federal judge james m.moody& us gov"t us supreme court James Moody intervened on my case after Judge Reasoner died,dismissed a case that had a trial date. little rock, Arkansas

There is some very disturbing news to Report about this Case.Mr. Smith was shot with 44 magnum,Super Magnums,Close Range.j*****f and Kent,what would the entrance and exit wounds be with such a High Caliber Gun?

The Eighth Circuit, in their opinion upholding the ruling of Judge Moody, did cite MANY cases as to why they were ruling the way they were acting.  So there goes that argument buddy.

Mincey v. Arizona addressed ONLY the admissibility of evidence and statements gathered in a particular homicide, finding that the searches and questioning of the badly injured suspect were inadmissible and essentially voiding Arizona's "homicide scene" exemption to warrantless searches.  Don't see where, having read the 8th Circuit's description of your complaint, this has anything to do with your case.  Your case seems to dwell entirely on the state's civil liability for items allegedly stolen during the processing of a crime scene as possible violations of 4th Amendment...which the Court found none.  It looks like, based on the opinion of the Court, that your legal team completely botched the appeal...failing to assert things on the initial case, citing irrelevant case law.

Unfortunately, I cannot access PACER to read the entire case but in the opinion I see nothing related to this alleged cover up in your son's death.

Also, the whole "I'm not giving up evidence until I get into court" thing. Not the way it works.  Cause then the other side can object to it.  No wonder your lawyers didn't wanna see you.  At the very least, you have to let your lawyers see the evidence to properly handle your case.

What was the court docket number for the original case that Judge Moody dismissed?  I would like to see what is available on that.  I can also find no record of your son's death, so care to share some details.  Who do you allege killed him?  Why?

Okay genius, here is a link for the United States District Court system that shows the boundaries of each Circuit(fancy word for district):

http://www.uscourts.gov/court_locator.aspx

You will see that Arkansas and Missouri are both in the 8th Circuit.  Now about your friend in Tennessee and his letter about similar cases and their value.  Tennessee is in the 6th Circuit.  Rulings in one Circuit do not set precedent for all Districts and only carry the weight of law in the Circuit of finding.  They can certainly be introduced in another Circuit but that Court is not required to give them any more value.

So the police told you to record everything.  Big whoop.  Just because the deceased judges secretary says you have nothing worry about doesn't mean you don't have anything to worry about.  Again, it has no evidential value in court because she has no standing to make you any guarantees/promises.

Incidentally, no I am not a lawyer.  Just someone who happens to know some of the ins & outs of our Court system.

Here's the Docket no.'s concerning this case,for All to see.The original Case Billy Smith vs d**k Busby Et. Al. no. 3:02-cv 000386 SMR.   US Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals no.04-3544. Case no. Smith vs Moody  5:07-cv-77. The 8th Circuit Denied  by Arnold,Bye and Smith decided to not Cosider for Rehearing,but this Case was never Heard by a Jury.The 8th Circuit never gave an Opinion.Anyone knows the Supreme Court can't Review a Case without a Lower Courts Ruling.Our esteemed Rebutter states other Judges From different states can be Brought in.But this letter of Recusal by Judge Leon Holmes states his Recusal was Because he Serves in the Same  Judicial District.From Arkansas to Missouri,I don't think the Districts Run that Far,Do You.This Case was sent to Supreme Court to not  only uphold the Entire US Constitution but the Supreme Courts The 9-0 Ruling by the US Supreme Court (Mincey v Arizona) governs the Law on Homicide scenes.This Case received by Supreme Court Jan.2006 by William K. Suter,Clerk.202-479-3025.Get this,8th Circuit states,Moody's Ruling Affirmed,Case Rejected.Not 1 piece of Case Law,nothing.Nor Did I get an Opinion. But what Really gets me and them,I have a Retired Judge in Tennessee whom states.Billy I'm going to write a Letter for You.This Letter States a similar case in Tennessee was settled for Many Millions,but your Case is Much Bigger.This guy has been A Judge and Lawyer longer than All the Judges on my Case,much Longer.James Moody should in no way be a Judge.He cares nothing about the Law,only whom He serves,The very Rich.He does as he is Told.What I  was suing for,is a Systemic Problem in this State,and has been for Many years.James Moody used State Law to Reverse Federal Law,and the Supreme Court has Heard Every Case since its Inception,when this Occurs.

I wonder why the Newspapers and TV stations won't touch this story.  Perhaps it is the feeling that this report may at the least be an exageration, at most an outright fabrication.

According to your claims, we have this case that was heard by the US Supreme Court and they ruled in his favor 9-0.  Yet a Federal Judge decided on his own to overturn the ruling of the US Supreme Court.

But let's say that everything that was written here is true.  Okay..then please provide the Docket and Court information for the case that the judge decided to overturn.  While you are at it provide the Docket number for the Supreme Court hearing.

Oh and the only reason that RipOff Report "touched" your story is because you wrote it.  See they post EVERYTHING, and it is their policy to not remove it. 

To the People writing Rebuttals,they must be Attorneys.The Real Rebuttals must come from the State of Arkansas or US Gov't.Back to the Rebuttals,these People involved,are scared to Death of What Evidence I really have.My son,Billy Joe Smith Jr. is the "First and Only" DEATH CERTIFICATE  to ever be changed from Suicide to Homicide without an Autopsy ever being Performed.I have No Time for Uneducated People whom know anything About the Law.As for a Judge over-Ruling another Judge you are Right.But this Case is Where Moody over-Ruled a Unanimous 9-0 Ruling by the U.S.Supreme Court.Also,If I were Wrong,and any of You were Close to Right,I would have Already been to Court,Catch my Drift.Like I said,you know my name and Where I live,I'm availabe Any Time.  What Really Ticks Everyone Off IS,The Police gave me a Tape Recorder,Their very Words,Tape All Your Conversations.I did Just That.Everything I have on Tape is Legal in a Court-Room.How About that.Plus the Investigating Detective,He's GONE.He was Terminated.The Arkansas Crime Lab was Totally Re-organized after this Fiasco.There were also Alot of Retirements after I went to Battle? I have Evidence,Large Amounts of Things,not on Just my Case,but others.The Newspapers and TV will Not touch this Story.Only Rip-Off Report has shown the Nerve to touch my Story.I will say this,I was supposed to Meet with my Attorney on a Thursday.I call as I'M  leaving my Home to Meet Her.Her Secretary says"Someone called Monday" and said you,Billy Joe,was not going to be able to Meet with Us.I will not give up any Evidence,only when I go to Court,which WILL  eventually Happen.But I will say this,I hired Arkansas's best Death Investigator.He has done Alot of Work in Arkansas.He told me,backed up by a very Trusted Attorney in Arkansas,Alot of Things.I mean,He Started Telling me Many Things from Way Back,and Guess What Rebuttals.ITS ALL ON TAPE.

1. Just because one judge rules one way does not preclude another judge from ruling differently if they feel the first judge erred.

2. What the deceased judge's secretary says means exactly squat to the new presiding judge and has no value in a court of law.

3.  You filed some kind of complaint against a sitting Federal judge.  As the other judges in the state were probably acquainted with him, it was proper for them to recuse themselves.  The judge brought in from MO was perfectly allowable.  As you state, Federal judges are appointed to districts and not states.  As such, they may preside anywhere within their given district as needed.  Had you bothered to research the matter, you would see that both AR and MO are in District 8...so there was nothing improper about bringing the MO judge in.  Sounds like you need a new attorney cause he is clueless about Federal Courts procedure.