Complaint Review: World Marketing Alliance(WMA Securities) - Duluth Georgia
- World Marketing Alliance(WMA Securities)
11315 Johns Creek Parkway
- Phone: (770)453-9300
- Category: Brokerage Companies
Avoid World Marketing Alliance (WMA Securities) misrepresent Its Products, erroneous information, fraud & illegal pyramid schemes
*UPDATE Employee: WFG Good and bad
*Consumer Comment: Network Marketing Not For All
*0: . Nepostism abounds, discrimination, you name it, they got it!
*Consumer Comment: Beware...
*UPDATE EX-employee responds: wma: the real truth ..This company is a pyramid scheme at it's best!
A business' first
line of defense
on the Internet.
If your business is
willing to make a
Click here now..
1. Read the May 2000 Money magazine expose of the WMA by Pat Regnier and Amy Feldman.
Regnier is a mutual-funds expert and former Morningstar analyst.
Also go to the NASD web-site and run an online search to obtain a report on the WMA's CRD record
(http://www.nasdr.com/2000.htm). The WMA's CRD
number is 32625. Note that the WMA illegally withheld nearly
900 complaints regarding misrepresentations of its VUL insurance product(see
2. Beware of High Income Claims:
WMA agents have been known to falsely claim high incomes:
A six-figure income is a common claim. If any WMA agent makes a claim about earning a high income through the WMA(or that it is his only source of income), insist upon receiving a personal photocopy of his federal income tax return. Take the return and submit it, without explanation, to: The Internal Revenue Service Criminal Investigation Division
If the information provided by the agent is legitimate, he will have nothing to fear whatsoever. If he fails to provide this proof, do not do business with him.
The WMA should furnish you with information regarding likely annual income, and termination rates(with terminations by category) consistent with federal and state franchise laws. See CFR 436
6_00.html), and your own state franchise laws.
3. Check Previous Employment Claims:
If any WMA agent claims to have left a lucrative job in the finance(or any other) industry, go to
http://www.nasdr.com/2000.htm to check his 10-year resume on file with the NASD. The CRD number for the WMA is 32625. Even
this information may be erroneous, as it is the responsibility of the WMA, not the NASD, to verify the employment claims. To further verify the information, obtain phone listings for the companies on the resume and call them before writing anyone a check or signing a contract. If you find no phone listings for any of the firms, certainly don't do business with the agent. WMA agents have also been known to (770)453-9300 themselves as
former engineers. Agents have also been known to misrepresent their educational backgrounds in order to establish credibility. If someone makes his educational background an issue by mentioning it, insist upon seeing the diploma. Write down the degree, name, and date of graduation for possible future reference.
4. Illegal Recruiting/Pyramid Scheme:
If a WMA agent emphasizes recruiting, rather than sales of a product(VULs, e.g.), then you are being asked to join an illegal pyramid scheme(see:
http://www.ftc.gov/speeches/other/dvimf16.htm, paragraph 4).
If, as a recruit, you are pressured into buying a product yourself, or are asked to take inordinately expensive training classes through the WMA(an investment in training), then the agent is engaging in inventory loading, and you are being asked to join an illegal pyramid scheme. See the new Pyramid Scheme Alert web-site and follow the links(http://www.pyramidschemealert.org).
In either instance, report this immediately to the Federal Trade
Commission(FTC) at https://www.ftc.gov/ftc/complaint.htm. Making payments until the day you are ultimately nailed shut into your coffin and hurled into a pit, or MRT insurance contained within the VUL, certainly constitute loading.
A former web-site for the WMA cited data from the 1999 WMA annual report, which indicated that the organization had recruited 272,000+ members and 8,400 licensed employees to date. As a securities license is necessary in order to make sales of their VUL and variable-annuity products, the 263,600+ members are clear losers as they at least pay a $100-$200 processing fee upon signing the MLM distributorship contract(see the California Department Corporations 1998 Desist & Refrain Order forbidding
the WMA from any additional sales of its MLM franchises in California).
Contact the San Francisco office of the Department for details through
Additionally a portion of the 8,400 licensed agents will also be net losers: these are clear pyramid-scheme numbers.
For claims about multi-level-marketing opportunities in general, see http://members.tripod.com/~nomorescams/fitzpatrick.htm.
Also go to
http://www.mlmlaw.com and browse the collection of cases brought against m-l-m firms for deception and fraud. Note that the presidents of these companies have been found to have lied about their personal wealth, top agents' incomes, the products, you name it. For information as to how m-l-m firms operate as cults, see the information about Amway, for example at http://www.freedomofmind.com/groups.htm. WMA founder Hubert Humphrey spent his formative years in Amway.
5. WRL VUL Insurance Misrepresentations:
Submit any sales illustrations to http://www.consumerfed.org/rorflyer.html.
Actuary James Hunt of the Consumer Federation of America will evaluate the truth of the claims for a nominal fee of $45. Mr. Hunt is also former Insurance Commissioner of
Vermont. The CFA also has links to publications and press releases, some of which are available for download as pdf files:
The Western Reserve Life VUL(variable universal life insurance) policy is heavily promoted by the WMA because it provides high commissions and fees. Beware of any claims indicating that this is a better use of your money than buying term life insurance and investing the difference in mutual funds placed in an IRA. The buy term and invest the difference(BTID) strategy is precisely what WMA founder Hubert Humphrey(CRD No. 857054)
advocated to customers when he was Vice President at A.L. Williams(see:
7). Now he advocates the exact opposite. Your challenge as a consumer is determining in which of the 2 instances he was actually telling the truth.
Numerous founders and early members of the WMA pyramid are former A.L. Williams(now Primerica) agents, and some, including Humphrey still report concurrent ALW/Primerica employment, indicating that they ultimately derive income from sets of customers(not necessarily mutually exclusive)who receive precisely the opposite insurance/financial advice. This is
clearly unethical, if not illegal.
To date, I have been able to obtain the CRD records of 25 of the 27 WMA employees who were featured speakers at the WMA 2000 Millennium Convention. They were listed on the WMA web-site
(http://www.wmas.com/events/2000MillConv/00_2851.htm) directly under the heading All-century Team All-Stars Why I a succeeding in WMA.
(a) The mean reported time of employment with the WMA was 7.29 years(note that starting dates with Alexander, Inc. were used for 4 employees - according to Money, Alexander, Inc. is the name of the pyramid Humphrey brought with him from Primerica).
(b) Sixty percent of these speakers reported having worked for A.L. Williams or Primerica: note that the employment need not fall within the scope of the 10-year NASD reporting requirement(the WMA was formed in 1991).
(c) If one includes work at Intersecurities(which according to the 1998 WRL Series Fund prospectus, is the Fund distributor), the number increases to 80%(I will provide a list of such members upon request). A number of individuals worked 1-2 years at Intersecurities in the interim between Primerica and WMA employment.
(d) At least 20% of the speakers have been reported for some sort of impropriety such as VUL misrepresentation.
(e) At least one had declared bankruptcy after joining the WMA.
According to Money(May 2000), the average annual VUL premium for policies sold through the WMA is $1,850. This is lower than the maximum annual contribution to an IRA account(traditional or Roth). Since Money reported that the WMA claims to specifically target persons who do not already have investment accounts, these individuals likely could have placed the total premium amount within a tax-protected IRA.
Look at the example chosen by the Western Reserve Life(WRL) actuaries to illustrate the benefits of the WRL Series Fund(1998 Prospectus). A 35-year-old male nonsmoker paying a $2,000 annual premium receives a death benefit of $165,000. At age 65(retirement), the cash value in the account(assuming the maximum allowable gross interest rate of 12% for such projections) would be $287,206(WRL Series Fund Prospectus, page 45). One reason is that the subaccount-mortality and portfolio-operating fees
reduce the interest rate 1.85% the first 15 years, and 1.70% the last 16(if you even believe their claim that the fee might be reduced).
Even if you purchased the same expensive insurance, simply investing in the mutual funds directly without the WRL's pickpocket interest fees would yield a cash value of $430,775. Using a price quoted for the same 35-year-old non-smoker category from Zurich Direct (January 1999), and adjusting the price downward to reflect the $165,000 death-benefit coverage, buying term and investing the difference directly into the same
mutual funds would yield a 30-year cash value of $505,198.
The WRL actuaries chose to illustrate Option A only. In Option A, if you die, your heirs receive either the death benefit or the cash value, but not both(whichever is greater). The cash value is multiplied by a limitati on percentage(page 15 of the Prospectus). Even if you did receive both, imagine you died at age 65. The total of the WRL $165,000 death benefit + the WRL cash value of $287,206 = 452,206, which is less than the total
cash value of the alternative cash value of $505,198 not even including the $165,000 death benefit($505,198 + $165,000 = $670,198). Under the WRL plan, the heirs of the insured would actually receive only $338.577.
The actuaries chose not even to illustrate Option B, which allows one to receive both the death benefit plus the cash value(times the limitation percentage) because the premiums must be increased proportionally to the coverage, which will significantly lower the cash value of $287,206 calculated for Option A. John Raymond Kenney(CRD No. 267984), The WRL CEO has been fined and censured by regulators for what appears to be insider trading. WMA Securities President Barry Milton Clause(CRD No. 1100029) has been fined and censured by regulators, and was specifically cited in 3 regulatory actions taken against his former firm Primerica, where he served as Compliance Director. Clause has also been known to suffer from Truth Deficit Disorder, as witnessed by his sworn deposition testimony in the
Tuttle v. A.L. Williams case(Dallas District Courts case 83-02089-L).
If a WMA agent tells you that purchasing a VUL(or any type of cash-value insurance policy) is an investment, he is guilty of investment misrepresentation, and he should be reported to your state department of insurance(see: http://www.naic.org/1regulator/usamap.htm). If he uses the
vanishing premiums misrepresentation, also report him, as this is also the subject of current litigation.
5. Insure Only against the Catastrophic:
If you have no dependents who would suffer catastrophic economic loss upon your death(e.g., inability to continue mortgage payments on your house), you probably don't even need life insurance. The WMA has been known to aggressively market policies to single persons, in good health, with no dependents, and no substantial tangible property. This is an out-and-out
If you didn't need life insurance, investing the $2,000 annually into an IRA would yield a 30-year cash value of $593,304.
6. Annuities Fraud & Misrepresentation:
If an agent sells you a tax-deferred annuity and then places it within an IRA, which is already tax-deferred, it is fraud. WRL, the WMA's major insurance partner is currently the subject of a class-action law suit for this practice(see:
Prudential and AEGON(WRL's parent company) are also named as defendants in the suit.
In addition, the suit claims that the plaintiffs were deliberately misled to believe their accounts were earning higher interest rates, because even the quarterly statements they received did not disclose the fees which reduced the gross interest rates in the mutual-fund accounts. The WMA and WRL Compliance Departments are known to defend this illegal practice. The practice occurs because, unlike mutual funds, the annuities generate large commissions and fees for WMA and WRL, at the consumers' expense. See NASD Directive 99-35 on annuity
7. Verify All Business Addresses & Telephone Numbers:
Verify business addresses with your state department of
insurance(see above). The business address listed by your agent with the department should have a listed telephone number, in the telephone directory.
The address submitted to the insurance department should agree with the business address he gives you. Do not do business with anyone who uses PO boxes or unlisted telephone numbers. Complaints about such problems, use
of multiple aliases, fraudulent sales illustrations, and agent
misrepresentation of professional/educational credentials and income have been made to the WMA Compliance Department, to no avail.
The WMA has actively recruited and compensated convicted
8. Consult an attorney before signing a contract with the WMA, and ask him specifically about any financial or legal liability you might incur regarding the persons in your downline. You will probably be surprised.
9. See the following popular business-publication web-sites for
information about Variable Universal Life(VUL) insurance:
Money Magazine Series(Follow Links)
Kiplinger Letter Series(Follow Links)
Business Week Article http://www.businessweek.com/1998/15/b3573139.htm
Also read the article entitled Who Needs Whole Life? in the July 1998 issue of Consumer Reportshttp://www.consumerreports.org/).
The author discusses cash-value life insurance in general. VUL is a type of cash-value insurance. I am not certain if access
to the article is free on the web-site, but many libraries
carry the publication.
Consult a Chartered Financial Analyst(http://www.aimr.com/)
or better an actuary(http://www.soa.org) for an independent
an unbiased opinion about Variable Universal Life insurance.
Actuaries must pass a series of rigorous mathematical examinations, and are the experts who actually design
insurance policies and benefit plans. The Actuarial Board
for Counseling and Discipline has links for its member
Unlike members of the WMA, they must subscribe to a code of ethics. College dropout and WMA CEO and founder Hubert Humphrey actually failed the securities supervisors exam 4 times before finally passing, which should be listed in the Guinness Book of World Records.
The other 2 members of A.L.Williams Buy Term and Invest the Difference group who left with him to set up the WMA include someone from the San Jose State athletic department, and former
construction worker Monte Holm. Monte Holm has been charged and fined in a WMA fraud/cover-up scandal in Texas.
10. The FTC can now hold members of multi-level-marketing firms completely responsible for the claims they make about the products of the parent firm.
"If you decide to become a distributor, remember that you're legally responsible for the claims you make about the company, its product and the business opportunities it offers. That applies even if you're simply repeating claims you read in a company brochure or advertising flyer.
When you promote the qualities of a product or service, you're obligated to present those claims truthfully and to ensure there's enough evidence to back them up. The Federal Trade Commission advises you to verify the research behind any claims about a product's performance before repeating those claims to a potential customer."
-Federal Trade Commission
If you are unable to understand what is in the actual WRL Series Fund 60-page prospectus, do not sell the product. Save all classroom materials, sales illustrations, etc., given to you by the WMA and send copies to the various aforementioned regulators. If you were misled as an agent, you may wish to contact regulators anonymously by e-mail first. Many former WMA
agents are victims who were simply targeted for VUL sales themselves, and to obtain a list of their friends for their upline sponsor to bilk before the agents themselves completed training or could earn commissions.
11. Beware: Persons in multi-level-marketing organizations like the WMA often prey upon even church congregations. You may wish to remind your minister or priest of John 2: 14-16, for example, if this becomes a problem at a church you attend. WMAS sued Richard Fischl's widow to keep from paying her off after he had husband bought phony securities from a WMA agent who had infiltrated his Bible-study group(WMA Securities Inc. v.
Ruppert, S.D. Ohio, Case No. C 1 99 492) Richard Fischl committed suicide after being swindled out of his life savings(as reported in the May 2000 issue of Money).
12. For additional information/advice: Contact radio-talk-show host and financial advisor Dave Ramsey http://www.financialpeace.com/).
He has discussed the WMA and their primary product, Variable Universal Life insurance, on a number of occasions. You may
wish to contact radio-talk-show host and financial advisor
Just say the words Variable Universal Life, Multi Level Marketing, and World Marketing Alliance.
13. Any and all misrepresentations by WMA agents should additionally be reported to your state securities
commission(http://www.nasaa.org/regulator/) and state attorney
14. Here are some additional links regarding the WMA:
NASD Complaint Cover-Up
California Desist & Refrain(Cited in 10QSB SEC Filing)
Arizona Corporations Commission
Nevada Securities Commission
Cornerstone Prodigy Group Ponzi
Additional Cornerstone Articles:
Royal Meridian(Thomas Connolly)
WMA 4 Phony Bank Investment
Ohio FLIC/Miller(Office Supervisor)
Ohio FLIC Donald Wayne Owens
Money Magazine WMA Expose
SEC Investigation/Prime Assets Home Loan Fraud
CA University Credit-Card Fraud(Use "World Marketing Alliance" Name) http://www.usc.edu/student-affairs/dt/V136/N28/01-company.28c.html
FLIC Ponzi Scheme
Montana Labor Ruling
I have a copy of the actual Montana action, but it's in microsoft format(I have a Mac) and I have to take it somewhere to open it up.
ChoicePoint on Massachusetts RMIB
Duluth Office Intimidation(Whipsuit)
Click here to read other Rip Off Reports on WMA Securities
This report was posted on Ripoff Report on 03/17/2001 12:00 AM and is a permanent record located here: https://www.ripoffreport.com/reports/world-marketing-alliancewma-securities/duluth-georgia-30097-1517/avoid-world-marketing-alliance-wma-securities-misrepresent-its-products-erroneous-infor-4700. The posting time indicated is Arizona local time. Arizona does not observe daylight savings so the post time may be Mountain or Pacific depending on the time of year. Ripoff Report has an exclusive license to this report. It may not be copied without the written permission of Ripoff Report. READ: Foreign websites steal our content
If you would like to see more Rip-off Reports on this company/individual, search here:
Advertisers above have met our
strict standards for business conduct.