificate does not mean that no problems were found during an exam, just not ones that. Health certificates do not usually involve a negative fecal exam either. I hope you are providing the results of this test you are saying is done? Otherwise, someone might think you are lying and intentionally misleading people. This could be an issue with your method of advertising or even could lead to theft by deception or something since you can reasonably be expected to know the difference. So I hope you have backed up all your claims and implications sufficiently (which means actually having all this done and verified by the vet AND providing it to the customer), or it could lead to some problems for you. Not one, but TWO pages from someone who said they didn't have one? Hmmm. Why TWO websites Anna? *just my opinions*

Saw you updated your page again on 2/1/09. Saw it now says you won't be breeding anymore on there as well as the post on here. As I looked at some close up pics, around the eyes and the edges of the ears, I thought you might want to give some ivomec or something. Could be nothing, or allergies, or whatever, but it is also known to be a sign of the contagious mange (scabies can freak some people out). I would do it if it were me, at least precautionarily. They need dewormed anyways, right? I also noticed the dig at k-lynn. It's on the upcoming litter page. Yeah, it'll probably upset her, but it makes you look like sh*!. Not in the best interest of the puppies or the breed, wouldn't you say. And yet on that same page you call other breeder's childish? You would endanger the dogs you claim to love, and act unethically and irresponsibly, and all to 'get back' at someone. SHAME ON YOU!
Anyone that wants a puppy from K-Lynn's Benzie will get one. You will make sure of that! This litter (only), you will be selling with full AKC Papers, Yes they will have breeding rights on their puppy. Email their info and you will put on the waiting list for her puppies ?
You are no longer breeding as your dogs mean to much to you and you are tired of all the childish breeders out there. It is sad as you have had many years of very happy puppy buyers that want you to keep breeding your quality dogs. You are the the type of breeder that does not breed for the money. You have always bred your dogs for the quality, health, personality and temperment???
This was your choice to stop breeding and no ones choice but yours. All of your dogs will still be living in your wonderful home with your family. Your dogs are very muched loved by you?
You love your dogs? You don't breed for money? You care? There is no excuse for your statements about Benzie's puppies. You don't qualify as a loving, caring, ethical breeder in my opinion if you are willing to punish the puppies because you are mad at one of your dogs' breeder, and want to hurt her and piss her off. They are YOUR puppies Anna, not hers, and you are willfully taking the chance to put them in a situation that could be horrible for them. That is no one's decision but yours. YOU are responsible for them, and if they end up badly, it will be YOUR doing, and intentional no less. Boy did you show your true colors with that one, I think. Whatever doubt there was, you erased with your bad intentions and uncaring, unfeeling attitude towards your own puppies!
I will keep looking for proof, and I hope other's do too. I hope we all keep posting whatever we find, so others may have a chance to avoid being hurt (unlike those poor pups), and to make a more informed decision if considering purchasing from you. You have shown with those comments about Benzie's pups that the lives you are responsible for mean nothing to you. You can take it down from the minpinz1981 page at geocities, but you can't ever take it back. *just my opinions*

I certainly wouldn't trust this person enough to hand over my hard earned money and my heart to a baby from this liar (if you get one, per other complaints). If she lies about this, what else? Liars don't usually mean others well, only themselves. In report #414489, on 1/25/09, Anna Goodnoe said:

*I am not competition for you anymore. We don't breed anymore because we love our dogs too much and want the best for them. *

She also said *If I had my website still I would post all this on their for everyone to see but since we are not breeders anymore we don't have one. So this is where I will post stuff. -*This is not an honest person AT ALL it seems. If she outright lies about something so simple, what does that mean to her customers? Not someone I would trust to get a future family member from, that's for sure. She has finished working on her minpinz1981 page at geocities, and it has available puppies and future planned litters on it. Last updated 1/28/09. And the site was in progress when she said it. I'd like to see a post every single time she proves it to be a lie too. I don't like liars. Tells you alot about a person and their intentions in my opinion. *just my opinions*

Well today was the court date and as expected Anna and Aaron Goodnoe didn't appear. The Judge gave them every opportunity to appear even holding the hearing over one hour later then the court documents indicated. After they did not appear the judge had his clerks contact the Goodnoes and allowed them to plead at least part of their case via the telephone. The Judge denied their motion for change of venue and even though the main portion of the case was suppose to be heard today, the judge allowed a continuance so they may present their own evidence. Although I was disappointed by the continuance It gives me more time to allow everyone else who have been wronged by Aaron and Anna Goodnoe to write to Judge Joe Guzman and show that both Aaron and Anna's credibility is a issue. By the amount and severity of the recent reports I have no doubt that Anna and Aaron Goodnoe are still trying to take advantage of people.

I have read many reports on this kennel here ........ I have some ideas. Some of them may involve suing in her state, but at this point there is alot of principles involved I think? Sounds like some of you have the documentation to do it too, like the OP. And the registration poster (why not limited rights?). She clearly is the one whom broke the agreement with the poster, and the emails prove it. Also, by the way, you seem to be a dream purchaser, LOL. And I think they knew full well you could not retract several of your postings and complaints, but they wanted to give the APPEARANCE of an attempt to settle I think. And for the poster about the registration, you have your contract, also, check her state lemon laws ....... A great deal of them require that if a puppy is sold as registerable, specific information must be required, and, LMAO, THAT THE PAPERS MUST BE PROVIDED WITHIN A SPECIFIC AMOUNT OF TIME. So, if the rules say x amount days, but the papers are withheld (or not provided) until x time, a breeder would be breaking a state law to withhold papers that long. So check the laws, you may be able to get her. And, the neighbor, and at least another comment gave me a great idea........... Start DNA testing those dogs.

I think a pre-paid DNA test from AKC is like $35 or something. Are we absolutely sure her breeding records are correct? Does she keep her males and females seperate? Are we really sure that the sires are whom she says they are? False records and parental info are frowned on by just about every registry. Sounds like she has enough pups to be required to DNA the sires. If she's not, some of you may be able to make her through the courts if you have the right paperwork and can prove there is enough reason for the request. And even those of you whom did not recieve their actual papers, but have the DNA of the parent(s) can check this. We are just wanting to check that the animals are decended from the animals which she says they are. You can be banned from ALOT (most of them I believe) of registry's by doing this, not just AKC. Just look in the code of ethics for any of them. Alot of breeder's switch registry's if they get in trouble with AKC for this, but most people don't think to provide proof to the other registry's as well. You may be causing alot of problems for those whom have and are breeding registered puppies from her though, if she is found to have not been so accurate.

It's just an idea. Start checking the laws in her state, or where she resided when you purchased your puppy, and as long as you have actual proof, and not a he said/she said situation, you will most likely come out on top. You would be surprised how many breeders are not aware of their own state puppy lemon laws, and how they are classified by those laws, and as a result, break them. One small step at a time. If she is truly as bad as you all seem to BELIEVE, you can make life VERY difficult for her. If she has done nothing wrong according to those laws, well.....Some of you may want to look into the laws involving sales across state lines as well. Good luck to you all.

I have read many reports on this kennel here ........ I have some ideas. Some of them may involve suing in her state, but at this point there is alot of principles involved I think? Sounds like some of you have the documentation to do it too, like the OP. And the registration poster (why not limited rights?). She clearly is the one whom broke the agreement with the poster, and the emails prove it. Also, by the way, you seem to be a dream purchaser, LOL. And I think they knew full well you could not retract several of your postings and complaints, but they wanted to give the APPEARANCE of an attempt to settle I think. And for the poster about the registration, you have your contract, also, check her state lemon laws ....... A great deal of them require that if a puppy is sold as registerable, specific information must be required, and, LMAO, THAT THE PAPERS MUST BE PROVIDED WITHIN A SPECIFIC AMOUNT OF TIME. So, if the rules say x amount days, but the papers are withheld (or not provided) until x time, a breeder would be breaking a state law to withhold papers that long. So check the laws, you may be able to get her. And, the neighbor, and at least another comment gave me a great idea........... Start DNA testing those dogs.

I think a pre-paid DNA test from AKC is like $35 or something. Are we absolutely sure her breeding records are correct? Does she keep her males and females seperate? Are we really sure that the sires are whom she says they are? False records and parental info are frowned on by just about every registry. Sounds like she has enough pups to be required to DNA the sires. If she's not, some of you may be able to make her through the courts if you have the right paperwork and can prove there is enough reason for the request. And even those of you whom did not recieve their actual papers, but have the DNA of the parent(s) can check this. We are just wanting to check that the animals are decended from the animals which she says they are. You can be banned from ALOT (most of them I believe) of registry's by doing this, not just AKC. Just look in the code of ethics for any of them. Alot of breeder's switch registry's if they get in trouble with AKC for this, but most people don't think to provide proof to the other registry's as well. You may be causing alot of problems for those whom have and are breeding registered puppies from her though, if she is found to have not been so accurate.

It's just an idea. Start checking the laws in her state, or where she resided when you purchased your puppy, and as long as you have actual proof, and not a he said/she said situation, you will most likely come out on top. You would be surprised how many breeders are not aware of their own state puppy lemon laws, and how they are classified by those laws, and as a result, break them. One small step at a time. If she is truly as bad as you all seem to BELIEVE, you can make life VERY difficult for her. If she has done nothing wrong according to those laws, well.....Some of you may want to look into the laws involving sales across state lines as well. Good luck to you all.

To whom it ma concern that reads all of the reports on the net and on here -

Anna has been proven to have sick dogs, sick puppies and she is VERY abusive to ALL the breeds she has there in her home and the SINGLE WIDE trailer next to her house. She also keeps them in her SUB ZERO garage if she does not like the animals. All information given here is FACT and has been told to us the new group to STOP Anna from hurting anyone else or any other animal.

Google her name and see the MANY complaints for those who are NOT afraid of her and her terrible ways. We are asking ANTONE who has a personal terrible experience with Anna either with the Miniature Pinschers, Chinese Cresteds, Great Danes, and Wiemeraners she has purchased through the years. Now we see she has BIRDS... with her SIX cats.

Everything we have read on her site for years about her is TOTALLY the OPPOSITE from what she TRULY is!!!

We have set up a email address to you to send your report to so we can send it to the state of NORTH DAKOTA --- and is saying in her advertisements she lives in GRAND FORKS, MINNESOTA - NO SUCH PLACE, she is running hard from the law and everyone she owes money and a legal explanation to. She has now been proved to be HARD CORE abusive to the animals she keeps and does not like. Neither Her NOR her Husband Arron have jobs, they sit in their home and HARASS people daily. We have talked to breeders she has bullied with legal contracts that she has tried to extort money from them by saying she would SMEAR their good reputation all over the site if they did not PAY her to get their dogs back... OR she has told them the dogs would end up in a PUPPY MILL if the money did not come. And she means it. Another breeder has NO idea the condition or whereabouts of her three dogs. Anna is NOT to be trusted. Then lets go to the BUYERS... she TAKES money and does not provide pups, or she asks for MORE money to ship dogs. And HOW IN THE HECK are these dogs passing Health inspection Dr. Pinkerton of Minot North Dakota??? OR is Anna falsifying her Health Certificates?

We could go on for days and weeks with at he amount of trash we have found on this SICK person... lets stop her and any other puppy milling idiot out there! This has to stop.

IF you have had a health issue with your puppy from Anna or have had a threatening experience with Anna PLEASE send your email to

stop_anna_goodnoe@yahoo.com

Thank you from the staff!

I received my notice today from Maricopa County Justice Court, State of Arizona: Beverly Sills vs. Aaron and Anna Goodnoe, case number CC2008184670. Their request for a venue change was denied based on evidence I presented with my reply, furthermore the case will be heard on Janurary 14, 2009 at 10:00 am.

"Parties are reminded that they must have with them at the hearing all documents and any witnesses needed to establish their claim, defense or counterclaim. Evidence and testimony cannot be submitted after the Justice of the Peace or Hearing Officer has heard the cases..... If you do not appear at the time of the trial you risk having a judgment entered against you and your claim dismissed"

Anyone wishing to provide me a written statement regarding their business or personal dealings with Aaron or Anna Goodnoe may contact me using the method I outlined in a previous post. They may also write the court directly and have their statement included in the case. Please refer to the case number above and direct your statements to the judge hearing the case, Joe Guzman. The court will not include anonymous statements so please include your contact information when addressing the Honorable Joe Guzman.

I received my notice today from Maricopa County Justice Court, State of Arizona: Beverly Sills vs. Aaron and Anna Goodnoe, case number CC2008184670. Their request for a venue change was denied based on evidence I presented with my reply, furthermore the case will be heard on Janurary 14, 2009 at 10:00 am.

"Parties are reminded that they must have with them at the hearing all documents and any witnesses needed to establish their claim, defense or counterclaim. Evidence and testimony cannot be submitted after the Justice of the Peace or Hearing Officer has heard the cases..... If you do not appear at the time of the trial you risk having a judgment entered against you and your claim dismissed"

Anyone wishing to provide me a written statement regarding their business or personal dealings with Aaron or Anna Goodnoe may contact me using the method I outlined in a previous post. They may also write the court directly and have their statement included in the case. Please refer to the case number above and direct your statements to the judge hearing the case, Joe Guzman. The court will not include anonymous statements so please include your contact information when addressing the Honorable Joe Guzman.

I received my notice today from Maricopa County Justice Court, State of Arizona: Beverly Sills vs. Aaron and Anna Goodnoe, case number CC2008184670. Their request for a venue change was denied based on evidence I presented with my reply, furthermore the case will be heard on Janurary 14, 2009 at 10:00 am.

"Parties are reminded that they must have with them at the hearing all documents and any witnesses needed to establish their claim, defense or counterclaim. Evidence and testimony cannot be submitted after the Justice of the Peace or Hearing Officer has heard the cases..... If you do not appear at the time of the trial you risk having a judgment entered against you and your claim dismissed"

Anyone wishing to provide me a written statement regarding their business or personal dealings with Aaron or Anna Goodnoe may contact me using the method I outlined in a previous post. They may also write the court directly and have their statement included in the case. Please refer to the case number above and direct your statements to the judge hearing the case, Joe Guzman. The court will not include anonymous statements so please include your contact information when addressing the Honorable Joe Guzman.

I received my notice today from Maricopa County Justice Court, State of Arizona: Beverly Sills vs. Aaron and Anna Goodnoe, case number CC2008184670. Their request for a venue change was denied based on evidence I presented with my reply, furthermore the case will be heard on Janurary 14, 2009 at 10:00 am.

"Parties are reminded that they must have with them at the hearing all documents and any witnesses needed to establish their claim, defense or counterclaim. Evidence and testimony cannot be submitted after the Justice of the Peace or Hearing Officer has heard the cases..... If you do not appear at the time of the trial you risk having a judgment entered against you and your claim dismissed"

Anyone wishing to provide me a written statement regarding their business or personal dealings with Aaron or Anna Goodnoe may contact me using the method I outlined in a previous post. They may also write the court directly and have their statement included in the case. Please refer to the case number above and direct your statements to the judge hearing the case, Joe Guzman. The court will not include anonymous statements so please include your contact information when addressing the Honorable Joe Guzman.

Indica - UPDATE

This is a question for you...it says in your post you bought a dog from Anna named "Izzy" in April 2008 and "Izzy's" mom's name is Kahlua.... are you telling me that ANNA bred Kahlua back to back like this AGAIN???

Kahlua JUST had another litter of SEVEN pups on September 11th, 2008 ~

This clears up sooooooo many questions I have had! You can contact me online...I can't put any info up here other than clues...

K-Lynn's is my kennel name - I raise Min Pins...

If this is the truth and Anna had sold you a puppy in APRIL ....then she is lying to me AGAIN... this makes THREE litters and a BREACHED contract from Miss Perry! I did not sign the contract over from Miss P until MUCH MUCH later this summer!

She signed a release giving Anna ownership legally AND then Anna had to sign a whole new contract and stipulations through ME!

When were the pups born??? How many pups were in the littter?? Who was the sire? How did she advertise them??? They were NOT on her site?

Can we ALL see a trend here??? OMG... she lost all that weight, was fed hardly anything and then bred BACK TO BACK... and behind *my back*! She was NOT PHYSICALLY ready to have another litter after everything her little body had gone through since NOVEMBER 2007... I remember NOW...Anna drove to Georgia to pick up all those dogs...AND KAHLUA! WHAT A SCUM BAG! Then she call wolf....b y saying it was the LINES from Kahlua... grrrrrrr I am soooo mad right now!


If she legally sold you that dog... oh boy... THOSE TWO ARE IN SOME HOT HOT WATER!

hmmmmm???

Miss P. let Anna have Kahlua under my contract that stated this dog cannot be transferred or sold without my permission... THIS IS WHY YOU WILL NEVER SEE PAPERS ON THIS DOG IF THIS IS TRUE! This was an "UNDER THE TABLE BREEDING" and done by breaching a LEGAL AND BINDING CONTRACT!



PLEASE CONTACT ME!

Thanks, Kristin

To the comment about Anna's "Kahlua" and the Inguinal Hernia situation - LMAO



Here is a bit of information on Kahlua and the puppies she had. It is NOT the genetics of the dog... it was the IGNORANCE of the breeder who bred her - SEVEN PUPPIES CAME FROM THIS ILL BREEDING!



FIRST off, I do not support Anna in any way shape or form..... I am not perfect in any means... but her Fly off the handle and screaming... SCREAMING at the top of her lungs and SLAMMING the phone down is enough to make me roll on the floor laughing. My seven year old has better conduct than Anna ever will!

Anna is certifiably INSANE...

Anna got Kahlua back from a breeder "I" sold Kahlua to as a 8 week old pup, the dog was NOT being cared for properly in BOTH of our eyes... Kahlua was SIXTEEN POUNDS as an 11 inch female! Anna had gotten the weight off her to EIGHT POUNDS (HALF HER BODY WEIGHT)... then she bred her. I know all of this from Anna's OWN MOUTH! I commended her for the RIGHT THING she did, but then she turns around and does a WRONG THING. 1/4 cup of Holistic adult dog food (PER DAY) that is for fat dogs and a slice of apple or carrot is what SHE TOLD ME SHE WAS GIVING KAHLUA!

Then she bred this dog... FOR YOU LADIES OUT THERE THAT HAVE HAD CHILDREN and understand growth and development... maybe you could follow up with the support that GROWING FETUSES NEED PROPER NUTRITION AND PLENTY OF IT!!!



We let all our female FREE FEED when pregnant and add Calcium towards the very end and extra protein the entire time with extra FRESH veggies and fruit!



I ~WAS~ speaking to Anna t the time of the birth of theses SEVEN puppies! For an eight pound dog... that is alot!



#1.)She told me they were a WEEK EARLY....



#2.)Skin was missing from TWO of the puppies....



#3.)I heard from her LAST week on a phone call... that the WALLS of the abdomens were very thin and unstable....



#4.) They were all under ONE pound at Eight weeks....



#5.)AS WELL as a few had inguinal hernias!





I have asked her SIX or SEVEN times... if I could get the vet report on these pups... and NEVER ONE TIME has she sent them! (I am the breeder of Kahlua)



See the thing is Anna will lie to God if she was standing there in front of him...



She will tell you one thing and you will catch her in the NEXT conversation totally CONTRADITCTING every last word.... if you know her personally ... you will agree!



The thing is... Kahlua had these pups a week early and they are VERY undervelped in many ways from what Anna told me personally ---- THIS is not a genetic issue by ANY menas... IF IT WAS... then Kahluas LAST litter would have had the same issues and Kahlua's daughter MACKENZIE would have had the same or simular issues in her last litter... AND WHY IN GODS NAME did she just breed the dog again IF....IF it is TRULY genetic!

I have 5 generations of that line her in my breeding program - ONLY one female EVER produced INGUINAL HERNIAS - ONE... and we have had SEVERAL litters and some of those dogs are producing lines out there wil full breeding right and NO ISSUES!



COMMON SENSE DICTATES.... Anna should not be breeding if she cannot understand the issues dogs have, learn from them and EXCEPT her own d**n mistakes... and STOP blaming everyone else in the world for her issues and problems - Anna YOU are not a ~VICTIM~... you past buyers and past FRIENDS are! And some of you poor dogs are as well!



Don't blame the poor dog OR the genetics... blame her for not taking responsibility for what SHE bred... the dog was ~NOT~ ready to take on a litter of SEVEN puppies and carry them full term as on what she was being FED and and what she had lost as far as body mass...

TO ME... that was complete selfishness!


DO YOUR OWN RESEARCH! ~Can a starved dog or HUMAN carry a baby full term with hardly any calories or fat intake???



ALSO - I have a contract with ANNA GOODNOE... she seems to think contracts are something to line the bird cage with... UNLESS it is HER CONTRACT!!!



THAT DOG IS TO COME BACK TO ME if for any reason she does not want her or need her... Here is the portion of the contract:



______The buyer agrees that at anytime the buyer cannot take proper care of the puppy OR DOES NOT WANT THE PUPPY, or the puppy no longer works for a breeding program for whatever reason the buyer must contact the breeder and the breeder will either A.) Have 1st choice to TAKE the puppy back in original condition if unaltered and with AKC papers with FULL registration provided or B.) Assist the buyer in finding a suitable home for the puppy in a PET home. Seller is not responsible for ANY costs or expenses incurred!!!(READ THIS AND UNDERSTAND!!!) NO ONE else gets the 1st chance at the puppy if you decide you do not want the puppy anymore. SELLER will TAKE the puppy back!!! If local, seller will help find a suitable home.



******SELLER WILL NOT BE HELD RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY BILLS, TREATMENT, MEDICATIONS OR SHIPPING COSTS!!!( If the puppy is returned)


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
LOOK on Anna's website under ADULTS FOR SALE... she has her up for sale, BECAUSE she wants ME to pay her $625 to get Kahlua back... and I offered her $100 for the crate and Health Cetificate as well as COD on pick up of Kahlua....



Anna NEVER paid me a DIME for this dog.... and she wants me to but her back! YEA right, I have learned from all the complaints...if I send her the money, I will NEVER see my poor dog!



THIS IS THE SAME REASON WHY I WILL NEVER IN MY LIFE SELL A DOG TO A BREEDER AGAIN....You can all thank Anna for this and a few other idiots!

I am sorry Anna, you brought ALL of this crap on yourself! Thanks for using me as a stepping stone in your sick little life!

As for Mindy and Jamie... you had better watch your backs! You are the last of the last that MIGHT have any chances in this business.... hangin with Anna... will certainly blow you backwards in the Min Pin world!


OH.... and another thing that irritates the skin off my back....

Anna, you don't have kids and those dogs ARE NOT RAISED WITH KIDS -LIAR!

AND... those dogs SIT in a crate most of the day until yuo ROTATE the 30 sum Min Pins you own! I have been on the PHONE WITH you while you let them out...then in ...then out...then in - To me that is like a PRISON! Stacked crates and arotation schedule! We don't crate our dogs...unless they have litters on the ground.


The last go around of puppies you had you had a TOTAL OF 31 puppies... and you claim that is SANTITARY in your home! OMG And you are NOT doing it for $$$ and you are NOT a Puppy Mill - What do you call it???

You bag me because I have hired a vet tech to help me with my dogs on the weekend ( when I am busy with my OTHER business - At least I have a JoB) and NOT all of them live in my home making it smell like a barn! I spent THOUSANDS on a building/home (NOT A KENNEL) for my dogs to have Adequate living quarters, it is clean, I am INSPECTED by AKC AND the STATE...I am LICENSED are you! I have to follow STRICT guidlines and rules to keep my dogs OR THEY TAKE THEM FROM ME!@!!!

I want to say a few positive things... and I have a few things to say... but why, have you EVER in your life said anything positve about anyone you deal with???

SELFISH! In so many ways! This is what it will get you Anna!

Sorry if the truth hurts... you have hurt me ten times over...

What comes around goes around!

AND - This is for God and everyone to see...if you hurt or do something to the two dog you have from me...I will plaster it all over the web! i will contact whoever I need to make sure you pay for your sins! I am SICK of your threats!

We will all be watching....

To the comment about Anna's "Kahlua" and the Inguinal Hernia situation - LMAO



Here is a bit of information on Kahlua and the puppies she had. It is NOT the genetics of the dog... it was the IGNORANCE of the breeder who bred her - SEVEN PUPPIES CAME FROM THIS ILL BREEDING!



FIRST off, I do not support Anna in any way shape or form..... I am not perfect in any means... but her Fly off the handle and screaming... SCREAMING at the top of her lungs and SLAMMING the phone down is enough to make me roll on the floor laughing. My seven year old has better conduct than Anna ever will!

Anna is certifiably INSANE...

Anna got Kahlua back from a breeder "I" sold Kahlua to as a 8 week old pup, the dog was NOT being cared for properly in BOTH of our eyes... Kahlua was SIXTEEN POUNDS as an 11 inch female! Anna had gotten the weight off her to EIGHT POUNDS (HALF HER BODY WEIGHT)... then she bred her. I know all of this from Anna's OWN MOUTH! I commended her for the RIGHT THING she did, but then she turns around and does a WRONG THING. 1/4 cup of Holistic adult dog food (PER DAY) that is for fat dogs and a slice of apple or carrot is what SHE TOLD ME SHE WAS GIVING KAHLUA!

Then she bred this dog... FOR YOU LADIES OUT THERE THAT HAVE HAD CHILDREN and understand growth and development... maybe you could follow up with the support that GROWING FETUSES NEED PROPER NUTRITION AND PLENTY OF IT!!!



We let all our female FREE FEED when pregnant and add Calcium towards the very end and extra protein the entire time with extra FRESH veggies and fruit!



I ~WAS~ speaking to Anna t the time of the birth of theses SEVEN puppies! For an eight pound dog... that is alot!



#1.)She told me they were a WEEK EARLY....



#2.)Skin was missing from TWO of the puppies....



#3.)I heard from her LAST week on a phone call... that the WALLS of the abdomens were very thin and unstable....



#4.) They were all under ONE pound at Eight weeks....



#5.)AS WELL as a few had inguinal hernias!





I have asked her SIX or SEVEN times... if I could get the vet report on these pups... and NEVER ONE TIME has she sent them! (I am the breeder of Kahlua)



See the thing is Anna will lie to God if she was standing there in front of him...



She will tell you one thing and you will catch her in the NEXT conversation totally CONTRADITCTING every last word.... if you know her personally ... you will agree!



The thing is... Kahlua had these pups a week early and they are VERY undervelped in many ways from what Anna told me personally ---- THIS is not a genetic issue by ANY menas... IF IT WAS... then Kahluas LAST litter would have had the same issues and Kahlua's daughter MACKENZIE would have had the same or simular issues in her last litter... AND WHY IN GODS NAME did she just breed the dog again IF....IF it is TRULY genetic!

I have 5 generations of that line her in my breeding program - ONLY one female EVER produced INGUINAL HERNIAS - ONE... and we have had SEVERAL litters and some of those dogs are producing lines out there wil full breeding right and NO ISSUES!



COMMON SENSE DICTATES.... Anna should not be breeding if she cannot understand the issues dogs have, learn from them and EXCEPT her own d**n mistakes... and STOP blaming everyone else in the world for her issues and problems - Anna YOU are not a ~VICTIM~... you past buyers and past FRIENDS are! And some of you poor dogs are as well!



Don't blame the poor dog OR the genetics... blame her for not taking responsibility for what SHE bred... the dog was ~NOT~ ready to take on a litter of SEVEN puppies and carry them full term as on what she was being FED and and what she had lost as far as body mass...

TO ME... that was complete selfishness!


DO YOUR OWN RESEARCH! ~Can a starved dog or HUMAN carry a baby full term with hardly any calories or fat intake???



ALSO - I have a contract with ANNA GOODNOE... she seems to think contracts are something to line the bird cage with... UNLESS it is HER CONTRACT!!!



THAT DOG IS TO COME BACK TO ME if for any reason she does not want her or need her... Here is the portion of the contract:



______The buyer agrees that at anytime the buyer cannot take proper care of the puppy OR DOES NOT WANT THE PUPPY, or the puppy no longer works for a breeding program for whatever reason the buyer must contact the breeder and the breeder will either A.) Have 1st choice to TAKE the puppy back in original condition if unaltered and with AKC papers with FULL registration provided or B.) Assist the buyer in finding a suitable home for the puppy in a PET home. Seller is not responsible for ANY costs or expenses incurred!!!(READ THIS AND UNDERSTAND!!!) NO ONE else gets the 1st chance at the puppy if you decide you do not want the puppy anymore. SELLER will TAKE the puppy back!!! If local, seller will help find a suitable home.



******SELLER WILL NOT BE HELD RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY BILLS, TREATMENT, MEDICATIONS OR SHIPPING COSTS!!!( If the puppy is returned)


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
LOOK on Anna's website under ADULTS FOR SALE... she has her up for sale, BECAUSE she wants ME to pay her $625 to get Kahlua back... and I offered her $100 for the crate and Health Cetificate as well as COD on pick up of Kahlua....



Anna NEVER paid me a DIME for this dog.... and she wants me to but her back! YEA right, I have learned from all the complaints...if I send her the money, I will NEVER see my poor dog!



THIS IS THE SAME REASON WHY I WILL NEVER IN MY LIFE SELL A DOG TO A BREEDER AGAIN....You can all thank Anna for this and a few other idiots!

I am sorry Anna, you brought ALL of this crap on yourself! Thanks for using me as a stepping stone in your sick little life!

As for Mindy and Jamie... you had better watch your backs! You are the last of the last that MIGHT have any chances in this business.... hangin with Anna... will certainly blow you backwards in the Min Pin world!


OH.... and another thing that irritates the skin off my back....

Anna, you don't have kids and those dogs ARE NOT RAISED WITH KIDS -LIAR!

AND... those dogs SIT in a crate most of the day until yuo ROTATE the 30 sum Min Pins you own! I have been on the PHONE WITH you while you let them out...then in ...then out...then in - To me that is like a PRISON! Stacked crates and arotation schedule! We don't crate our dogs...unless they have litters on the ground.


The last go around of puppies you had you had a TOTAL OF 31 puppies... and you claim that is SANTITARY in your home! OMG And you are NOT doing it for $$$ and you are NOT a Puppy Mill - What do you call it???

You bag me because I have hired a vet tech to help me with my dogs on the weekend ( when I am busy with my OTHER business - At least I have a JoB) and NOT all of them live in my home making it smell like a barn! I spent THOUSANDS on a building/home (NOT A KENNEL) for my dogs to have Adequate living quarters, it is clean, I am INSPECTED by AKC AND the STATE...I am LICENSED are you! I have to follow STRICT guidlines and rules to keep my dogs OR THEY TAKE THEM FROM ME!@!!!

I want to say a few positive things... and I have a few things to say... but why, have you EVER in your life said anything positve about anyone you deal with???

SELFISH! In so many ways! This is what it will get you Anna!

Sorry if the truth hurts... you have hurt me ten times over...

What comes around goes around!

AND - This is for God and everyone to see...if you hurt or do something to the two dog you have from me...I will plaster it all over the web! i will contact whoever I need to make sure you pay for your sins! I am SICK of your threats!

We will all be watching....

To the comment about Anna's "Kahlua" and the Inguinal Hernia situation - LMAO



Here is a bit of information on Kahlua and the puppies she had. It is NOT the genetics of the dog... it was the IGNORANCE of the breeder who bred her - SEVEN PUPPIES CAME FROM THIS ILL BREEDING!



FIRST off, I do not support Anna in any way shape or form..... I am not perfect in any means... but her Fly off the handle and screaming... SCREAMING at the top of her lungs and SLAMMING the phone down is enough to make me roll on the floor laughing. My seven year old has better conduct than Anna ever will!

Anna is certifiably INSANE...

Anna got Kahlua back from a breeder "I" sold Kahlua to as a 8 week old pup, the dog was NOT being cared for properly in BOTH of our eyes... Kahlua was SIXTEEN POUNDS as an 11 inch female! Anna had gotten the weight off her to EIGHT POUNDS (HALF HER BODY WEIGHT)... then she bred her. I know all of this from Anna's OWN MOUTH! I commended her for the RIGHT THING she did, but then she turns around and does a WRONG THING. 1/4 cup of Holistic adult dog food (PER DAY) that is for fat dogs and a slice of apple or carrot is what SHE TOLD ME SHE WAS GIVING KAHLUA!

Then she bred this dog... FOR YOU LADIES OUT THERE THAT HAVE HAD CHILDREN and understand growth and development... maybe you could follow up with the support that GROWING FETUSES NEED PROPER NUTRITION AND PLENTY OF IT!!!



We let all our female FREE FEED when pregnant and add Calcium towards the very end and extra protein the entire time with extra FRESH veggies and fruit!



I ~WAS~ speaking to Anna t the time of the birth of theses SEVEN puppies! For an eight pound dog... that is alot!



#1.)She told me they were a WEEK EARLY....



#2.)Skin was missing from TWO of the puppies....



#3.)I heard from her LAST week on a phone call... that the WALLS of the abdomens were very thin and unstable....



#4.) They were all under ONE pound at Eight weeks....



#5.)AS WELL as a few had inguinal hernias!





I have asked her SIX or SEVEN times... if I could get the vet report on these pups... and NEVER ONE TIME has she sent them! (I am the breeder of Kahlua)



See the thing is Anna will lie to God if she was standing there in front of him...



She will tell you one thing and you will catch her in the NEXT conversation totally CONTRADITCTING every last word.... if you know her personally ... you will agree!



The thing is... Kahlua had these pups a week early and they are VERY undervelped in many ways from what Anna told me personally ---- THIS is not a genetic issue by ANY menas... IF IT WAS... then Kahluas LAST litter would have had the same issues and Kahlua's daughter MACKENZIE would have had the same or simular issues in her last litter... AND WHY IN GODS NAME did she just breed the dog again IF....IF it is TRULY genetic!

I have 5 generations of that line her in my breeding program - ONLY one female EVER produced INGUINAL HERNIAS - ONE... and we have had SEVERAL litters and some of those dogs are producing lines out there wil full breeding right and NO ISSUES!



COMMON SENSE DICTATES.... Anna should not be breeding if she cannot understand the issues dogs have, learn from them and EXCEPT her own d**n mistakes... and STOP blaming everyone else in the world for her issues and problems - Anna YOU are not a ~VICTIM~... you past buyers and past FRIENDS are! And some of you poor dogs are as well!



Don't blame the poor dog OR the genetics... blame her for not taking responsibility for what SHE bred... the dog was ~NOT~ ready to take on a litter of SEVEN puppies and carry them full term as on what she was being FED and and what she had lost as far as body mass...

TO ME... that was complete selfishness!


DO YOUR OWN RESEARCH! ~Can a starved dog or HUMAN carry a baby full term with hardly any calories or fat intake???



ALSO - I have a contract with ANNA GOODNOE... she seems to think contracts are something to line the bird cage with... UNLESS it is HER CONTRACT!!!



THAT DOG IS TO COME BACK TO ME if for any reason she does not want her or need her... Here is the portion of the contract:



______The buyer agrees that at anytime the buyer cannot take proper care of the puppy OR DOES NOT WANT THE PUPPY, or the puppy no longer works for a breeding program for whatever reason the buyer must contact the breeder and the breeder will either A.) Have 1st choice to TAKE the puppy back in original condition if unaltered and with AKC papers with FULL registration provided or B.) Assist the buyer in finding a suitable home for the puppy in a PET home. Seller is not responsible for ANY costs or expenses incurred!!!(READ THIS AND UNDERSTAND!!!) NO ONE else gets the 1st chance at the puppy if you decide you do not want the puppy anymore. SELLER will TAKE the puppy back!!! If local, seller will help find a suitable home.



******SELLER WILL NOT BE HELD RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY BILLS, TREATMENT, MEDICATIONS OR SHIPPING COSTS!!!( If the puppy is returned)


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
LOOK on Anna's website under ADULTS FOR SALE... she has her up for sale, BECAUSE she wants ME to pay her $625 to get Kahlua back... and I offered her $100 for the crate and Health Cetificate as well as COD on pick up of Kahlua....



Anna NEVER paid me a DIME for this dog.... and she wants me to but her back! YEA right, I have learned from all the complaints...if I send her the money, I will NEVER see my poor dog!



THIS IS THE SAME REASON WHY I WILL NEVER IN MY LIFE SELL A DOG TO A BREEDER AGAIN....You can all thank Anna for this and a few other idiots!

I am sorry Anna, you brought ALL of this crap on yourself! Thanks for using me as a stepping stone in your sick little life!

As for Mindy and Jamie... you had better watch your backs! You are the last of the last that MIGHT have any chances in this business.... hangin with Anna... will certainly blow you backwards in the Min Pin world!


OH.... and another thing that irritates the skin off my back....

Anna, you don't have kids and those dogs ARE NOT RAISED WITH KIDS -LIAR!

AND... those dogs SIT in a crate most of the day until yuo ROTATE the 30 sum Min Pins you own! I have been on the PHONE WITH you while you let them out...then in ...then out...then in - To me that is like a PRISON! Stacked crates and arotation schedule! We don't crate our dogs...unless they have litters on the ground.


The last go around of puppies you had you had a TOTAL OF 31 puppies... and you claim that is SANTITARY in your home! OMG And you are NOT doing it for $$$ and you are NOT a Puppy Mill - What do you call it???

You bag me because I have hired a vet tech to help me with my dogs on the weekend ( when I am busy with my OTHER business - At least I have a JoB) and NOT all of them live in my home making it smell like a barn! I spent THOUSANDS on a building/home (NOT A KENNEL) for my dogs to have Adequate living quarters, it is clean, I am INSPECTED by AKC AND the STATE...I am LICENSED are you! I have to follow STRICT guidlines and rules to keep my dogs OR THEY TAKE THEM FROM ME!@!!!

I want to say a few positive things... and I have a few things to say... but why, have you EVER in your life said anything positve about anyone you deal with???

SELFISH! In so many ways! This is what it will get you Anna!

Sorry if the truth hurts... you have hurt me ten times over...

What comes around goes around!

AND - This is for God and everyone to see...if you hurt or do something to the two dog you have from me...I will plaster it all over the web! i will contact whoever I need to make sure you pay for your sins! I am SICK of your threats!

We will all be watching....

To the comment about Anna's "Kahlua" and the Inguinal Hernia situation - LMAO



Here is a bit of information on Kahlua and the puppies she had. It is NOT the genetics of the dog... it was the IGNORANCE of the breeder who bred her - SEVEN PUPPIES CAME FROM THIS ILL BREEDING!



FIRST off, I do not support Anna in any way shape or form..... I am not perfect in any means... but her Fly off the handle and screaming... SCREAMING at the top of her lungs and SLAMMING the phone down is enough to make me roll on the floor laughing. My seven year old has better conduct than Anna ever will!

Anna is certifiably INSANE...

Anna got Kahlua back from a breeder "I" sold Kahlua to as a 8 week old pup, the dog was NOT being cared for properly in BOTH of our eyes... Kahlua was SIXTEEN POUNDS as an 11 inch female! Anna had gotten the weight off her to EIGHT POUNDS (HALF HER BODY WEIGHT)... then she bred her. I know all of this from Anna's OWN MOUTH! I commended her for the RIGHT THING she did, but then she turns around and does a WRONG THING. 1/4 cup of Holistic adult dog food (PER DAY) that is for fat dogs and a slice of apple or carrot is what SHE TOLD ME SHE WAS GIVING KAHLUA!

Then she bred this dog... FOR YOU LADIES OUT THERE THAT HAVE HAD CHILDREN and understand growth and development... maybe you could follow up with the support that GROWING FETUSES NEED PROPER NUTRITION AND PLENTY OF IT!!!



We let all our female FREE FEED when pregnant and add Calcium towards the very end and extra protein the entire time with extra FRESH veggies and fruit!



I ~WAS~ speaking to Anna t the time of the birth of theses SEVEN puppies! For an eight pound dog... that is alot!



#1.)She told me they were a WEEK EARLY....



#2.)Skin was missing from TWO of the puppies....



#3.)I heard from her LAST week on a phone call... that the WALLS of the abdomens were very thin and unstable....



#4.) They were all under ONE pound at Eight weeks....



#5.)AS WELL as a few had inguinal hernias!





I have asked her SIX or SEVEN times... if I could get the vet report on these pups... and NEVER ONE TIME has she sent them! (I am the breeder of Kahlua)



See the thing is Anna will lie to God if she was standing there in front of him...



She will tell you one thing and you will catch her in the NEXT conversation totally CONTRADITCTING every last word.... if you know her personally ... you will agree!



The thing is... Kahlua had these pups a week early and they are VERY undervelped in many ways from what Anna told me personally ---- THIS is not a genetic issue by ANY menas... IF IT WAS... then Kahluas LAST litter would have had the same issues and Kahlua's daughter MACKENZIE would have had the same or simular issues in her last litter... AND WHY IN GODS NAME did she just breed the dog again IF....IF it is TRULY genetic!

I have 5 generations of that line her in my breeding program - ONLY one female EVER produced INGUINAL HERNIAS - ONE... and we have had SEVERAL litters and some of those dogs are producing lines out there wil full breeding right and NO ISSUES!



COMMON SENSE DICTATES.... Anna should not be breeding if she cannot understand the issues dogs have, learn from them and EXCEPT her own d**n mistakes... and STOP blaming everyone else in the world for her issues and problems - Anna YOU are not a ~VICTIM~... you past buyers and past FRIENDS are! And some of you poor dogs are as well!



Don't blame the poor dog OR the genetics... blame her for not taking responsibility for what SHE bred... the dog was ~NOT~ ready to take on a litter of SEVEN puppies and carry them full term as on what she was being FED and and what she had lost as far as body mass...

TO ME... that was complete selfishness!


DO YOUR OWN RESEARCH! ~Can a starved dog or HUMAN carry a baby full term with hardly any calories or fat intake???



ALSO - I have a contract with ANNA GOODNOE... she seems to think contracts are something to line the bird cage with... UNLESS it is HER CONTRACT!!!



THAT DOG IS TO COME BACK TO ME if for any reason she does not want her or need her... Here is the portion of the contract:



______The buyer agrees that at anytime the buyer cannot take proper care of the puppy OR DOES NOT WANT THE PUPPY, or the puppy no longer works for a breeding program for whatever reason the buyer must contact the breeder and the breeder will either A.) Have 1st choice to TAKE the puppy back in original condition if unaltered and with AKC papers with FULL registration provided or B.) Assist the buyer in finding a suitable home for the puppy in a PET home. Seller is not responsible for ANY costs or expenses incurred!!!(READ THIS AND UNDERSTAND!!!) NO ONE else gets the 1st chance at the puppy if you decide you do not want the puppy anymore. SELLER will TAKE the puppy back!!! If local, seller will help find a suitable home.



******SELLER WILL NOT BE HELD RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY BILLS, TREATMENT, MEDICATIONS OR SHIPPING COSTS!!!( If the puppy is returned)


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
LOOK on Anna's website under ADULTS FOR SALE... she has her up for sale, BECAUSE she wants ME to pay her $625 to get Kahlua back... and I offered her $100 for the crate and Health Cetificate as well as COD on pick up of Kahlua....



Anna NEVER paid me a DIME for this dog.... and she wants me to but her back! YEA right, I have learned from all the complaints...if I send her the money, I will NEVER see my poor dog!



THIS IS THE SAME REASON WHY I WILL NEVER IN MY LIFE SELL A DOG TO A BREEDER AGAIN....You can all thank Anna for this and a few other idiots!

I am sorry Anna, you brought ALL of this crap on yourself! Thanks for using me as a stepping stone in your sick little life!

As for Mindy and Jamie... you had better watch your backs! You are the last of the last that MIGHT have any chances in this business.... hangin with Anna... will certainly blow you backwards in the Min Pin world!


OH.... and another thing that irritates the skin off my back....

Anna, you don't have kids and those dogs ARE NOT RAISED WITH KIDS -LIAR!

AND... those dogs SIT in a crate most of the day until yuo ROTATE the 30 sum Min Pins you own! I have been on the PHONE WITH you while you let them out...then in ...then out...then in - To me that is like a PRISON! Stacked crates and arotation schedule! We don't crate our dogs...unless they have litters on the ground.


The last go around of puppies you had you had a TOTAL OF 31 puppies... and you claim that is SANTITARY in your home! OMG And you are NOT doing it for $$$ and you are NOT a Puppy Mill - What do you call it???

You bag me because I have hired a vet tech to help me with my dogs on the weekend ( when I am busy with my OTHER business - At least I have a JoB) and NOT all of them live in my home making it smell like a barn! I spent THOUSANDS on a building/home (NOT A KENNEL) for my dogs to have Adequate living quarters, it is clean, I am INSPECTED by AKC AND the STATE...I am LICENSED are you! I have to follow STRICT guidlines and rules to keep my dogs OR THEY TAKE THEM FROM ME!@!!!

I want to say a few positive things... and I have a few things to say... but why, have you EVER in your life said anything positve about anyone you deal with???

SELFISH! In so many ways! This is what it will get you Anna!

Sorry if the truth hurts... you have hurt me ten times over...

What comes around goes around!

AND - This is for God and everyone to see...if you hurt or do something to the two dog you have from me...I will plaster it all over the web! i will contact whoever I need to make sure you pay for your sins! I am SICK of your threats!

We will all be watching....

I have an update as well. I received this e-mail on 11/5/2008 at 11:52 A.M from Anna Goodnoe as presented below:


do u want another puppy from izzy mom? i will give you one for free. she has 1 male and 4 females. they are ready to go now. there are fawns and chocolates. let me know.

-- ( Izzy is the name of my puppy) Izzy's mom's name is Kahlua
Enchanted Ridge Min Pins
Home (701) 594-9129
Cell (701) 240-3221
www.enchantedridge.com

The reason why she is trying to get rid of these puppies are because they were born with inguinal hernia's. So she doesn't want them since there defective dogs, and she can't get as much money from them, or she will have trouble selling them. She also stated in an instant message to me that she wants to get rid of all her dogs so she can move away from this hateful place, I'm assumeing she means Meckinok North Dakota were she resides cause everyone in that small town has had about enough of her there so there trying to run her out of town and I can't say that I blame them. As soon as I told her no I didn't want another dog from her she began ranting about how I somehow stabbed her in the back and she wants to leave North Dakota because of people like me which I find funny cause if I'm such a horrible person then why the heck would you want to give me another dog? She claims that she cares so much about her dogs then it makes no sense to try and give me more of them. The only thing I'm guilty of is being a victim of her scam to make people think there getting AKC puppies from her and you get the old bait and switch in paperwork. There contract on her web page she had up when I bought my dog was not the paperwork I was given when I went home with my puppy. This is what she states on her own web site:


Your new puppy will come with....


AKC Papers, Current Shots & Wormings, Lupine Collar, Toys, Blanket, 2 Year Health Guarantee and Litter Box Trained!!!

And she also stated that the Mom and Dad which were Kahlua and Smokey which are my dogs parents are AKC parents and advertised that on her page.

I still have yet to receive my AKC papers and my puppy was spayed at 6 months of age and she's 9 months old this month so what gives? I payed 650.00 for her. And then she has the nerve to say I stabbed her in the back? Ha! She's just mad that I saw this report and had my say and let people know the truth about her business practice.

She is by far mature in nature as she has a constant tendancy to contact you and harrass you with her immature rantings like a 6 year old child and then will log off of Aim like as if she said something that bothers me or maybe feels better about herself cause she thinks she had the last word. I actually feel sorry for her cause she is obviously mentally disturbed, or needs Jesus! I will be recording any further messages from her and sending them to our local D.A and posting them here as well, so hopefully she reads this and gets the message that I've had enough of her and she needs to stop contacting me from this day forward. And hopefully she will move out of our State for good. Amen!

11-11-08 5:45 PM- Anna Goodnoe calls me to offer another puppy, are you kidding me. I entered into one contract with her and she totally ripped me off, now she is scheming to do it again. You have got to be kidding. For those of you who don't know, my little sister was murdered and her remains recently discovered, Anna is the last thing on my mind. For her to call me up with this knowledge and try to scam my family again, is beyond belief and cruel.

I'm happy I was able to expose Enchanted Ridge, Anna Goodnoe and Aaron Goodnoe for what they truly are. Since my original posting several other unhappy consumers have come forward to tell their story despite the threats from the Goodnoe's. Be certain that you are not alone and you have nothing to fear from Anna Goodnoe or Aaron Goodnoe. Their empty threats are just that, empty.

I haven't been posting recently as my family has experienced a tragic loss. You may read the press release at www.sandraanngivens.com. You can also find my direct email address on that website to contact me regarding issues or questions with Enchanted Ridge, Anna Goodnoe and Aaron Goodnoe.

Enchanted Ridge has posted their own fantasy tale on their own website, however, if you have kept up with this ongoing saga I have left the email and the dates of the email posted above for everyone to judge for themselves and make the determination if this is truly a breeder they wish to purchase from.

I'd like to thank everyone who has read my complaint and posted their own experience with Enchanted Ridge without fear of Anna and Aaron Goodnoe. Since truth is on our side we have nothing to fear from the likes of them.

Hello, I am also a customer of Anna's and I bought a puppy from her back in April of 2008. I am normally not a confrontational person, and I normally don't like to complain unless it's neccessary, but after reading all these comments I have to get this off my shoulders cause I'm personally very upset about what happend to my family and I as of recently. I payed 650.00 for my chocolate/rust female. I read up on the breed for a few months before decideing to buy one of this type of breed so I was prepared for what the habits and personality of the breed would be like. I also became part of a Yahoo MinPin group to get insight of current breeders and owners of the breed and what they say about what it's like to own such a dog. So I did to my homework prior to buying this puppy. According to her website under her contract for people purchaseing puppies from her it states that once you have fullfilled your obligation and payed for the puppy in full and had the puppy spayed/nuetered and had paperwork in proof of this you will be given AKC papers. Unless you are a breeder and have agreed upon not spaying/neutering for breeding purposes.

I had gotten to know Anna a little during the waiting process for my puppy and she did seem like a decent person, but through time and getting to know her I noticed that she seemed like a type of Dr. Geckle, Mr. Hyde personality when things wouldn't go her way. IE. One time I was suppose to go to her residence and spend the day with her but she was worried about one of her puppies because he was loseing hair, and of course me being the type of person I am I figured it would be safer if I didn't come over and bring my dog with me in case whatever it was this puppy had was contagious. Well to make a long story short she freaked out on me! Sending me txt messages through MSN and telling me how messed up it was that one minute I wanted to come over and the next I didn't want to and that I should know better then to think I would put my dog at harm. After me trying to be the nicest person I could and calm her down I started to realize that this lady is a bit wierd and had a a horrible temper!

Well as time went on I had made the desision to bring my dog to get her spayed, and I even went one further and decided to bring my dog to her personal vet cause she said he was much cheaper and was more trust worthy then the vets in my hometown. So I Paypal her 200.00 for the vet fees ahead of time. But when I decided that day not to go over to her house she was sending me txt messages cussing at me and basically saying forget it and I'll send you a check in the mail when she can to reimburse me my 200.00. My theory was why would you have to send me a check in the mail when you have paypal and you know I do as well? That seemed odd to me.

Anyways she was going on this trip for approximatly 5 of her dogs anyways to get there teeth cleaned, and one had been injured and had a hip fracture and includeing the puppy that I was talking about earlier was loseing his hair so she was bringing him in to see if it was allergies or something else. She ended up getting a rental car, and she also rented a hotel room cause it was going to have to be an overnight stay seeing as the dogs had to be at the vet early in the morning and we felt it was easier that way. So to make a long story short I ended up paying 650.00 for the dog, 200.00 for the vet fees, half of the hotel stay which was about 30.00 and half for the rental car, and half for the gas. through all this time I had brought up plently of times about when I got my AKC papers under certain discussions includeing Obediance classes ect. and never once did she correct me about not getting AKC papers. Once I had payed her in full and had my puppy spayed I finally decided to ask for her AKC papers. She acted like I was crazy! She kept saying "What AKC Papers?" "What are you talking about?" I said the ones you claim on your website I get once I have fullfilled my end of the bargain in getting her all updated on shots, and getting her fixed! "She continued to act like I was the lost one and stated "Were is this comeing from?" And my response is on your website you state that once I have fullfilled my obligation in getting her spayed, and caught up to date on all shots I was given AKC papers. Well after going back and forth and her telling me she gave me no such contract I asked her well then why did you make me pay so much for her if she's not AKC registered? I even noticed even now according to their own contract it says you get AKC papers once you fullfill your obligation which I did, and she knows I did cause she was there when I did it. My dog costs the same as the ones she's selling even today and those come with AKC papers so what the hecks the deal? I feel I was ripped off cause if I'm going to pay as much as the next guy who gets papers then that's what I should of gotten. Otherwise I should have payed less for an unregistered Miniature Pinscher which costs no more then any mutt would have from the pound.
My thoery is don't advertise that the general public that buys your dogs are getting an AKC registered dog when that's not your practice, to me that's false advertising, and I have a family and kids that saw this whole thing take place so I have witnesses which is why I do not talk to her anymore and won't accept her phone calls.
Thank you and I'm glad I got that off my chest!

Hello Beverly I am also a customer of Enchanted Ridge MinPins and would love to ask you some questions and maybe I can get some help. Please contact me via e-mail if possible @ (((ROR REDACTED)))


CLICK here to see why Rip-off Report, as a matter of policy, deleted either a phone number, link or e-mail address from this Report.

anna claims on her webite, that SHE call AKC to come out and inspect her. I know for a fact that is not true, because I am the one who reported her to AKC.

Enchanted Ridge owners and breeders Anna and Aaron Goodnoe found that I filed another report regarding their website switch. They immediately called my home number late at night and made 4 follow-up calls in a row only 3 of which I answered. The first call went as follows:

9/4/08 9:15 pm
Bev: "Hello"
Anna: "B***ch" -hang up

9/4/08 9:16 pm
Bev: "Hello"
Anna: "Sucks to be a wh**e" - hang up

9/4/08 9:17 pm
Bev: "Hello"
Anna:"You know what liable is B**ch, I'll see you in court"

These phone calls were proceded up by an email that I didn't read until after the phone calls:
Thu, Sep 04, 2008 09:05 PM
Multiple Line Textbox 1 WATCH OUT BI**H!!! YOU WILL GET YOURS
One Line Textbox 1 B**CH
One Line Textbox 2 C*NT@GOF*CKYOURSLEF.COM

I've just edit the profanity but I do assure you that the words in their entirety are appear both on the phone recordings and email.

The above is evidence of the professionalism of Anna and Aaron Goodnoe. This is how they treat their unhappy clients. They steal money from people and expect them to just role over and take it. They also feel they are totally in the right to act and behave in an aggressive manner when confronted with their wrong doings. They are unhappy by the fact that they have multiple complaints with AKC, at least one complaint with the BBB and that their past bad behavior is finally catching up with them.

Their Northern Light Min Pins site was deleted and their Enchanted Ridge Website is partially up again. They sell their dogs on Nextdaypets, Quality pets and other pet websites. Next day and Quality pets are well aware of Anna Goodnoe's business practices and still lists them as a breeder. Buyers, please contact both AKC and the BBB before actually considering purchasing from Anna and Aaron Goodnoe. If this business was reputable they would do everything in their power to keep their business in good standing with both agencies. The BBB is sympathic to small businesses and do everything in their power to help business's resolve complaints. Anna and Aaron Goodnoe have not kept their word or made attempts to ethically resolve their complaints.

As with all scams they have to change their website. As for Anna she has abandoned the Enchanted Ridge Website and has started a new one call Northern Light Min Pins. Quality pets has her listed under both names as well next day pets. Anna Goodnoe doesn't list her name but be assured this is the same person who scammed me.

One of the TV Judge shows offered to take the case on TV. But Anna has refused. If in fact she thought she was in the right she could have accepted and still can accept. She knows she is nothing but a thief and con artist who will scam anyone she can.

Enchanted ridge has refused my many requests to return my money. They have illegally kept funds that rightfully belong to my family. These bad people lured my family on with promises of a puppy and have not deliverred. Enchanted Ridge is nothing more then a scam, to rip off families. They ARE BAD PEOPLE. BEWARE OF DOING BUSINESS WITH THEM. You can judge for yourself, all the email exchanges are listed. ANY COMPANY THAT TAKES MONEY AND DOES NOT DELIVER THE GOOD OR SERVICES PROMISED ARE BAD BUSINESSES RUN BY BAD PEOPLE.

I met Anna 3 years ago I bought a puppy from her. Since that time she has
helped me start my breeding program. She has helped me pick good dogs for
my program and i have bought a total of 4 dogs from her. I have never had a
problem with Anna or Aaron. They have helped me allot. I have drove to
their home to pick up all my dogs and i love the way her dogs look and act
all her dogs are very well socialized, healthy and happy. All her dogs
played with my kids while we were there. When i went to pickup my first dog
and all my other dogs from their home she offered me and my family to stay in
their home with them (at the time we were complete strangers). The one trip
we made up their our car broke down and Aaron and Anna went out of their way
to help us get the car fixed. If i have any questions i can call Anna at
any time day or night and she will give me the answers or find out the
answers and call right back. I just wanted to let people know that Anna and
Aaron are not bad people and they have NEVER lied to me or my family.

The email speaks for itself as for the mentality of Anna Goodnoe of Enchanted Ridge Min Pins. Typical. She is still trying to scam money from me and my family, after she has allready ripped us off for over $1100. Now she threatens to use the legal system to extort more money from me. Take note of the spelling, normally you see this type of thing with the South African scams.

Sent to Victim:

Nothing hads changed here. Once you remove the rip off report on me I will refund your money and no sooner! If it is not removed I will see you in court as their are laws that protect me from people like you that post lies on the Internet. You are mad at me because I tried to ship the puppy where you asked me to and the YOU changed your mind and that is my fault how? As far as I can see you are the one that is going along with the contract. You owe me money still it you want the puppy. I charge $35.00 a week but you know that you signed the contract. He is now almost 12 weeks so do the math.
You will not get away with posting all the false emails and lies about us. I will make sure of that. You are the only one here stopping the puppy from coming to you of the money coming to you. You agreed to remove the posting so just do it. I will give you to 10am on 8/8/08 to have it removed or I will go to the court house and file the paperwork. I have spoken to lawyers and I do have a great cast against you. So you have the final say here not me.
Let me know and I will do what I need to do to make this right for both of us.

On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 at 12:58 PM, wrote:
Anna,
I have already offered you a solution. I will not discuss this situation over the phone. You may contact me through email, regular mail or make an appointment through those two outlets to meet in person in public. I will not have a phone conversation regarding this situation.
Beverly

On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 at 11:15 AM, wrote:
K, Well to start we are not willing to do anything until you retract the lies that you posted about us. Once that is done and I know they have been removed we will talk about refunding money or giving you a puppy. But I will not do that until you retract the lies about us. You had NO RIGHT to post all those lies about us just because the temp where you live is so hot. You need to stop blaming my for something that is no way my fault. I was willing to ship the puppy for you to San Diego as you asked. So you need to tell all the places you lies to to remove your postings as they were nothing but lies and once that is dont we will get you out paperwork that you will need to sign and send back to us that states you will never post lies or anything false against us again. You know what you did was wrong otherwise you would not of sent my a email stating that is was. So please let me know as soon as you finish reporting the "TRUTH" that you did lie about us since you did not get what you wanted as soon as you wanted it to everyone you told that we were "SCAMERS"

On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 at 6:50 PM, wrote:
Anna,
Nothing I have stated is a lie, in each statement I've made I have supported it evidence. The only way that any of my statements could be untrue is if the contract was fulfilled as written or I was the recipient of a full refund. This did not occur. I have been reasonable in my requests for a full refund. Your demands below are fully unreasonable. There is no way to drop the Federal Criminal Report against you unless you have fully refunded my money or aherred to the written agreement. By keeping my money and not delivering the goods or services paid for YOU HAVE COMMITTED A CRIME!!! YOU ARE GOING TO BE PROSECUTED BY AUTHORITIES FOR THIS CRIME. By definition IF you return my money no crime was committed and authorities will be forced to drop the charges.

As for recanting my statements, I will notify 3 main agencies (not all of them) that you have promised to REFUND ALL MY MONEY. If this does not occur in 10 days I will ask the agencies to proceed with my compliant. I am being reasonable about this. If you wish to mediate this dispute you will have to be reasonable as well and put aside you defensiveness and personal feelings.

There is no way that I am signing another agreement or contract with you, that is a very unreasonable demand and it is not going to happen. Like I said by 10:00 pm tonight I will notify 3 agencies that you have agreed to FULLY REFUND MY MONEY. By 10 days time I expect a full refund and by default all other allegations and charges will be dropped and dismissed.
On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 09:44 PM, wrote:

First of all you have not stated the truth. You have submitted claims to these agencies and businesses using edited emails which is filing a false report, which is a crime. We could then move on to defamation of character and liable, these are also crimes. I have stated in every email I have sent you that I am willing to work with you on getting this puppy to you. You asked me to ship to San Diego and I made the arrangements, then you got upset with me and told me you would not drive to san diego. I have been trying to call you to tell you that I would be willing to absorb the extra shipping costs if you can drive to San Diego to pick up the puppy. If you would only pick up the phone this probably would have been resolved by now. I am not trying to squablle like a child here all that I want to do is to either get you your puppy or if you dont want him give you your refund. I will try in the morning to call you so that we can work out the details. I would really appreciate if you would pick up the phone so that we can get this issue resolved in a peaceful manner. If we can resolve this tomorrow I can have (weather permitting) the puppy to you in the next few days. However you need to remove all of your false posting and accusations from the internet and anywhere else you filed a complaint. Bottom line it all needs to be retracted and removed and you need to agree in writing not to do this any more. I dont want to be in this situation any more than you do, but you need to understand that I dont control the temp in Phx or what the airlines do, so neither of things are my fault. I would be able to ship in to San Diego (weather permitting) at this point as he weighs in at 2lbs 3 oz. Please answer your phone so that we can resolve this situation.
On Wed, Jul 23, 2008 at 10:01 AM, wrote:

As I already explained, I have supporting evidence that indicates my allegations are completely valid and true. As for editing email, you do realize that programs are available, that registers every keystroke. The computer forensic investigator can validate what I have already alleged. As for my involvement of criminal activity, that did not happen. I am the victim in this case. You allege defamation of character and liable, that is Civil Charges, which I will happily answer in court and there are rarely criminal penalties involved in Civil Complaints. You, on the other hand, are facing Criminal Charges; these types of charges do involve fines, jail time, probation, and possible loss of property; not to mention the lifetime criminal record, loss of civil rights, such as the right to vote and suspension of second amendment property rights. I know this because I am a 4th year criminology student; I study and understand the criminal justice system. Please do not try to misrepresent the facts concerning law. The choice is yours provide me with a full refund or face the consequences of you decisions.
Furthermore, I have stated in previous emails that I have no desire to have any phone conversations with you. At this point further phone calls will be considered harassment and will be dealt with in the appropriate manner. I WILL NOT DRIVE TO SAN DIEGO.
You now have 9 days to provide me with a full refund. If I do not have a full refund in 9 days, I will expand my notifications to:
Your County Supervisors, County Commissioners, County Representatives, County Assessors, County Recorder's Office, State Councilmen, State Congress and other State Reps. I will also notify every news outlet in your area about your activity and how I was swindled out of over $1100.00.
I have been more than fair; I will not be taken advantage of in this manner. The events set forth after the nine days grace period cannot be undone with a simple recant or refund. Please do discuss your options with an attorney before it is too late. It might help you to take all evidence associated with this to a competent uninvolved 3rd party and ask their advice or ask them what they would do in this situation. This is a serious manner, perhaps more serious then you realize.

On Tue Wed, Jul 23, 2008 08:13 PM, wrote:
So let me start with a very simple question. Do you want the puppy or not. A yes or no answer to this question will be absolutly fine. You are the one here that is making up stories and false allegations. I also have every email that you sent stating that you would gladly drive to san diego. As a matter of fact going to san diego was your idea. You really need to to go back and take a look at your actions, we have already stated that we would either refund your money or send you the puppy (which I am notifying you of again). You have been the one here that has been making this very difficult. Do you really expect everyone in life to just go ahead and jump through every hoop that you lay out for them. If you choose to request a refund you need to understand that it will take up to 10 days after you retract all of your allegations about us and a notarized letter stating that you wont be posting anymore or filing any other allegations of this sort anywhere. Those are the plain and simple facts, I wont have you going around telling false stories because you got mad that the temperatures in phoenix were to hot to ship your puppy. We have repeatedly offered many alternatives and you are simply not willing to work it out. I cant be the only bending over backwards here. I would love it if you would meet me somewhere in the middle. But the bottom line here is what do you want to do, do you want this puppy or not.

On Sat, Jul 26, 2008 at 12:24 AM, wrote:
Everything is spelled out in the agreement including on how the money will be delivered and how you will have the final notarized copy of the Mediation Agreement, it ends all business between me and enchanted ridge and also prohibits me from discussing the dispute or the agreement. I have sent a copy to *********** (I don't know ******* last name) but the agreement also protects her and her involvement as the mediator of our dispute.

I can have a notarized copy to her as early as tomorrow, please let her know when she can expect the cashiers check or money order. I'd like to have this business completed in no more then 7 business days. The agreement reads like this and is not valid until signed, this is only a draft please discuss any revisions with *******:

MEDIATION AGREEMENT
This is an agreement between the Beverly ******. (Hereafter known as the "Claimant") and Anna Goodnoe of Enchanted Ridge Min Pins_ (identified herein as a "party" or as the "parties".)
1) The parties and Claimant have mutually decided to end their contract.
2) Mediation is a structured problem-solving process in which a neutral, impartial third person or persons assists the parties to reach a voluntary agreement to resolve the matters in issue refund for puppy purchased but not delivered by party.
3) Claimant and Parties have assigned Cindy ************* to mediate this dispute. A different mediator or mediators may be assigned if party advises Claimant of circumstances, which would cause any question regarding the appropriateness of the assigned mediator.
4) The party agrees to refund Claimant at a rate of One Thousand one Hundred and No/100 Dollars ($1100.00).
5) In return, of funds by party ends consumer dispute and claimant has contacted and retract the consumer complaint disputes claimant has filed. If the agency refused to remove complaint claimant agrees to update all reports with a statement of satisfactory results and mediated dispute resolution.
6) Claimant agrees that Parties have fulfilled their agreement and claimant will not make any other consumer reports alleging otherwise.
7) Claimant agrees not to discuss dispute with any other website or through electronic communications unless it is to report satisfactory results or defend against civil or criminal allegations.
8) The Parties adopt the following statements of principle regarding mediation:
(a) Mediation will be conducted in a spirit of cooperation.
(b) The major criteria for decision making will be:
The needs of all parties
Standards of fairness as agreed to by the parties
9) The mediator will control the procedural aspects of the mediation. The mediator will be free to meet and communicate separately with each party. The mediator will decide when to hold joint and/or separate meetings with the parties and shall, in consultation with the parties, fix the time, place, and agenda of each session. The Mediator will hold both the settlement contract and the refund by certified cashier's check or money order.
9) The mediation process will be confidential. The mediator may not be called to testify as a witness, consultant, or expert in any pending or future action relating to the subject matter of the mediation. Neither party may seek to introduce, for any purpose, evidence of a statement or of conduct during mediation at any trial or hearing that may later be held between the parties.
10) The mediator will not provide legal advice or legal representation for any party and does not represent either party.
11) Additional rules and procedures for the mediation may be negotiated and agreed upon by the mediator and the parties at any time during the mediation process.
12) The Claimant and parties acknowledge that they have read this agreement and reviewed it with the mediator, that they understand the agreement, that each has received a copy.

On Sat, Jul 26, 2008 08:41 PM, wrote:

Beverly,
My name is Aaron Goodnoe, I am annas husband and I am going to be the one that is dealing with this process. I was wondering if you would be ok if I called you to discuss revissions to this agreement? Please send an email back to this address and let me know one way or another. I think that we can have this resolved quickly and painlessly, I would just like you to give me the opputunity to do so.
Thanks Aaron Goodnoe

On Tue, Jul 29, 2008 08:31 AM, wrote:


Very well,
My first revision and also the most important is going to be that the complaint must be sucessfully removed from the website. Having reports simply updated will not be satisfactory. No refund will be made until such time as the complaint is removed. At the point of removal of the complaint I will send out the refund via fed ex and provide you with a tracking number. You now have in writing that once the complaint is removed that I WILL send you your refund.

On Tue, Jul 29, 2008 at 8:05 PM, wrote:
Now you are asking for the impossible, once a complaint is made, like the bbb and AKC, it is put on your permanent record along with the fact that it was either resolved or not resolved and whether the results were satisfactory or not by inserting you unreasonable conditions you are denying me access to ever getting MY MONEY BACK. I'm not going to go around and around about this with you and I'm not going to say the incident has been cleared when in fact it hasn't. I like that YOU have chosen a mediator and I agree to hand her the contract signed and notarized and have her hold the contract until conditions have been satisfied, I'm willing to be reasonable, but I will not be taken advantage of and conned any longer. I WILL NOT PERFORM MIRACLES FOR YOU. YOU have to be reasonable. If YOU will not be reasonable I have already made you aware of the consequences of bad business practices and I will continue with the criminal charges. You have 5 more business days to complete this. I will not wait one hour, one minute or one second after the deadline. A promise of a fed ex parcel is unreasonable, the mediator is the holder of both the cashiers check/ money order and the contract; the contract laid out is fair and reasonable to all parties involved including that poor lady who agreed to speak to me about you. She has been put in a very uncomfortable position and is doing her best to try and salvage your reputation and business. She has to deal with two very angry parties and she considers you as her friends.

You have 5 more business days and that is final.

On Tue, Jul 29, 2008 08:22 PM, wrote:


Listen , I am not being unreasonable to ask that an acuusation that is false "scam artist"..."A variation of the baby adoption scams This breeder leads families on and then breaks their hearts" be removed. You lied when you posted on that website and asking you to remove a lie is not asking the impossible all that you need to do is to inform these people that you lied. I will not deny your money if you are willing to tell the truth. I understand that you put emails up there also, but the bottom line is that we are not scam artists. This is not variation of an adoption scam. If you will promise me removal of this posting once you have your moeny then maybe we can work something out that way. I'm not being unreasonable at all. I dont know if you noticed all of the reviews on the website. Those are from people that have sucessfully recieved thier puppies and are very happy with them. I am not trying to to advantage of you at all. I am trying to restore what is left of my wifes reputation. You seem to be hellbent on destroying it. I would think that as a breeder you would understand that someones reputation is very important to them. How would you like it if someone posted lies about you on that website. I would love to see you try and ship a puppy into north dakota in the middle of the winter......its not going to happen because of the temperature here in the winter. That is no different than what we were dealing with trying to ship to phoenix in the summer time. No one wnated to scam you here you need to take a step back and look at this from a different perspective. Had you not posted all of these things online you would have already had your money by now. I am really trying to get through this ordeal peacefully and calmly. So please work with me here you dont need to be yelling at me in your emails. I am not treating you with any disrespect and I would appreciate the same. If you are not willing to come to some sort of an agreement that both parties can live with than you wont have your money in 5 business days. I would also appreciate it if you would stop making threats towards myself and my wife. Lastly I do not see how it is your place to set a deadline if you are not willing to make constructive comments instead of just calling me unreasonable. I'm sure that I will be speaking with you soon

Aaron Goodnoe

On Wed, Jul 30, 2008 at 12:53 AM, wrote:
First, I am not lying and I am not going to say that I was lying to make you feel better about what you have done to me and my family. As for business matters, I have frequently shipped to Canada and Alaska in the middle of winter and never went back on my word with a client even if it has involved a little more money. I make things right with my clients and have never had a complaint, my dogs are all delivered on time because I do care about my business, my clients and my puppies. So you can get off both those rants right there.
As I still see it, I haven't got the puppy and I haven't got my money hence you are running a scam. You asked for a mediator and I agreed to your terms. Giving both the money and contract to a third party is wise and reasonable. As for taking the tag line down, that will not happen until a third party has the money in their hand, so if you don't like the mediator choose another.
The report will always be on consumer complaints web site it will just be moved to the resolved category with a glowing response about our business dealings and how you went out of your way to resolve the conflict. You still have 5 more business day, I am not going around this with you. If you would like, I will add a comment to that tag indicating you are working with a mediator to resolve the dispute, but my deadline is not negotiable.


On Thu, Jul 31, 2008 09:46 PM, wrote:
I am no longer going to deal with someone as crazy as you are. You are doing nothing but lying to make your self feel better. I DO HAVE proof that you are nothing other then a liar. I have never gone back on my word like you have. Their are laws that will help me deal with you. And as for you filing a report that is false well the law will deal with you and maybe you will spend some time in jail where you will have the time to think about the awful things you have posted about me and MY FAMILY. I have never had to deal with someone like you. As far as I can see you broke the contract by not letting me ship the puppy like I planned. So you will NEVER see your deposit. You signed a contract that said you understand the deposit is NON REFUNDABLE. NOW THAT I HAVE PROOF (FROM MORE THEN A FEW PEOPLE) THAT YOU ARE HURTING MY LIFE AND MY BREEDING PROGRAM I WILL SEE YOU IN COURT. I WILL SUE YOU FOR MY LOSSES. You never have a right to post lies and YES that is what you did!!!! But you already know that. I will not sit back and let you walk all over me I am a better person then you could ever be. You are nothing other than a sad person that does nothing other then hurting people for fun. So I have nothing left to say to you other than I WILL SEE YOU IN COURT!!! I will stand up for my business always. I have never done anything wrong and I do have many VERY HAPPY puppy buyers that will stand behind me here. So get ready for the fight of your life!! I WIll not and have NEVER put up with people that lie to hurt an innocent person. You really should find a job so you dont have so much time on your hands to make up lies about me or anyone else for that matter.
Anna


On Thu, Jul 31, 2008 10:06 PM, wrote:


Dear Anna,
I'd be happy to answer any charges you bring up in court in addition I will enter a counter suit. I'm am certain that when this reaches a court of law that it will be settled in my favor. I'm disappointed that mediations attempts with you have failed. Since your agreed upon mediator contacted me this evening and made it clear that you do not wish to continue mediation, and an amicable solution to our transaction is impossible. I will continue with criminal prosecution as well as notification of you activities to the aforementioned authorites and agencies. At this point I chose not to do
business with you anymore, Please refund the entirety of monies paid to you, since YOU have not fulfilled the terms of our contract.

Sincerely,
Beverly Sills

On Thu, Jul 31, 2008 10:12 PM, wrote:

Just so that we are clear. The fact that I will be bringing you to court for damages and liable has nothing to do with the fact that the weather in Phx is still to hot to ship. Since you last said, when I asked that you still want the puppy. As soon as the temp is cooler you will certainly get your puppy unless you decide that you dont want your puppy in which case you would be breaking the contract. Look you could very easily have come to me before going psychotic and posting lies online and you could have already gone to San Diego and picked up your puppy. This could have been worked out weeks ago. I really regret ever having met you, all that you have done is bring stress and misery to me and my family. I cant wait to ship your puppy to you so that I never have to deal with you again.

On Fri, Aug 01, 2008 06:13 AM, wrote:

Dear Anna,
I stand by my last email. I would answer any charges you bring up in court as I am certain when this reaches a court of law it will be settled in my favor. I am disappointed that mediations attempts with you have failed. Since your agreed upon mediator contacted me and made it clear that you do not wish to continue mediation, and an amicable solution to our transaction is impossible. I have continued with criminal prosecution as well as notification of your activities to the aforementioned authorities
and agencies. At this point I chose not to do business with you anymore, Please refund the entirety of monies paid to you, since YOU have not fulfilled the terms of our contract.

Sincerely,
Beverly

On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 at 12:58 PM, wrote:
Anna,
I have already offered you a solution. I will not discuss this situation over the phone. You may contact me through email, regular mail or make an appointment through those two outlets to meet in person in public. I will not have a phone conversation regarding this situation.
Beverly

On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 at 11:15 AM, wrote:
K, Well to start we are not willing to do anything until you retract the lies that you posted about us. Once that is done and I know they have been removed we will talk about refunding money or giving you a puppy. But I will not do that until you retract the lies about us. You had NO RIGHT to post all those lies about us just because the temp where you live is so hot. You need to stop blaming my for something that is no way my fault. I was willing to ship the puppy for you to San Diego as you asked. So you need to tell all the places you lies to to remove your postings as they were nothing but lies and once that is dont we will get you out paperwork that you will need to sign and send back to us that states you will never post lies or anything false against us again. You know what you did was wrong otherwise you would not of sent my a email stating that is was. So please let me know as soon as you finish reporting the "TRUTH" that you did lie about us since you did not get what you wanted as soon as you wanted it to everyone you told that we were "SCAMERS"

On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 at 6:50 PM, wrote:
Anna,
Nothing I have stated is a lie, in each statement I've made I have supported it evidence. The only way that any of my statements could be untrue is if the contract was fulfilled as written or I was the recipient of a full refund. This did not occur. I have been reasonable in my requests for a full refund. Your demands below are fully unreasonable. There is no way to drop the Federal Criminal Report against you unless you have fully refunded my money or aherred to the written agreement. By keeping my money and not delivering the goods or services paid for YOU HAVE COMMITTED A CRIME!!! YOU ARE GOING TO BE PROSECUTED BY AUTHORITIES FOR THIS CRIME. By definition IF you return my money no crime was committed and authorities will be forced to drop the charges.

As for recanting my statements, I will notify 3 main agencies (not all of them) that you have promised to REFUND ALL MY MONEY. If this does not occur in 10 days I will ask the agencies to proceed with my compliant. I am being reasonable about this. If you wish to mediate this dispute you will have to be reasonable as well and put aside you defensiveness and personal feelings.

There is no way that I am signing another agreement or contract with you, that is a very unreasonable demand and it is not going to happen. Like I said by 10:00 pm tonight I will notify 3 agencies that you have agreed to FULLY REFUND MY MONEY. By 10 days time I expect a full refund and by default all other allegations and charges will be dropped and dismissed.
On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 09:44 PM, wrote:

First of all you have not stated the truth. You have submitted claims to these agencies and businesses using edited emails which is filing a false report, which is a crime. We could then move on to defamation of character and liable, these are also crimes. I have stated in every email I have sent you that I am willing to work with you on getting this puppy to you. You asked me to ship to San Diego and I made the arrangements, then you got upset with me and told me you would not drive to san diego. I have been trying to call you to tell you that I would be willing to absorb the extra shipping costs if you can drive to San Diego to pick up the puppy. If you would only pick up the phone this probably would have been resolved by now. I am not trying to squablle like a child here all that I want to do is to either get you your puppy or if you dont want him give you your refund. I will try in the morning to call you so that we can work out the details. I would really appreciate if you would pick up the phone so that we can get this issue resolved in a peaceful manner. If we can resolve this tomorrow I can have (weather permitting) the puppy to you in the next few days. However you need to remove all of your false posting and accusations from the internet and anywhere else you filed a complaint. Bottom line it all needs to be retracted and removed and you need to agree in writing not to do this any more. I dont want to be in this situation any more than you do, but you need to understand that I dont control the temp in Phx or what the airlines do, so neither of things are my fault. I would be able to ship in to San Diego (weather permitting) at this point as he weighs in at 2lbs 3 oz. Please answer your phone so that we can resolve this situation.
On Wed, Jul 23, 2008 at 10:01 AM, wrote:

As I already explained, I have supporting evidence that indicates my allegations are completely valid and true. As for editing email, you do realize that programs are available, that registers every keystroke. The computer forensic investigator can validate what I have already alleged. As for my involvement of criminal activity, that did not happen. I am the victim in this case. You allege defamation of character and liable, that is Civil Charges, which I will happily answer in court and there are rarely criminal penalties involved in Civil Complaints. You, on the other hand, are facing Criminal Charges; these types of charges do involve fines, jail time, probation, and possible loss of property; not to mention the lifetime criminal record, loss of civil rights, such as the right to vote and suspension of second amendment property rights. I know this because I am a 4th year criminology student; I study and understand the criminal justice system. Please do not try to misrepresent the facts concerning law. The choice is yours provide me with a full refund or face the consequences of you decisions.
Furthermore, I have stated in previous emails that I have no desire to have any phone conversations with you. At this point further phone calls will be considered harassment and will be dealt with in the appropriate manner. I WILL NOT DRIVE TO SAN DIEGO.
You now have 9 days to provide me with a full refund. If I do not have a full refund in 9 days, I will expand my notifications to:
Your County Supervisors, County Commissioners, County Representatives, County Assessors, County Recorder's Office, State Councilmen, State Congress and other State Reps. I will also notify every news outlet in your area about your activity and how I was swindled out of over $1100.00.
I have been more than fair; I will not be taken advantage of in this manner. The events set forth after the nine days grace period cannot be undone with a simple recant or refund. Please do discuss your options with an attorney before it is too late. It might help you to take all evidence associated with this to a competent uninvolved 3rd party and ask their advice or ask them what they would do in this situation. This is a serious manner, perhaps more serious then you realize.

On Tue Wed, Jul 23, 2008 08:13 PM, wrote:
So let me start with a very simple question. Do you want the puppy or not. A yes or no answer to this question will be absolutly fine. You are the one here that is making up stories and false allegations. I also have every email that you sent stating that you would gladly drive to san diego. As a matter of fact going to san diego was your idea. You really need to to go back and take a look at your actions, we have already stated that we would either refund your money or send you the puppy (which I am notifying you of again). You have been the one here that has been making this very difficult. Do you really expect everyone in life to just go ahead and jump through every hoop that you lay out for them. If you choose to request a refund you need to understand that it will take up to 10 days after you retract all of your allegations about us and a notarized letter stating that you wont be posting anymore or filing any other allegations of this sort anywhere. Those are the plain and simple facts, I wont have you going around telling false stories because you got mad that the temperatures in phoenix were to hot to ship your puppy. We have repeatedly offered many alternatives and you are simply not willing to work it out. I cant be the only bending over backwards here. I would love it if you would meet me somewhere in the middle. But the bottom line here is what do you want to do, do you want this puppy or not.

On Sat, Jul 26, 2008 at 12:24 AM, wrote:
Everything is spelled out in the agreement including on how the money will be delivered and how you will have the final notarized copy of the Mediation Agreement, it ends all business between me and enchanted ridge and also prohibits me from discussing the dispute or the agreement. I have sent a copy to *********** (I don't know ******* last name) but the agreement also protects her and her involvement as the mediator of our dispute.

I can have a notarized copy to her as early as tomorrow, please let her know when she can expect the cashiers check or money order. I'd like to have this business completed in no more then 7 business days. The agreement reads like this and is not valid until signed, this is only a draft please discuss any revisions with *******:

MEDIATION AGREEMENT
This is an agreement between the Beverly ******. (Hereafter known as the "Claimant") and Anna Goodnoe of Enchanted Ridge Min Pins_ (identified herein as a "party" or as the "parties".)
1) The parties and Claimant have mutually decided to end their contract.
2) Mediation is a structured problem-solving process in which a neutral, impartial third person or persons assists the parties to reach a voluntary agreement to resolve the matters in issue refund for puppy purchased but not delivered by party.
3) Claimant and Parties have assigned Cindy ************* to mediate this dispute. A different mediator or mediators may be assigned if party advises Claimant of circumstances, which would cause any question regarding the appropriateness of the assigned mediator.
4) The party agrees to refund Claimant at a rate of One Thousand one Hundred and No/100 Dollars ($1100.00).
5) In return, of funds by party ends consumer dispute and claimant has contacted and retract the consumer complaint disputes claimant has filed. If the agency refused to remove complaint claimant agrees to update all reports with a statement of satisfactory results and mediated dispute resolution.
6) Claimant agrees that Parties have fulfilled their agreement and claimant will not make any other consumer reports alleging otherwise.
7) Claimant agrees not to discuss dispute with any other website or through electronic communications unless it is to report satisfactory results or defend against civil or criminal allegations.
8) The Parties adopt the following statements of principle regarding mediation:
(a) Mediation will be conducted in a spirit of cooperation.
(b) The major criteria for decision making will be:
The needs of all parties
Standards of fairness as agreed to by the parties
9) The mediator will control the procedural aspects of the mediation. The mediator will be free to meet and communicate separately with each party. The mediator will decide when to hold joint and/or separate meetings with the parties and shall, in consultation with the parties, fix the time, place, and agenda of each session. The Mediator will hold both the settlement contract and the refund by certified cashier's check or money order.
9) The mediation process will be confidential. The mediator may not be called to testify as a witness, consultant, or expert in any pending or future action relating to the subject matter of the mediation. Neither party may seek to introduce, for any purpose, evidence of a statement or of conduct during mediation at any trial or hearing that may later be held between the parties.
10) The mediator will not provide legal advice or legal representation for any party and does not represent either party.
11) Additional rules and procedures for the mediation may be negotiated and agreed upon by the mediator and the parties at any time during the mediation process.
12) The Claimant and parties acknowledge that they have read this agreement and reviewed it with the mediator, that they understand the agreement, that each has received a copy.

On Sat, Jul 26, 2008 08:41 PM, wrote:

Beverly,
My name is Aaron Goodnoe, I am annas husband and I am going to be the one that is dealing with this process. I was wondering if you would be ok if I called you to discuss revissions to this agreement? Please send an email back to this address and let me know one way or another. I think that we can have this resolved quickly and painlessly, I would just like you to give me the opputunity to do so.
Thanks Aaron Goodnoe

On Tue, Jul 29, 2008 08:31 AM, wrote:


Very well,
My first revision and also the most important is going to be that the complaint must be sucessfully removed from the website. Having reports simply updated will not be satisfactory. No refund will be made until such time as the complaint is removed. At the point of removal of the complaint I will send out the refund via fed ex and provide you with a tracking number. You now have in writing that once the complaint is removed that I WILL send you your refund.

On Tue, Jul 29, 2008 at 8:05 PM, wrote:
Now you are asking for the impossible, once a complaint is made, like the bbb and AKC, it is put on your permanent record along with the fact that it was either resolved or not resolved and whether the results were satisfactory or not by inserting you unreasonable conditions you are denying me access to ever getting MY MONEY BACK. I'm not going to go around and around about this with you and I'm not going to say the incident has been cleared when in fact it hasn't. I like that YOU have chosen a mediator and I agree to hand her the contract signed and notarized and have her hold the contract until conditions have been satisfied, I'm willing to be reasonable, but I will not be taken advantage of and conned any longer. I WILL NOT PERFORM MIRACLES FOR YOU. YOU have to be reasonable. If YOU will not be reasonable I have already made you aware of the consequences of bad business practices and I will continue with the criminal charges. You have 5 more business days to complete this. I will not wait one hour, one minute or one second after the deadline. A promise of a fed ex parcel is unreasonable, the mediator is the holder of both the cashiers check/ money order and the contract; the contract laid out is fair and reasonable to all parties involved including that poor lady who agreed to speak to me about you. She has been put in a very uncomfortable position and is doing her best to try and salvage your reputation and business. She has to deal with two very angry parties and she considers you as her friends.

You have 5 more business days and that is final.

On Tue, Jul 29, 2008 08:22 PM, wrote:


Listen , I am not being unreasonable to ask that an acuusation that is false "scam artist"..."A variation of the baby adoption scams This breeder leads families on and then breaks their hearts" be removed. You lied when you posted on that website and asking you to remove a lie is not asking the impossible all that you need to do is to inform these people that you lied. I will not deny your money if you are willing to tell the truth. I understand that you put emails up there also, but the bottom line is that we are not scam artists. This is not variation of an adoption scam. If you will promise me removal of this posting once you have your moeny then maybe we can work something out that way. I'm not being unreasonable at all. I dont know if you noticed all of the reviews on the website. Those are from people that have sucessfully recieved thier puppies and are very happy with them. I am not trying to to advantage of you at all. I am trying to restore what is left of my wifes reputation. You seem to be hellbent on destroying it. I would think that as a breeder you would understand that someones reputation is very important to them. How would you like it if someone posted lies about you on that website. I would love to see you try and ship a puppy into north dakota in the middle of the winter......its not going to happen because of the temperature here in the winter. That is no different than what we were dealing with trying to ship to phoenix in the summer time. No one wnated to scam you here you need to take a step back and look at this from a different perspective. Had you not posted all of these things online you would have already had your money by now. I am really trying to get through this ordeal peacefully and calmly. So please work with me here you dont need to be yelling at me in your emails. I am not treating you with any disrespect and I would appreciate the same. If you are not willing to come to some sort of an agreement that both parties can live with than you wont have your money in 5 business days. I would also appreciate it if you would stop making threats towards myself and my wife. Lastly I do not see how it is your place to set a deadline if you are not willing to make constructive comments instead of just calling me unreasonable. I'm sure that I will be speaking with you soon

Aaron Goodnoe

On Wed, Jul 30, 2008 at 12:53 AM, wrote:
First, I am not lying and I am not going to say that I was lying to make you feel better about what you have done to me and my family. As for business matters, I have frequently shipped to Canada and Alaska in the middle of winter and never went back on my word with a client even if it has involved a little more money. I make things right with my clients and have never had a complaint, my dogs are all delivered on time because I do care about my business, my clients and my puppies. So you can get off both those rants right there.
As I still see it, I haven't got the puppy and I haven't got my money hence you are running a scam. You asked for a mediator and I agreed to your terms. Giving both the money and contract to a third party is wise and reasonable. As for taking the tag line down, that will not happen until a third party has the money in their hand, so if you don't like the mediator choose another.
The report will always be on consumer complaints web site it will just be moved to the resolved category with a glowing response about our business dealings and how you went out of your way to resolve the conflict. You still have 5 more business day, I am not going around this with you. If you would like, I will add a comment to that tag indicating you are working with a mediator to resolve the dispute, but my deadline is not negotiable.


On Thu, Jul 31, 2008 09:46 PM, wrote:
I am no longer going to deal with someone as crazy as you are. You are doing nothing but lying to make your self feel better. I DO HAVE proof that you are nothing other then a liar. I have never gone back on my word like you have. Their are laws that will help me deal with you. And as for you filing a report that is false well the law will deal with you and maybe you will spend some time in jail where you will have the time to think about the awful things you have posted about me and MY FAMILY. I have never had to deal with someone like you. As far as I can see you broke the contract by not letting me ship the puppy like I planned. So you will NEVER see your deposit. You signed a contract that said you understand the deposit is NON REFUNDABLE. NOW THAT I HAVE PROOF (FROM MORE THEN A FEW PEOPLE) THAT YOU ARE HURTING MY LIFE AND MY BREEDING PROGRAM I WILL SEE YOU IN COURT. I WILL SUE YOU FOR MY LOSSES. You never have a right to post lies and YES that is what you did!!!! But you already know that. I will not sit back and let you walk all over me I am a better person then you could ever be. You are nothing other than a sad person that does nothing other then hurting people for fun. So I have nothing left to say to you other than I WILL SEE YOU IN COURT!!! I will stand up for my business always. I have never done anything wrong and I do have many VERY HAPPY puppy buyers that will stand behind me here. So get ready for the fight of your life!! I WIll not and have NEVER put up with people that lie to hurt an innocent person. You really should find a job so you dont have so much time on your hands to make up lies about me or anyone else for that matter.
Anna


On Thu, Jul 31, 2008 10:06 PM, wrote:


Dear Anna,
I'd be happy to answer any charges you bring up in court in addition I will enter a counter suit. I'm am certain that when this reaches a court of law that it will be settled in my favor. I'm disappointed that mediations attempts with you have failed. Since your agreed upon mediator contacted me this evening and made it clear that you do not wish to continue mediation, and an amicable solution to our transaction is impossible. I will continue with criminal prosecution as well as notification of you activities to the aforementioned authorites and agencies. At this point I chose not to do
business with you anymore, Please refund the entirety of monies paid to you, since YOU have not fulfilled the terms of our contract.

Sincerely,
Beverly Sills

On Thu, Jul 31, 2008 10:12 PM, wrote:

Just so that we are clear. The fact that I will be bringing you to court for damages and liable has nothing to do with the fact that the weather in Phx is still to hot to ship. Since you last said, when I asked that you still want the puppy. As soon as the temp is cooler you will certainly get your puppy unless you decide that you dont want your puppy in which case you would be breaking the contract. Look you could very easily have come to me before going psychotic and posting lies online and you could have already gone to San Diego and picked up your puppy. This could have been worked out weeks ago. I really regret ever having met you, all that you have done is bring stress and misery to me and my family. I cant wait to ship your puppy to you so that I never have to deal with you again.

On Fri, Aug 01, 2008 06:13 AM, wrote:

Dear Anna,
I stand by my last email. I would answer any charges you bring up in court as I am certain when this reaches a court of law it will be settled in my favor. I am disappointed that mediations attempts with you have failed. Since your agreed upon mediator contacted me and made it clear that you do not wish to continue mediation, and an amicable solution to our transaction is impossible. I have continued with criminal prosecution as well as notification of your activities to the aforementioned authorities
and agencies. At this point I chose not to do business with you anymore, Please refund the entirety of monies paid to you, since YOU have not fulfilled the terms of our contract.

Sincerely,
Beverly

On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 at 12:58 PM, wrote:
Anna,
I have already offered you a solution. I will not discuss this situation over the phone. You may contact me through email, regular mail or make an appointment through those two outlets to meet in person in public. I will not have a phone conversation regarding this situation.
Beverly

On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 at 11:15 AM, wrote:
K, Well to start we are not willing to do anything until you retract the lies that you posted about us. Once that is done and I know they have been removed we will talk about refunding money or giving you a puppy. But I will not do that until you retract the lies about us. You had NO RIGHT to post all those lies about us just because the temp where you live is so hot. You need to stop blaming my for something that is no way my fault. I was willing to ship the puppy for you to San Diego as you asked. So you need to tell all the places you lies to to remove your postings as they were nothing but lies and once that is dont we will get you out paperwork that you will need to sign and send back to us that states you will never post lies or anything false against us again. You know what you did was wrong otherwise you would not of sent my a email stating that is was. So please let me know as soon as you finish reporting the "TRUTH" that you did lie about us since you did not get what you wanted as soon as you wanted it to everyone you told that we were "SCAMERS"

On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 at 6:50 PM, wrote:
Anna,
Nothing I have stated is a lie, in each statement I've made I have supported it evidence. The only way that any of my statements could be untrue is if the contract was fulfilled as written or I was the recipient of a full refund. This did not occur. I have been reasonable in my requests for a full refund. Your demands below are fully unreasonable. There is no way to drop the Federal Criminal Report against you unless you have fully refunded my money or aherred to the written agreement. By keeping my money and not delivering the goods or services paid for YOU HAVE COMMITTED A CRIME!!! YOU ARE GOING TO BE PROSECUTED BY AUTHORITIES FOR THIS CRIME. By definition IF you return my money no crime was committed and authorities will be forced to drop the charges.

As for recanting my statements, I will notify 3 main agencies (not all of them) that you have promised to REFUND ALL MY MONEY. If this does not occur in 10 days I will ask the agencies to proceed with my compliant. I am being reasonable about this. If you wish to mediate this dispute you will have to be reasonable as well and put aside you defensiveness and personal feelings.

There is no way that I am signing another agreement or contract with you, that is a very unreasonable demand and it is not going to happen. Like I said by 10:00 pm tonight I will notify 3 agencies that you have agreed to FULLY REFUND MY MONEY. By 10 days time I expect a full refund and by default all other allegations and charges will be dropped and dismissed.
On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 09:44 PM, wrote:

First of all you have not stated the truth. You have submitted claims to these agencies and businesses using edited emails which is filing a false report, which is a crime. We could then move on to defamation of character and liable, these are also crimes. I have stated in every email I have sent you that I am willing to work with you on getting this puppy to you. You asked me to ship to San Diego and I made the arrangements, then you got upset with me and told me you would not drive to san diego. I have been trying to call you to tell you that I would be willing to absorb the extra shipping costs if you can drive to San Diego to pick up the puppy. If you would only pick up the phone this probably would have been resolved by now. I am not trying to squablle like a child here all that I want to do is to either get you your puppy or if you dont want him give you your refund. I will try in the morning to call you so that we can work out the details. I would really appreciate if you would pick up the phone so that we can get this issue resolved in a peaceful manner. If we can resolve this tomorrow I can have (weather permitting) the puppy to you in the next few days. However you need to remove all of your false posting and accusations from the internet and anywhere else you filed a complaint. Bottom line it all needs to be retracted and removed and you need to agree in writing not to do this any more. I dont want to be in this situation any more than you do, but you need to understand that I dont control the temp in Phx or what the airlines do, so neither of things are my fault. I would be able to ship in to San Diego (weather permitting) at this point as he weighs in at 2lbs 3 oz. Please answer your phone so that we can resolve this situation.
On Wed, Jul 23, 2008 at 10:01 AM, wrote:

As I already explained, I have supporting evidence that indicates my allegations are completely valid and true. As for editing email, you do realize that programs are available, that registers every keystroke. The computer forensic investigator can validate what I have already alleged. As for my involvement of criminal activity, that did not happen. I am the victim in this case. You allege defamation of character and liable, that is Civil Charges, which I will happily answer in court and there are rarely criminal penalties involved in Civil Complaints. You, on the other hand, are facing Criminal Charges; these types of charges do involve fines, jail time, probation, and possible loss of property; not to mention the lifetime criminal record, loss of civil rights, such as the right to vote and suspension of second amendment property rights. I know this because I am a 4th year criminology student; I study and understand the criminal justice system. Please do not try to misrepresent the facts concerning law. The choice is yours provide me with a full refund or face the consequences of you decisions.
Furthermore, I have stated in previous emails that I have no desire to have any phone conversations with you. At this point further phone calls will be considered harassment and will be dealt with in the appropriate manner. I WILL NOT DRIVE TO SAN DIEGO.
You now have 9 days to provide me with a full refund. If I do not have a full refund in 9 days, I will expand my notifications to:
Your County Supervisors, County Commissioners, County Representatives, County Assessors, County Recorder's Office, State Councilmen, State Congress and other State Reps. I will also notify every news outlet in your area about your activity and how I was swindled out of over $1100.00.
I have been more than fair; I will not be taken advantage of in this manner. The events set forth after the nine days grace period cannot be undone with a simple recant or refund. Please do discuss your options with an attorney before it is too late. It might help you to take all evidence associated with this to a competent uninvolved 3rd party and ask their advice or ask them what they would do in this situation. This is a serious manner, perhaps more serious then you realize.

On Tue Wed, Jul 23, 2008 08:13 PM, wrote:
So let me start with a very simple question. Do you want the puppy or not. A yes or no answer to this question will be absolutly fine. You are the one here that is making up stories and false allegations. I also have every email that you sent stating that you would gladly drive to san diego. As a matter of fact going to san diego was your idea. You really need to to go back and take a look at your actions, we have already stated that we would either refund your money or send you the puppy (which I am notifying you of again). You have been the one here that has been making this very difficult. Do you really expect everyone in life to just go ahead and jump through every hoop that you lay out for them. If you choose to request a refund you need to understand that it will take up to 10 days after you retract all of your allegations about us and a notarized letter stating that you wont be posting anymore or filing any other allegations of this sort anywhere. Those are the plain and simple facts, I wont have you going around telling false stories because you got mad that the temperatures in phoenix were to hot to ship your puppy. We have repeatedly offered many alternatives and you are simply not willing to work it out. I cant be the only bending over backwards here. I would love it if you would meet me somewhere in the middle. But the bottom line here is what do you want to do, do you want this puppy or not.

On Sat, Jul 26, 2008 at 12:24 AM, wrote:
Everything is spelled out in the agreement including on how the money will be delivered and how you will have the final notarized copy of the Mediation Agreement, it ends all business between me and enchanted ridge and also prohibits me from discussing the dispute or the agreement. I have sent a copy to *********** (I don't know ******* last name) but the agreement also protects her and her involvement as the mediator of our dispute.

I can have a notarized copy to her as early as tomorrow, please let her know when she can expect the cashiers check or money order. I'd like to have this business completed in no more then 7 business days. The agreement reads like this and is not valid until signed, this is only a draft please discuss any revisions with *******:

MEDIATION AGREEMENT
This is an agreement between the Beverly ******. (Hereafter known as the "Claimant") and Anna Goodnoe of Enchanted Ridge Min Pins_ (identified herein as a "party" or as the "parties".)
1) The parties and Claimant have mutually decided to end their contract.
2) Mediation is a structured problem-solving process in which a neutral, impartial third person or persons assists the parties to reach a voluntary agreement to resolve the matters in issue refund for puppy purchased but not delivered by party.
3) Claimant and Parties have assigned Cindy ************* to mediate this dispute. A different mediator or mediators may be assigned if party advises Claimant of circumstances, which would cause any question regarding the appropriateness of the assigned mediator.
4) The party agrees to refund Claimant at a rate of One Thousand one Hundred and No/100 Dollars ($1100.00).
5) In return, of funds by party ends consumer dispute and claimant has contacted and retract the consumer complaint disputes claimant has filed. If the agency refused to remove complaint claimant agrees to update all reports with a statement of satisfactory results and mediated dispute resolution.
6) Claimant agrees that Parties have fulfilled their agreement and claimant will not make any other consumer reports alleging otherwise.
7) Claimant agrees not to discuss dispute with any other website or through electronic communications unless it is to report satisfactory results or defend against civil or criminal allegations.
8) The Parties adopt the following statements of principle regarding mediation:
(a) Mediation will be conducted in a spirit of cooperation.
(b) The major criteria for decision making will be:
The needs of all parties
Standards of fairness as agreed to by the parties
9) The mediator will control the procedural aspects of the mediation. The mediator will be free to meet and communicate separately with each party. The mediator will decide when to hold joint and/or separate meetings with the parties and shall, in consultation with the parties, fix the time, place, and agenda of each session. The Mediator will hold both the settlement contract and the refund by certified cashier's check or money order.
9) The mediation process will be confidential. The mediator may not be called to testify as a witness, consultant, or expert in any pending or future action relating to the subject matter of the mediation. Neither party may seek to introduce, for any purpose, evidence of a statement or of conduct during mediation at any trial or hearing that may later be held between the parties.
10) The mediator will not provide legal advice or legal representation for any party and does not represent either party.
11) Additional rules and procedures for the mediation may be negotiated and agreed upon by the mediator and the parties at any time during the mediation process.
12) The Claimant and parties acknowledge that they have read this agreement and reviewed it with the mediator, that they understand the agreement, that each has received a copy.

On Sat, Jul 26, 2008 08:41 PM, wrote:

Beverly,
My name is Aaron Goodnoe, I am annas husband and I am going to be the one that is dealing with this process. I was wondering if you would be ok if I called you to discuss revissions to this agreement? Please send an email back to this address and let me know one way or another. I think that we can have this resolved quickly and painlessly, I would just like you to give me the opputunity to do so.
Thanks Aaron Goodnoe

On Tue, Jul 29, 2008 08:31 AM, wrote:


Very well,
My first revision and also the most important is going to be that the complaint must be sucessfully removed from the website. Having reports simply updated will not be satisfactory. No refund will be made until such time as the complaint is removed. At the point of removal of the complaint I will send out the refund via fed ex and provide you with a tracking number. You now have in writing that once the complaint is removed that I WILL send you your refund.

On Tue, Jul 29, 2008 at 8:05 PM, wrote:
Now you are asking for the impossible, once a complaint is made, like the bbb and AKC, it is put on your permanent record along with the fact that it was either resolved or not resolved and whether the results were satisfactory or not by inserting you unreasonable conditions you are denying me access to ever getting MY MONEY BACK. I'm not going to go around and around about this with you and I'm not going to say the incident has been cleared when in fact it hasn't. I like that YOU have chosen a mediator and I agree to hand her the contract signed and notarized and have her hold the contract until conditions have been satisfied, I'm willing to be reasonable, but I will not be taken advantage of and conned any longer. I WILL NOT PERFORM MIRACLES FOR YOU. YOU have to be reasonable. If YOU will not be reasonable I have already made you aware of the consequences of bad business practices and I will continue with the criminal charges. You have 5 more business days to complete this. I will not wait one hour, one minute or one second after the deadline. A promise of a fed ex parcel is unreasonable, the mediator is the holder of both the cashiers check/ money order and the contract; the contract laid out is fair and reasonable to all parties involved including that poor lady who agreed to speak to me about you. She has been put in a very uncomfortable position and is doing her best to try and salvage your reputation and business. She has to deal with two very angry parties and she considers you as her friends.

You have 5 more business days and that is final.

On Tue, Jul 29, 2008 08:22 PM, wrote:


Listen , I am not being unreasonable to ask that an acuusation that is false "scam artist"..."A variation of the baby adoption scams This breeder leads families on and then breaks their hearts" be removed. You lied when you posted on that website and asking you to remove a lie is not asking the impossible all that you need to do is to inform these people that you lied. I will not deny your money if you are willing to tell the truth. I understand that you put emails up there also, but the bottom line is that we are not scam artists. This is not variation of an adoption scam. If you will promise me removal of this posting once you have your moeny then maybe we can work something out that way. I'm not being unreasonable at all. I dont know if you noticed all of the reviews on the website. Those are from people that have sucessfully recieved thier puppies and are very happy with them. I am not trying to to advantage of you at all. I am trying to restore what is left of my wifes reputation. You seem to be hellbent on destroying it. I would think that as a breeder you would understand that someones reputation is very important to them. How would you like it if someone posted lies about you on that website. I would love to see you try and ship a puppy into north dakota in the middle of the winter......its not going to happen because of the temperature here in the winter. That is no different than what we were dealing with trying to ship to phoenix in the summer time. No one wnated to scam you here you need to take a step back and look at this from a different perspective. Had you not posted all of these things online you would have already had your money by now. I am really trying to get through this ordeal peacefully and calmly. So please work with me here you dont need to be yelling at me in your emails. I am not treating you with any disrespect and I would appreciate the same. If you are not willing to come to some sort of an agreement that both parties can live with than you wont have your money in 5 business days. I would also appreciate it if you would stop making threats towards myself and my wife. Lastly I do not see how it is your place to set a deadline if you are not willing to make constructive comments instead of just calling me unreasonable. I'm sure that I will be speaking with you soon

Aaron Goodnoe

On Wed, Jul 30, 2008 at 12:53 AM, wrote:
First, I am not lying and I am not going to say that I was lying to make you feel better about what you have done to me and my family. As for business matters, I have frequently shipped to Canada and Alaska in the middle of winter and never went back on my word with a client even if it has involved a little more money. I make things right with my clients and have never had a complaint, my dogs are all delivered on time because I do care about my business, my clients and my puppies. So you can get off both those rants right there.
As I still see it, I haven't got the puppy and I haven't got my money hence you are running a scam. You asked for a mediator and I agreed to your terms. Giving both the money and contract to a third party is wise and reasonable. As for taking the tag line down, that will not happen until a third party has the money in their hand, so if you don't like the mediator choose another.
The report will always be on consumer complaints web site it will just be moved to the resolved category with a glowing response about our business dealings and how you went out of your way to resolve the conflict. You still have 5 more business day, I am not going around this with you. If you would like, I will add a comment to that tag indicating you are working with a mediator to resolve the dispute, but my deadline is not negotiable.


On Thu, Jul 31, 2008 09:46 PM, wrote:
I am no longer going to deal with someone as crazy as you are. You are doing nothing but lying to make your self feel better. I DO HAVE proof that you are nothing other then a liar. I have never gone back on my word like you have. Their are laws that will help me deal with you. And as for you filing a report that is false well the law will deal with you and maybe you will spend some time in jail where you will have the time to think about the awful things you have posted about me and MY FAMILY. I have never had to deal with someone like you. As far as I can see you broke the contract by not letting me ship the puppy like I planned. So you will NEVER see your deposit. You signed a contract that said you understand the deposit is NON REFUNDABLE. NOW THAT I HAVE PROOF (FROM MORE THEN A FEW PEOPLE) THAT YOU ARE HURTING MY LIFE AND MY BREEDING PROGRAM I WILL SEE YOU IN COURT. I WILL SUE YOU FOR MY LOSSES. You never have a right to post lies and YES that is what you did!!!! But you already know that. I will not sit back and let you walk all over me I am a better person then you could ever be. You are nothing other than a sad person that does nothing other then hurting people for fun. So I have nothing left to say to you other than I WILL SEE YOU IN COURT!!! I will stand up for my business always. I have never done anything wrong and I do have many VERY HAPPY puppy buyers that will stand behind me here. So get ready for the fight of your life!! I WIll not and have NEVER put up with people that lie to hurt an innocent person. You really should find a job so you dont have so much time on your hands to make up lies about me or anyone else for that matter.
Anna


On Thu, Jul 31, 2008 10:06 PM, wrote:


Dear Anna,
I'd be happy to answer any charges you bring up in court in addition I will enter a counter suit. I'm am certain that when this reaches a court of law that it will be settled in my favor. I'm disappointed that mediations attempts with you have failed. Since your agreed upon mediator contacted me this evening and made it clear that you do not wish to continue mediation, and an amicable solution to our transaction is impossible. I will continue with criminal prosecution as well as notification of you activities to the aforementioned authorites and agencies. At this point I chose not to do
business with you anymore, Please refund the entirety of monies paid to you, since YOU have not fulfilled the terms of our contract.

Sincerely,
Beverly Sills

On Thu, Jul 31, 2008 10:12 PM, wrote:

Just so that we are clear. The fact that I will be bringing you to court for damages and liable has nothing to do with the fact that the weather in Phx is still to hot to ship. Since you last said, when I asked that you still want the puppy. As soon as the temp is cooler you will certainly get your puppy unless you decide that you dont want your puppy in which case you would be breaking the contract. Look you could very easily have come to me before going psychotic and posting lies online and you could have already gone to San Diego and picked up your puppy. This could have been worked out weeks ago. I really regret ever having met you, all that you have done is bring stress and misery to me and my family. I cant wait to ship your puppy to you so that I never have to deal with you again.

On Fri, Aug 01, 2008 06:13 AM, wrote:

Dear Anna,
I stand by my last email. I would answer any charges you bring up in court as I am certain when this reaches a court of law it will be settled in my favor. I am disappointed that mediations attempts with you have failed. Since your agreed upon mediator contacted me and made it clear that you do not wish to continue mediation, and an amicable solution to our transaction is impossible. I have continued with criminal prosecution as well as notification of your activities to the aforementioned authorities
and agencies. At this point I chose not to do business with you anymore, Please refund the entirety of monies paid to you, since YOU have not fulfilled the terms of our contract.

Sincerely,
Beverly

On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 at 12:58 PM, wrote:
Anna,
I have already offered you a solution. I will not discuss this situation over the phone. You may contact me through email, regular mail or make an appointment through those two outlets to meet in person in public. I will not have a phone conversation regarding this situation.
Beverly

On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 at 11:15 AM, wrote:
K, Well to start we are not willing to do anything until you retract the lies that you posted about us. Once that is done and I know they have been removed we will talk about refunding money or giving you a puppy. But I will not do that until you retract the lies about us. You had NO RIGHT to post all those lies about us just because the temp where you live is so hot. You need to stop blaming my for something that is no way my fault. I was willing to ship the puppy for you to San Diego as you asked. So you need to tell all the places you lies to to remove your postings as they were nothing but lies and once that is dont we will get you out paperwork that you will need to sign and send back to us that states you will never post lies or anything false against us again. You know what you did was wrong otherwise you would not of sent my a email stating that is was. So please let me know as soon as you finish reporting the "TRUTH" that you did lie about us since you did not get what you wanted as soon as you wanted it to everyone you told that we were "SCAMERS"

On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 at 6:50 PM, wrote:
Anna,
Nothing I have stated is a lie, in each statement I've made I have supported it evidence. The only way that any of my statements could be untrue is if the contract was fulfilled as written or I was the recipient of a full refund. This did not occur. I have been reasonable in my requests for a full refund. Your demands below are fully unreasonable. There is no way to drop the Federal Criminal Report against you unless you have fully refunded my money or aherred to the written agreement. By keeping my money and not delivering the goods or services paid for YOU HAVE COMMITTED A CRIME!!! YOU ARE GOING TO BE PROSECUTED BY AUTHORITIES FOR THIS CRIME. By definition IF you return my money no crime was committed and authorities will be forced to drop the charges.

As for recanting my statements, I will notify 3 main agencies (not all of them) that you have promised to REFUND ALL MY MONEY. If this does not occur in 10 days I will ask the agencies to proceed with my compliant. I am being reasonable about this. If you wish to mediate this dispute you will have to be reasonable as well and put aside you defensiveness and personal feelings.

There is no way that I am signing another agreement or contract with you, that is a very unreasonable demand and it is not going to happen. Like I said by 10:00 pm tonight I will notify 3 agencies that you have agreed to FULLY REFUND MY MONEY. By 10 days time I expect a full refund and by default all other allegations and charges will be dropped and dismissed.
On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 09:44 PM, wrote:

First of all you have not stated the truth. You have submitted claims to these agencies and businesses using edited emails which is filing a false report, which is a crime. We could then move on to defamation of character and liable, these are also crimes. I have stated in every email I have sent you that I am willing to work with you on getting this puppy to you. You asked me to ship to San Diego and I made the arrangements, then you got upset with me and told me you would not drive to san diego. I have been trying to call you to tell you that I would be willing to absorb the extra shipping costs if you can drive to San Diego to pick up the puppy. If you would only pick up the phone this probably would have been resolved by now. I am not trying to squablle like a child here all that I want to do is to either get you your puppy or if you dont want him give you your refund. I will try in the morning to call you so that we can work out the details. I would really appreciate if you would pick up the phone so that we can get this issue resolved in a peaceful manner. If we can resolve this tomorrow I can have (weather permitting) the puppy to you in the next few days. However you need to remove all of your false posting and accusations from the internet and anywhere else you filed a complaint. Bottom line it all needs to be retracted and removed and you need to agree in writing not to do this any more. I dont want to be in this situation any more than you do, but you need to understand that I dont control the temp in Phx or what the airlines do, so neither of things are my fault. I would be able to ship in to San Diego (weather permitting) at this point as he weighs in at 2lbs 3 oz. Please answer your phone so that we can resolve this situation.
On Wed, Jul 23, 2008 at 10:01 AM, wrote:

As I already explained, I have supporting evidence that indicates my allegations are completely valid and true. As for editing email, you do realize that programs are available, that registers every keystroke. The computer forensic investigator can validate what I have already alleged. As for my involvement of criminal activity, that did not happen. I am the victim in this case. You allege defamation of character and liable, that is Civil Charges, which I will happily answer in court and there are rarely criminal penalties involved in Civil Complaints. You, on the other hand, are facing Criminal Charges; these types of charges do involve fines, jail time, probation, and possible loss of property; not to mention the lifetime criminal record, loss of civil rights, such as the right to vote and suspension of second amendment property rights. I know this because I am a 4th year criminology student; I study and understand the criminal justice system. Please do not try to misrepresent the facts concerning law. The choice is yours provide me with a full refund or face the consequences of you decisions.
Furthermore, I have stated in previous emails that I have no desire to have any phone conversations with you. At this point further phone calls will be considered harassment and will be dealt with in the appropriate manner. I WILL NOT DRIVE TO SAN DIEGO.
You now have 9 days to provide me with a full refund. If I do not have a full refund in 9 days, I will expand my notifications to:
Your County Supervisors, County Commissioners, County Representatives, County Assessors, County Recorder's Office, State Councilmen, State Congress and other State Reps. I will also notify every news outlet in your area about your activity and how I was swindled out of over $1100.00.
I have been more than fair; I will not be taken advantage of in this manner. The events set forth after the nine days grace period cannot be undone with a simple recant or refund. Please do discuss your options with an attorney before it is too late. It might help you to take all evidence associated with this to a competent uninvolved 3rd party and ask their advice or ask them what they would do in this situation. This is a serious manner, perhaps more serious then you realize.

On Tue Wed, Jul 23, 2008 08:13 PM, wrote:
So let me start with a very simple question. Do you want the puppy or not. A yes or no answer to this question will be absolutly fine. You are the one here that is making up stories and false allegations. I also have every email that you sent stating that you would gladly drive to san diego. As a matter of fact going to san diego was your idea. You really need to to go back and take a look at your actions, we have already stated that we would either refund your money or send you the puppy (which I am notifying you of again). You have been the one here that has been making this very difficult. Do you really expect everyone in life to just go ahead and jump through every hoop that you lay out for them. If you choose to request a refund you need to understand that it will take up to 10 days after you retract all of your allegations about us and a notarized letter stating that you wont be posting anymore or filing any other allegations of this sort anywhere. Those are the plain and simple facts, I wont have you going around telling false stories because you got mad that the temperatures in phoenix were to hot to ship your puppy. We have repeatedly offered many alternatives and you are simply not willing to work it out. I cant be the only bending over backwards here. I would love it if you would meet me somewhere in the middle. But the bottom line here is what do you want to do, do you want this puppy or not.

On Sat, Jul 26, 2008 at 12:24 AM, wrote:
Everything is spelled out in the agreement including on how the money will be delivered and how you will have the final notarized copy of the Mediation Agreement, it ends all business between me and enchanted ridge and also prohibits me from discussing the dispute or the agreement. I have sent a copy to *********** (I don't know ******* last name) but the agreement also protects her and her involvement as the mediator of our dispute.

I can have a notarized copy to her as early as tomorrow, please let her know when she can expect the cashiers check or money order. I'd like to have this business completed in no more then 7 business days. The agreement reads like this and is not valid until signed, this is only a draft please discuss any revisions with *******:

MEDIATION AGREEMENT
This is an agreement between the Beverly ******. (Hereafter known as the "Claimant") and Anna Goodnoe of Enchanted Ridge Min Pins_ (identified herein as a "party" or as the "parties".)
1) The parties and Claimant have mutually decided to end their contract.
2) Mediation is a structured problem-solving process in which a neutral, impartial third person or persons assists the parties to reach a voluntary agreement to resolve the matters in issue refund for puppy purchased but not delivered by party.
3) Claimant and Parties have assigned Cindy ************* to mediate this dispute. A different mediator or mediators may be assigned if party advises Claimant of circumstances, which would cause any question regarding the appropriateness of the assigned mediator.
4) The party agrees to refund Claimant at a rate of One Thousand one Hundred and No/100 Dollars ($1100.00).
5) In return, of funds by party ends consumer dispute and claimant has contacted and retract the consumer complaint disputes claimant has filed. If the agency refused to remove complaint claimant agrees to update all reports with a statement of satisfactory results and mediated dispute resolution.
6) Claimant agrees that Parties have fulfilled their agreement and claimant will not make any other consumer reports alleging otherwise.
7) Claimant agrees not to discuss dispute with any other website or through electronic communications unless it is to report satisfactory results or defend against civil or criminal allegations.
8) The Parties adopt the following statements of principle regarding mediation:
(a) Mediation will be conducted in a spirit of cooperation.
(b) The major criteria for decision making will be:
The needs of all parties
Standards of fairness as agreed to by the parties
9) The mediator will control the procedural aspects of the mediation. The mediator will be free to meet and communicate separately with each party. The mediator will decide when to hold joint and/or separate meetings with the parties and shall, in consultation with the parties, fix the time, place, and agenda of each session. The Mediator will hold both the settlement contract and the refund by certified cashier's check or money order.
9) The mediation process will be confidential. The mediator may not be called to testify as a witness, consultant, or expert in any pending or future action relating to the subject matter of the mediation. Neither party may seek to introduce, for any purpose, evidence of a statement or of conduct during mediation at any trial or hearing that may later be held between the parties.
10) The mediator will not provide legal advice or legal representation for any party and does not represent either party.
11) Additional rules and procedures for the mediation may be negotiated and agreed upon by the mediator and the parties at any time during the mediation process.
12) The Claimant and parties acknowledge that they have read this agreement and reviewed it with the mediator, that they understand the agreement, that each has received a copy.

On Sat, Jul 26, 2008 08:41 PM, wrote:

Beverly,
My name is Aaron Goodnoe, I am annas husband and I am going to be the one that is dealing with this process. I was wondering if you would be ok if I called you to discuss revissions to this agreement? Please send an email back to this address and let me know one way or another. I think that we can have this resolved quickly and painlessly, I would just like you to give me the opputunity to do so.
Thanks Aaron Goodnoe

On Tue, Jul 29, 2008 08:31 AM, wrote:


Very well,
My first revision and also the most important is going to be that the complaint must be sucessfully removed from the website. Having reports simply updated will not be satisfactory. No refund will be made until such time as the complaint is removed. At the point of removal of the complaint I will send out the refund via fed ex and provide you with a tracking number. You now have in writing that once the complaint is removed that I WILL send you your refund.

On Tue, Jul 29, 2008 at 8:05 PM, wrote:
Now you are asking for the impossible, once a complaint is made, like the bbb and AKC, it is put on your permanent record along with the fact that it was either resolved or not resolved and whether the results were satisfactory or not by inserting you unreasonable conditions you are denying me access to ever getting MY MONEY BACK. I'm not going to go around and around about this with you and I'm not going to say the incident has been cleared when in fact it hasn't. I like that YOU have chosen a mediator and I agree to hand her the contract signed and notarized and have her hold the contract until conditions have been satisfied, I'm willing to be reasonable, but I will not be taken advantage of and conned any longer. I WILL NOT PERFORM MIRACLES FOR YOU. YOU have to be reasonable. If YOU will not be reasonable I have already made you aware of the consequences of bad business practices and I will continue with the criminal charges. You have 5 more business days to complete this. I will not wait one hour, one minute or one second after the deadline. A promise of a fed ex parcel is unreasonable, the mediator is the holder of both the cashiers check/ money order and the contract; the contract laid out is fair and reasonable to all parties involved including that poor lady who agreed to speak to me about you. She has been put in a very uncomfortable position and is doing her best to try and salvage your reputation and business. She has to deal with two very angry parties and she considers you as her friends.

You have 5 more business days and that is final.

On Tue, Jul 29, 2008 08:22 PM, wrote:


Listen , I am not being unreasonable to ask that an acuusation that is false "scam artist"..."A variation of the baby adoption scams This breeder leads families on and then breaks their hearts" be removed. You lied when you posted on that website and asking you to remove a lie is not asking the impossible all that you need to do is to inform these people that you lied. I will not deny your money if you are willing to tell the truth. I understand that you put emails up there also, but the bottom line is that we are not scam artists. This is not variation of an adoption scam. If you will promise me removal of this posting once you have your moeny then maybe we can work something out that way. I'm not being unreasonable at all. I dont know if you noticed all of the reviews on the website. Those are from people that have sucessfully recieved thier puppies and are very happy with them. I am not trying to to advantage of you at all. I am trying to restore what is left of my wifes reputation. You seem to be hellbent on destroying it. I would think that as a breeder you would understand that someones reputation is very important to them. How would you like it if someone posted lies about you on that website. I would love to see you try and ship a puppy into north dakota in the middle of the winter......its not going to happen because of the temperature here in the winter. That is no different than what we were dealing with trying to ship to phoenix in the summer time. No one wnated to scam you here you need to take a step back and look at this from a different perspective. Had you not posted all of these things online you would have already had your money by now. I am really trying to get through this ordeal peacefully and calmly. So please work with me here you dont need to be yelling at me in your emails. I am not treating you with any disrespect and I would appreciate the same. If you are not willing to come to some sort of an agreement that both parties can live with than you wont have your money in 5 business days. I would also appreciate it if you would stop making threats towards myself and my wife. Lastly I do not see how it is your place to set a deadline if you are not willing to make constructive comments instead of just calling me unreasonable. I'm sure that I will be speaking with you soon

Aaron Goodnoe

On Wed, Jul 30, 2008 at 12:53 AM, wrote:
First, I am not lying and I am not going to say that I was lying to make you feel better about what you have done to me and my family. As for business matters, I have frequently shipped to Canada and Alaska in the middle of winter and never went back on my word with a client even if it has involved a little more money. I make things right with my clients and have never had a complaint, my dogs are all delivered on time because I do care about my business, my clients and my puppies. So you can get off both those rants right there.
As I still see it, I haven't got the puppy and I haven't got my money hence you are running a scam. You asked for a mediator and I agreed to your terms. Giving both the money and contract to a third party is wise and reasonable. As for taking the tag line down, that will not happen until a third party has the money in their hand, so if you don't like the mediator choose another.
The report will always be on consumer complaints web site it will just be moved to the resolved category with a glowing response about our business dealings and how you went out of your way to resolve the conflict. You still have 5 more business day, I am not going around this with you. If you would like, I will add a comment to that tag indicating you are working with a mediator to resolve the dispute, but my deadline is not negotiable.


On Thu, Jul 31, 2008 09:46 PM, wrote:
I am no longer going to deal with someone as crazy as you are. You are doing nothing but lying to make your self feel better. I DO HAVE proof that you are nothing other then a liar. I have never gone back on my word like you have. Their are laws that will help me deal with you. And as for you filing a report that is false well the law will deal with you and maybe you will spend some time in jail where you will have the time to think about the awful things you have posted about me and MY FAMILY. I have never had to deal with someone like you. As far as I can see you broke the contract by not letting me ship the puppy like I planned. So you will NEVER see your deposit. You signed a contract that said you understand the deposit is NON REFUNDABLE. NOW THAT I HAVE PROOF (FROM MORE THEN A FEW PEOPLE) THAT YOU ARE HURTING MY LIFE AND MY BREEDING PROGRAM I WILL SEE YOU IN COURT. I WILL SUE YOU FOR MY LOSSES. You never have a right to post lies and YES that is what you did!!!! But you already know that. I will not sit back and let you walk all over me I am a better person then you could ever be. You are nothing other than a sad person that does nothing other then hurting people for fun. So I have nothing left to say to you other than I WILL SEE YOU IN COURT!!! I will stand up for my business always. I have never done anything wrong and I do have many VERY HAPPY puppy buyers that will stand behind me here. So get ready for the fight of your life!! I WIll not and have NEVER put up with people that lie to hurt an innocent person. You really should find a job so you dont have so much time on your hands to make up lies about me or anyone else for that matter.
Anna


On Thu, Jul 31, 2008 10:06 PM, wrote:


Dear Anna,
I'd be happy to answer any charges you bring up in court in addition I will enter a counter suit. I'm am certain that when this reaches a court of law that it will be settled in my favor. I'm disappointed that mediations attempts with you have failed. Since your agreed upon mediator contacted me this evening and made it clear that you do not wish to continue mediation, and an amicable solution to our transaction is impossible. I will continue with criminal prosecution as well as notification of you activities to the aforementioned authorites and agencies. At this point I chose not to do
business with you anymore, Please refund the entirety of monies paid to you, since YOU have not fulfilled the terms of our contract.

Sincerely,
Beverly Sills

On Thu, Jul 31, 2008 10:12 PM, wrote:

Just so that we are clear. The fact that I will be bringing you to court for damages and liable has nothing to do with the fact that the weather in Phx is still to hot to ship. Since you last said, when I asked that you still want the puppy. As soon as the temp is cooler you will certainly get your puppy unless you decide that you dont want your puppy in which case you would be breaking the contract. Look you could very easily have come to me before going psychotic and posting lies online and you could have already gone to San Diego and picked up your puppy. This could have been worked out weeks ago. I really regret ever having met you, all that you have done is bring stress and misery to me and my family. I cant wait to ship your puppy to you so that I never have to deal with you again.

On Fri, Aug 01, 2008 06:13 AM, wrote:

Dear Anna,
I stand by my last email. I would answer any charges you bring up in court as I am certain when this reaches a court of law it will be settled in my favor. I am disappointed that mediations attempts with you have failed. Since your agreed upon mediator contacted me and made it clear that you do not wish to continue mediation, and an amicable solution to our transaction is impossible. I have continued with criminal prosecution as well as notification of your activities to the aforementioned authorities
and agencies. At this point I chose not to do business with you anymore, Please refund the entirety of monies paid to you, since YOU have not fulfilled the terms of our contract.

Sincerely,
Beverly

You noticed the owner of this scam has finally posted a rebuttal, yet they fail to address any of the claims. Although Anna Goodnoe runs the business, when there are problems her husband, Arron Goodnoe, quickly tries to bully or intimate those customers. BUYER BEWARE!!!! YOU be the judge, I have presented the emails between me and this CON Artist for your review. As of 8/3/08 this Scammer has yet to deliver a puppy or return my money. As you can read by the emails they have no intention of doing either despite the repeated requests. Beware of having any business dealings with these people, if they truly wanted to deliver the puppy there has been several weekends when the low was well below the 85 degree mark. In addition there are other delivery methods available that they choose not to use or even consider. THESE heartless cruel people do not keep their word and will try to take advantage of consumers who give their money to them in good faith.

In response to a recent false postings on the internet by a disgruntled potential puppy buyer, I would like to openly address this issue to our past, present, and future puppy buyers.

Ms. Beverly entered into a contractual agreement with Enchanted Ridge to purchase a puppy that suited her needs and desires. Unfortunately, Ms. Beverly failed to understand that when her local temperatures in Arizona are in the EXTREME triple digits this is unsafe for a young puppy to travel. Federal guidelines are in place to protect all live animals from suffering from this unacceptable shipping practice.

As a responsible breeder, we do our best here at Enchanted Ridge to produce healthy puppies with sound temperament. Part of this responsibility is to ensure that all puppies reach their families in the same condition in which they left our home. All shipping is done in accordance with Federal regulations. If the temperatures are too high (over 85 degrees Fahrenheit) or too low (under 10 degrees Fahrenheit), shipping will be delayed until the weather cooperates.

In response to Ms. Beverlys accusations of asking for more money, the rising cost of fuel in America is causing everything to go up. We are all feeling this impact on a daily basis. The airlines too have raised their shipping prices and being that this puppy's shipping rates were based on and paid on the shipping rates prior to the increase, we asked all buyers that were caught in the middle of this price increase to also increase their shipping fees to accommodate the airlines recent and unexpected increase. This shipping increase is directly influenced by the fuel increase. The actual cost of my puppies has gone DOWN in price, and I am adding permanent identification (microchip) of all puppies at no additional cost to the puppy buyer.

Enchanted Ridged stands by our puppies, we have multiple repeat purchases and continue to offer puppies with over 99% satisfaction from families that are sharing their lives with one of more of our puppies.

If you are interested in one of our precious puppies, please contact me for more information. If you would like to discuss your concerns of what you may have read by the recent slanderous postings by one woman who has never seen my dogs/puppies feel free to talk to me. References are available from our vet and previous puppy buyers.

OMG! Thank you for filing your report. I was JUST about to enter an agreement to purchase a pup from this company when your report popped up on my google search. No way, no how will I buy from her now, especially after reading Irritated Neighbor's post. Now, not only am I afraid of being ripped off, but I wonder about the health and lineage of the pup.

Where am I going to find a blue min pin now? :(

On Sat, Jul 19, 2008 at 12:27 AM, victim wrote:

Anna,

I have taken a couple of days to think things over about this puppy. I have concluded the following:

1. You were NOT able to ship my puppy because the airlines will not ship during the summer in Phoenix because of the very hot temperatures. This however, is not my fault. You as a breeder, should have known and discussed it with me before allowing me to purchase the puppy. I had no idea that airlines couldn't ship. You had also stated that the puppy was too small and that your vet wouldn't let him fly because he didn't weigh 2 pounds. The way I see it, neither of those things is my fault.

2. We did discuss shipping him to San Diego, but if your vet wouldn't let him fly in the beginning, why would he decide to let him to go to San Diego? That made me wonder.

Then you told me that you couldn't guarantee his health going to San Diego. That is when I told you NOT to ship him to San Diego, if it could jeopardize his health, and void the contract. I didn't quite understand that he would have been fine coming to Phoenix, but not to San Diego.

My conclusion is that I would like to get a FULL REFUND of $1,100.00
(because not being able to get him to me was NOT my fault). Upon receiving a full refund, I will descend ALL the comments I made public, update the FBI database IC3 Criminal Complaint Division, retract my complaints to AKC and the BBB. I don't want to continue this anymore. It isn't worth the stress. I am sorry things didn't work out. I really would like to have gotten my puppy.


I would really like to work this out amicably.

On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 07:20 AM, Anna Goodnoe of Enchanted Ridge Mins Pins wrote:

If you keep filing false complaints on me I will not be willing to work wioth you about anything. I have the proof below that I need to prove these were false complaints. My husband and I am talking about what to do and once we know I will call you and we can go over it. Anna

On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 at 12:58 PM, Victim wrote:

Anna,
I have already offered you a solution. I will not discuss this situation over the phone. You may contact me through email, regular mail or make an appointment through those two outlets to meet in person in public. I will not have a phone conversation regarding this situation.


On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 11:15 AM, Anna Goodnoe of Enchanted Ridge Min Pins wrote:

OK, Well to start we are not willing to do anything until you retract the lies that you posted about us. Once that is done and I know they have been removed we will talk about refunding money or giving you a puppy. But I will not do that until you retract the lies about us. You had NO RIGHT to post all those lies about us just because the temp where you live is so hot. You need to stop blaming my for something that is no way my fault. I was willing to ship the puppy for you to San Diego as you asked. So you need to tell all the places you lies to to remove your postings as they were nothing but lies and once that is dont we will get you out paperwork that you will need to sign and send back to us that states you will never post lies or anything false against us again. You know what you did was wrong otherwise you would not of sent my a email stating that is was. So please let me know as soon as you finish reporting the "TRUTH" that you did lie about us since you did not get what you wanted as soon as you wanted it to everyone you told that we were "SCAMERS"

On Tue, Jul 22, 2008 at 4:50 PM, Victim wrote:

Anna,
Nothing I have stated is a lie, in each statement I've made I have supported it evidence. The only way that any of my statements could be untrue is if the contract was fulfilled as written or I was the recipient of a full refund. This did not occur. I have been reasonable in my requests for a full refund. Your demands below are fully unreasonable. There is no way to drop the Federal Criminal Report against you unless you have fully
refunded my money or aherred to the written agreement. By keeping my money and not delivering the goods or services paid for YOU HAVE COMMITTED A CRIME!!! YOU ARE GOING TO BE PROSECUTED BY AUTHORITIES FOR THIS CRIME. By definition IF you return my money no
crime was committed and authorities will be forced to drop the charges.

As for recanting my statements, I will notify 3 main agencies (not all of them) that you have promised to REFUND ALL MY MONEY. If this does not occur in 10 days I will ask the agencies to proceed with my compliant. I am being reasonable about this. If you wish to mediate this dispute you will have to be reasonable as well and put aside you defensiveness and personal feelings.

There is no way that I am signing another agreement or contract with you, that is a very unreasonable demand and it is not going to happen. Like I said by 10:00 pm tonight I will notify 3 agencies that you have agreed to FULLY REFUND MY MONEY. By 10 days time I expect a full refund and by default all other allegations and charges will be dropped and dismissed.

Anna Goodnoe and Enchanted Ridge Min Pins

I live next door to this breeder and she is by no means and nice lady.

Firstly she is running her breeding business illegally. We reside in a town with a population of 100 people MAX! The Goodnoe's moved into the the house they claim to own a little over 2 years ago. And since then they have been a thorn in the side of this close knit town. Where they reside and run thier breeding bussiness is NOT in the business zone of the town! They are running in in the residental area. They have any where from 30 to 45 of these dogs they leave out in the yard. They have no respect for the surrounding neighbors that these dogs contantly bark at anything that moves. I can not be out in my yard with out all of the dogs piled up in the corner of thier fence barking and yipping the whole time I am out in my own yard.

Thier have been many complaints against these people. And nothing has been done about it. They have been smart about not listing thier adress for the bussiness...thier AKC compliance form on thier web site has thier home address balonked out. They know they are doing wrong here. THier cute dogs and all but enoughs enough! Thie was a quite sleepy little town till they came into it. All the neighbors that surround their house are feed up with them. For the price she charges for these dogs they could at least put up a better fence that the dogs can not see through,.......that would cut the noise level of these dogs greatly!

I especially love when they let them out at 3 am in the in the morning and let them bark for an hour before letting them in....my bedroom window is 200 yards from thier yard! Im sure Im not the only neighbor that get woke up!

And when asked to do something about the dogs or her property she gets rude and defensive.

These breeders know they are in the wrong and thanks to finding thier webpage and seeing this feed back on them things will be brought up at the next town counsel meeting and they will be either forced to move the dogs outta the residential area, or just move outta our town all together. I know I can speak for 90% of the residents here......WE HAVE ALL HAD IT WITH THIS PERSON AND HER TOTAL DISREGARDE FOR HER NEIGHBORS.

This is my home town. Im 30 years old and have lived here my whole life. I refuse to be chased outta my home town by her!

On Fri, Feb 22, 2008 at 7:35 PM, xxxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
Hi Anna,
I hope everything is going well. My address is:

Thanks for all your help in my search for a male min pin of good breeding quality. Like we discussed before, feel free to move me to another litter, I do prefer an offspring of Justice, but even that is not necessary. You are the best judge of what your min pins produce and if you happen to think that there is another male from any other litter that would be as good quality I'd be happy to discuss that option as well. I'm not in any hurry.

Thanks Again,
Bev

On Wed, Feb 27, 2008 at 2:34 PM, Enchanted Ridge wrote:
I will send you out the contract for him this weekend. You have paid in full for him. Anna

On Fri, Mar 14, 2008 02:37 PM, Enchanted Ridge wrote:
Here are a few pics of your pup at 3 weeks. Anna
On Fri, Mar 14, 2008 at 6:27 PM, xxxxxxxxxx wrote:
Thank you for the pictures. He is pretty. The only thing I'm concerned about is that white spot on his chest, or do you think it's something he'll grow out of? I know that if the white spot is a 1/2 inch or larger that it's a disqualifying feature. Would you as a breeder choose a breeding dog that has a white spot similar to his? I know you are quite busy and only send pictures as a courtesy, if you happen to be taking pictures again could you get a clearer picture of the chest for me.

Thanks,
Bev

On Fri, Mar 14, 2008 05:21 PM, Enchanted Ridge wrote:

I think he will be fine for breeding as of now. His mom had a bit of white on her chect too and he is the first puppy she has ever had that had white. She has had 11 puppies total so far. I think you will be ok with him. Anna
On Sun, Mar 16, 2008 at 8:17 PM, xxxxxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
In that case, I can hardly wait to welcome him to his new home, the children are really excited about having another little one under foot.

I don't know if you heard but if people are looking for small dogs their was a rescue nearby recently where over 800 Chihuahua's and 80 parrots were taken by the state. The dogs were in good shape but can you image, having 800 little dogs running around. Anyhow, I know you are busy. Thanks for getting back to me so quickly

Fri, Mar 21, 2008 06:55 PM, Enchanted Ridge wrote:
Here he is at 4 weeks. The pictures are not great. My good camera broke and my new one wont be here for a few weeks. Anna

___________________________________________
Anna switched me to another litter and we communicated alot on the telephone
___________________________________At this point I was moved to another litter and started communication via email regarding the new puppy----

There were many phone conversations----

Fri, Jun 06, 2008 02:18 PM, Enchanted Ridge wrote:

I have not gotten the paper work back for you. I need you to send me the Deposit contract along with the contract. Please be sure to fill out the contract before sending it back. Please send them both out this weekend. I need them here by 6/13/2008
Thanks Anna

Sun, Jun 08, 2008 12:23 PM, Enchanted Ridge wrote:
Here are some new pics of the puppy. He is VERY tiny so I will let you know if we will be shipping him on time once he gets a bit older. I also need you to send out the contracts to me asap. I need them here by friday. Anna

On Sun, Jun 8, 2008 at 6:43 PM xxxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
I will send them out tomorrow priority through the POST OFFICE. Do you want me to scan them and email them to you?

Sun, Jun 08, 2008 07:53 PM Enchanted Ridge wrote:

no just send them. Anna

On Mon, Jun 16, 2008 at 3:34 PM, xxxxxxxxxx wrote:
I just got an alert from fedex that they were unable to deliver the papers. I don't know what the problem is but the message said the papers are being sent back to sender. Please let me know if you received them.

Mon, Jun 16, 2008 01:37 PM, Enchanted Ridge wrote:

I did get them, friday I think

Wed, Jun 18, 2008 12:07 PM, Enchanted Ridge wrote:
Here are some new pictures. I hope he starts growing soon. He is very small. Anna

On Wed, Jun 18, 2008 at 11:08 PM, xxxxxxxx wrote:
He is so beautiful, what a cute little guy. What is his weight now, I understand that you may not be able ship him on time because he is small. Just let me know your plans

Wed, Jun 18, 2008 09:13 PM, Enchanted Ridge wrote:

He is 12oz today. Anna

Wed, Jun 25, 2008 12:53 PM, Enchanted Ridge wrote:

Here are new pictures. I am worried about his size. He is not really growing much. I will let you know. Anna

On Wed, Jun 25, 2008 at 8:20 PM, xxxxxxxxxx wrote:
He's so cute thanks for the pic's, I'm really looking forward to getting him home. He doesn't look to much smaller then his siblings, keep me updated.

Wed, Jun 25, 2008 06:27 PM, Enchanted Ridge wrote:

He is alot smaller in weight as well as smaller in size. Im sure he will grow in the next few weeks here. Anna

Tue, Jul 01, 2008 08:19 AM, Enchanted Ridge wrote:

I am just sending this out so I can save your email under Boo's puppies. Anna

Thu, Jul 03, 2008 08:19 PM, Enchanted Ridge wrote:

Here is a new picture. Anna

______________This is where I started thinking things are not quite right----


Sat, Jul 12, 2008 08:26 AM, Enchanted Ridge wrote:
I am not sure what I am going to do here. Everything is not working out. Every plan I have made has fallen through. I guess I will think about what to do today and please let me know if you think of anything. I know I cant hold on to these puppies for 2-3 months or even weeks. I need figure out what is going to be best here. Maybe waiting for a different litter and me srelling these puppies will be what is best. I wish I had thought of the heat in Pheonix this time of yeat because I would of told you no for this litter. I hate when I dont think. Anyway I will let know know in the next day or two what we will do. Anna


On Sat, Jul 12, 2008 at 11:41 PM, xxxxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
I suppose I could find someone to fly up there and turn around and come back if you could give me the airport name and have someone available to take the puppy to the airport, let me know what days of the week that we could a plan this for.

Sat, Jul 12, 2008 09:53 PM, Enchanted Ridge wrote:
the airport name is grand forks. a ticket is $600.00 plus $80 for the puppy to fly. I have looked into it.

On Sun, Jul 13, 2008 at 10:39 AM, xxxxxxxxx wrote:
Do you know any flight attendants, when I needed a stud dog from Russia transported in the cabin a flight attendant accompanied the Doberman in the cabin to the US and I flew with the dog from New York to AZ. That's a possibility also, there is ground transportation by companies that specialize in pet transport door to door delivery. I have one quote of $350 for one pet, I've left messages about the possibility of transporting 2 puppies in the same crate. I've contacted two companies to get quotes on that option. Also, Continental changes status of dog transport all the time. Is it possible to have the puppy delivered to a nearby city that's a little cooler, Like San Diego, Los Angeles or Burbank. It's a six hour drive but, it would well be worth it, I'd rent a car and drive to any one of those cities. I really like that little red guy. I want to do everything possible to get him here safely instead of being moved to another litter.
Let me know what you think.

Beverly

Sun, Jul 13, 2008 08:53 AM, Enchanted Ridge wrote:
I dont know any flight attendants. Also the ground transport is not something I am willing to do. I dont like that they are in a cage for 5 to 10 days. They will stress them out alot as well so they aer still too small. They are both under 2 lbs still and I will not do anything that could harm them. I am sorry but I am very picky when it comes to my dogs and their puppies. It is just too hot to ship most places this time of year. It is just getting hotter everyday here too. Well let me call the airlines in the morning and see what other airports they can get to. Anna

Mon, Jul 14, 2008 09:54 AM, Enchanted Ridge wrote:
OK, I think you will be better off waiting and getting one of the black boys I have from Mia and Jericho. That way we can ship him on time. Please let me know what you think. Anna

On Mon, Jul 14, 2008 at 5:04 PM, xxxxxxxxxx wrote:
i'm sorry about the last email, this has just been so frustrating. It has been a roller coster because each week I'm either getting him or not getting him. I figured after I signed the contract that I would definetly be getting him so I let my children see pictures. Now you want to move me to another litter.

I'd be okay to move to another litter, actually, out of the litter you mentioned I really like the blue female. As it was, I was going to have to wait to breed gabby at 2 years old because the little boy wouldn't be ready until then. At this point I'm just going to AI her when she's ready. How much more would it cost to buy the blue female?

Mon, Jul 14, 2008 05:04 PM, Enchanted Ridge wrote:

Well, I am looking to see and I cant find any flights that will work now. He cant leave here yet because he is still too small. My vet wont sign off on the puppies unless they are 2 lbs which he is not yet. I wish I could of had my friend fly the out to you guys. But her foot is still very broken and she cant do it. Also the other person is taking a different puppy as she knows how hard it is to ship to AZ this year. It is hotter then last year that is why everyone is having peoblems shipping there. My friend had to resell one of her pups also because she could not get her into Vegas so they had to take a younger pup that will beready in September. So that is something you may need to do also. I am sorry this is so hard but it is not my fault. I wish I could change the temp there for one day.

The blue female is pending right now. I am waiting for the deposit that was sent Friday . So I am sure she is SOLD.

Also why do you need to AI your female?

Anna

On Mon, Jul 14, 2008 at 7:56 PM, xxxxxxxxx wrote:
the reason I was going to ai is Because the male I've been waiting for will be to young to breed, so I have to import semen for her to be ai'd. The boy I was waiting for would only be 7 months old when she'd be ready for breeding.

On Mon, Jul 14, 2008 at 8:31 PM, Enchanted Ridge Min Pins wrote:
If you are wanting a refund I will send you back the money other then the $300.00 deposit because you are making the choice to not get a puppy.

If you want him, the shipping will go up $75.00 and you will need to go pick him up in San Diego. And I will need the $35.00 per week to hold him past 7/12 like stated in the contract. So you will need to send me $110.00 plus $4.40 for the paypal fee if you pay through paypal.com I need to know asap what you want to do because now my husband will need to take a day off work so I can go to the vet. And I will try to get him off thursday if the vet can get me in tomorrow. I will have to go to a different vet that will sign off even though he is under 2 lbs. I will not guarantee is safty since he is so tiny. Sorry.

_____________Note ________ After receiving my email she picked about it and wrote comments between each sentence
On Mon, Jul 14, 2008 at 8:53 PM, xxxxxxxx wrote:
I'm not the one breaching the signed contract, that is totally your doing.
No, I would not be breaking the contract that would be totally you if you dont want a puppy from me. I do not refund a NON REFUNDABLE deposit unless the puppy gets sick and dies in my care or if I change my mind about selling a puppy to someone.

So the choice you are giving me is to pay nearly $300 extra (total extra $110) for a puppy I've already paid in full for or lose $300 or move to another litter and probably not get the quality I have looked for or just cut my losses and take my business else where and learn from this costly mistake of dealing with you.
You would be getting a better quality if you moved to Mia's Litter it is a champion bloodline. Oh and all my dogs are quality some bay have better CH lines but it does not make them less quality. You have no right to say anything about my lines since you know nothing about them.

I sent the money when requested, I waited patiently for the right puppy, and was moved from litter to litter (Your Choice not mine) and I signed and had the contract delivered when you requested and I have absolutely nothing to show for my time or money. Gee thanks

Yes, Thanks for acting so childlike about the temps where you live not me. I cant change your weather. You could of told me it was so hot. I even brought it up and you said it should not be a problem.

You will not make it in a breeders world if you act like this. Stuff comes up and breeders have no control sometines and buyers just have to deal sometimes. I am being honest with you and all you can do is be rude to me.

I have booked the flight for 7/17 the booking number is 01242169400
Leaving GFK @ 5am on fligth #866
Arriving MSP @ 6:07am
Departing MSP @ 9:15am on fligth #189
Arriving San Diego @ 10:55am

If you chose not to pick him up please let me know asap. Also if you chose that you dont want him after me booking this flight that you asked for them you are the one making the choice not to take him amd you will loose $300 deposit, $35 boarding fee and as on tomorrow morning $65 for the health check to fly. I am not going to play your games. I will let you take one of Mia's puppies that will be ready to go once your temp cool down if you have changed your mind about driving to a different airport. The choice is yours. I am going out of my way now for you. Also if you want him you will need to pay the xtra $110.00 asap so I can go pick up stuff to ship him while I am in town tomorrow morning. I wont make that trip more them once a week. Well let me know what you choose to do. Anna

On Mon, Jul 14, 2008 at 10:44 PM, xxxxxxxxxxx wrote:


Don't ship him, if you can't guarantee his safety (He is under 2 lbs still) I don't want him put at risk so don't ship him. Do the ethical thing, (I am doing the ridge thing here) it's totally in your hands. If you are not going to refund my money in full (Like I said there is nothing wrong with him so I will refund you what I already said) send me a puppy just send me the shipping information (I already sent you the shipping info in the last email). Just to be totally honest the temp in Phoenix doesn't usually drop down from triple digits until after Halloween (Well that is not what I was told by 2 other people there) . The only puppy I liked from Mia litter was the little blue female, (The black boys are much better looking then the blue girl. She has white on her chest. And she is sold like I said. I also sell me blues for $1200 with full rights) since she is out of the question again, I'm leaving it totally up to you. (I find it strange that you said Mia's litter was not quality accept for the one puppy that is spoken for) Again... I am not happy with the situation and I don't believe I've been treated fairly (You have beed treated very fair by me. I dont have any control over the temps where you live you need to stop blaming me for this!), this is not the way I would treat one of my customers, I've always done everything in my power to make certain my customers are happy (I am made sure you have been happy.... you started demanding stuff today and being rude. I will not stand for that. I do not need to be treated bad by you. I am doing you a favor by letting you have one of my puppies for breeding) . But that is what ethical breeders do (I am clearly much more ethical then you are. I dont want to put a puppy in harms way but it is ok with you as long as you are getting what you want. I already told you that you could change to one of Mia's boys.... Their coats are better and they are nice puppies. If I did not have so many dogs that are related to Mia I would keep one for myself.)

The only other thing you could do is get the older blue female I have she is 3 months old. If you want her let me know asap I have someone else that may want her.

I am sorry that everything is not the way you want it to be but that is the way of life. My puppies health comes first to me. That is the way it has always been here.

On Tue, Jul 15, 2008 at 12:03 AM, xxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
It would be a burden to go to San Diego at this time for a puppy that may or may not live through the trip. I have made it clear that the rest of these dealings are totally up to you. I never said that Mia's puppies were lesser quality, I am concerned that I will not receive a small male, or one that is of equal size as the agreed on Boo male. I don't care what litter you switch me to, it's totally up to you. If you switch me to Mia's litter fine, I don't care, just tell me when the puppy will arrive in Phoenix. I am done. Just to be clear, it's up to you.

Tue, Jul 15, 2008 07:17 AM, Enchanted Ridge wrote:
As you stated in a pryor mail "Is it possible to have the puppy delivered to a nearby city that's a little cooler, Like San Diego, Los Angeles or Burbank. It's a six hour drive but, it would well be worth it, I'd rent a car and drive to any one of those cities." So I book the flight to one of the places you asked me to and now you say "It would be a burden to go to San Diego at this time". You should of never asked me to look into those places if you had no plans of driving to one of them. It took me over a hour to look up temps and what airport will be the least drive for YOU. I would have to be at the airport at 3:30 am and I would not be home until 5:30am which would be another day of no sleep for me.

"I have made it clear that the rest of these dealings are totally up to you." Yes, you have made it clear that the choice is up to me, But it is not. The choice is yours. I will not make any choices for a buyer. All I will do is tell them what I think will work the best. I will always do the best thing for the puppy and buyer.

About the quality of Boo's Vs Mia's pups you said "probably not get the quality I have looked for" Meaning Mia's pups and then also said "I never said that Mia's puppies were lesser quality,"
I have already booked the flight into San Diego as you requested. Are you not going to pick him up then? I need to bring him to the vet today if he is leaving Thursday morning. I need you to understand that I am not going to play the games of... send the puppy... dont send the puppy... it is not fair to him or me. I need to get alot ready to go if he is leaving. Also if you want the puppy you need to pay the $110 asap. Even if you dont want this puppy shipping has gone up and was $150.00 to ship and is now $250.00 to ship. Plus the boarding fee $30.00 and the extra health check is $35.00 over what I would pay my vet, but since he is under 2 lbs I have to pay more at a different vet. So that is where the extra comes in. Please let me know asap if you are going to pick the puppy up. I am going out of my way to do what yuo want and I am going to only ask you one time not to be rude to me anymore. So please let me know asap if you are going to pick the litte guy up if I send him thursday. Also if you pay with paypal dont for get to send $114.40 to cover the fees. This is the last time I am willing to send this puppy to you. My husband took the day off work today so I can bring the puppy to the vet and he cant take the day off work everyday for me. He looses $150 to take 1/2 the day off for me. And with everything costing so much these days we cant afford it more then once in a while. Let me know what you want to do.

On Tue, Jul 15, 2008 at 10:03 AM, xxxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
You stated you will not guarantee his health if I want him shipped to San Diego. I do not want the dog to be put in danger, I've said this several times. So if shipping him to San Diego is going to void his health guarantee then NO. I do not want him shipped. If shipping him will not void the health guarantee then ship him. Otherwise move me to whatever litter you want and ship want ever puppy you want. I am through going around with you about this. I am NOT SENDING ANYMORE MONEY UNTIL I SEE A LIVE ANIMAL. I have been more then fair in my dealings with you. You want to move me to another litter, fine, but I am not sending additional money to you for a puppy and shipping I've already paid for.

Tue, Jul 15, 2008 08:26 AM, Enchanted Ridge wrote:

The shipping went up therefor you still we money. So until I am paid for the extra shipping and the boarding fee I will not send ANY puppy. If you do not pay what you owe then I have no choice but not to send the puppy until I have recived $110.00 from you to cover the extra shipping and such. Like I said I am done dealing with your games. Send the money or you will not get the puppy.

On Tue, Jul 15, 2008 08:27 AM, Enchanted Ridge Min Pins wrote:
Everyone else has already send the extra shipping money and the boarding fees if needed. You are to one one that does not want to pay what you owe!!

On Tue, Jul 15, 2008 at 10:58 AM, xxxxxxxxxxxx wrote:

EVERY BEWARE OF BREEDER websites warns of this scam, I am not sending one more dime. SO EITHER SEND ME A PUPPY OR SEND ME MY MONEY.

Tue, Jul 15, 2008 09:30 AM, Enchanted Ridge Min Pins wrote:

Well This is FAR FROM A SCAM!! Sacms would not send you weekly pictures, a deposit contract and a contract. Scams dont have large websites that are so well put together like mine. As I told you a week ago that the airlines went up on the shipping on July 1st and that I have been asking everyone to send the difference to cover shipping. I know I did tell you that I would not charge extra shipping if I could ship the 2 puppies together, But that is not going to work out since the other person in AZ knows it is not going to work to ship her puppy there so she is waiting for a different litter that will be ready to go in a few weeks. Therefor you will need to pay the extra shipping if you want to get a puppy from me. I will NOT refund you the full amount you paid because you said you are willing to drive to san diego to pink him up and you are willing to pay the extra for shipping these are all things you have said in your emails over the last few days. So I will not be refunding you for the puppy and that is that. You are the one changing what you said and I am done going out of my way to help you and do what you want. I AM DONE. YOU CAN SEND THE MONEY OR NOT GET THE PUPPY YOU ARE MAKING THE CHOICE HERE NOT ME!!!

On Tue, Jul 15, 2008 at 12:10 PM, xxxxxxxxxx wrote:
It is totally a scam, and I'm contacting the authorities, as I have all the email, that indicates that I paid in FULL and you were going to ship him.
You can make all the excuses you want and lay all the blame on everything everyone else or circumstances. I am done dealing with you either send me my money or send me a puppy. I WILL NOT PAY YOU ONE DIME MORE!!!! You have allready ripped me off for over 1100 dollars. I'm not going to be taken for anymore money. As I see it you had no intention of ever sending me a puppy, you got money and was just trying to scam more money from me. I am done dealing with you.

Tue, Jul 15, 2008 07:35 PM, Enchanted Ridge Min Pins wrote:

OK, I will move to to Mia's litter like you asked. I will send you out a new contract soon. You will need to sign it and send it right back to me this time. Please let me know which one of the puppies you would like. Anna

Beware of this breeder, she will take all your money and give you nothing in return