• Report: #562294
Complaint Review:


  • Submitted: Sat, January 30, 2010
  • Updated: Sat, March 05, 2011

  • Reported By: WolvesinSheepClothing — sacramento California United States of America
Internet United States of America

PennyAuctionWatch.com Penny Auctions Controlled Directly Or Indirectly By Them Bidrodeo.com, Quibids.com, Bidcactus.com, Zoozle.com Misleading Information About Penny Auctions, Internet

*Consumer Suggestion: How to check a site AND "a ripoff by any other name.."

*REBUTTAL Owner of company: Penny Auction Watch is not a scam, doesn't own any Penny Auction Site

*UPDATE EX-employee responds: pennyauctionwatch.com(PAW) is 100% SCAM and ran by someone that owns SEVERAL Penny Auctions.

*Consumer Comment: PAW fails to answer questions!

*Consumer Comment: PAW FORUM HAS HELPED ME

*Consumer Comment: You've Got to be Kidding Me!

*Consumer Comment: hahahahahahahaha

*REBUTTAL Owner of company: Stop lying, please.

*UPDATE Employee: The report is true penny auction watch is misleading people

*Consumer Comment: Reporter live2bids is a fake and Liar

*UPDATE Employee: Original report is false

*Consumer Comment: Accusations by reporter are ridiculous

*UPDATE Employee: I Agree with the reporter

*REBUTTAL Owner of company: I do NOT own ANY penny auctions!

REBUTTAL BOX™ | Respond to this Report! | Consumer Comment

What's this?
Corporate Advocacy Program

Show customers why they should trust your business over your competitors...

What's this?
What's this?
Is this
Ripoff Report
About you?
Ripoff Report
A business' first
line of defense
on the Internet.
If your business is
willing to make a
commitment to
customer satisfaction
Click here now..

Does your business have a bad reputation?
Fix it the right way.
Corporate Advocacy Program™

Set the record straight:
Arbitration Program

SEO Reputation Management at its best!

Penny Auction Watch Claims, To Be One On The Side Of Honest Penny Auction Players Giving An Unbiased Watch Report Of Various Penny Auctions On The Web?But This Is a Scam. They Have And Continue, To  Promote Penny Auction Websites That Are Directly Or Indirectly Controlled By Them! Or People Close To Them! Upon Closer Inspection Of There http://www.Pennyauctionwatch.com scam One Will Quickly See That They Will Give Rather Gleaming Reports Of Obscure And Relatively New Sites, While Any Other  Site That Poses A Direct Threat To There Pockets Are Purposely And Relentlessly Cast In A Negative Light, While Maintaining And Steering Penny Auction Members Into Penny Auction Sites Directly Or Indirectly Controlled By Them, THIS IS A SCAM, http://www.PennyAuctionwatch.com Is A SCAM

Case Study #1 Penny Auction Watch Will Discredit Any And All Companies That Are Not Directly or Indirectly Controlled By Them,  At First Glance You Would Think That They Were Providing A Genuine Service, But Upon Closer Inspection, All Of There Negative  Posts Are Followed Up With Relatively Unknown  Penny Auctions Posts And Blatant Suggestions Like This One To Guide The  Reader To A Site Controlled By Them

DimeDivas.Another site I frequently have technical trouble loading and bidding on, but have won 3 awesome items and have had all 3 shipped within days of winning. Travis has always replied to my emails very quickly and I think they are going to be very very successful.great support, great service, HOT items!! Whats not to love???

I would like to thank Jackie and Joe at zoozle for taking care of my wife yesterday. Once my wife contacted them about a item it was shipped to her the next day. Thats great support. Also with Rockybids changeover they have have problems I have spoken to them a number of times and been taken care of. Great Support. Bidrodeo has also taken care of any issues right away when I have contacted them.Anytime I have had a suggestion or issue Weronika has emailed me right away.
Great support I have used other sites but these three sites are the sites I use and trust.

So far Zoozle.com, Rockybid.com, live2bid.com are the best in customer support.

I have had great customer service with quibids, I have won a PS3 a dyson vacuum and an iPod touch all shipped within a few days from Amazon with a note A gift from Quibid"?. That Doesn't Sound Like A Watch Dog Service But, A Blatant Advertisement By The Owners of Penny Auction Watch To Steer There Readers Into Websites Directly Controlled By Them. The Websites Controlled Directly Or Indirectly By Them Or Obvious  Rockybids.com, Quibids.com, Zoozle.com  Bidrodeo.com and live2bid.com

Case Study #2, "Can Do No Harm", The Websites Controlled Directly Or Indirectly By Penny Auction Watch Will Never Get A Negative Review And Are Always Purposely Cast In A Positive Light, Which Websites Would These Be? One Only Needs To Open There Eyes And Look , These Websites Are Repeated In There Posts Time, And Time Again, And Everytime They Are Always Cast As The Savior, As The Safe Ones, As The Ones That Can Be Trusted And Can Do No Harm, And To "Not "Patronize There Website's Is Foolish?  There Websites Have No Negative Comments, That Is Not Normal, Any Business Dealing With The Public At Large Is Going To Have Some Form Of A Complaint Or Negative Comment, Its Human Nature, Pennyauctionwatch.com is a scam. Just Look How They Talk Up The Sites Owned by Them Time And Time Again. Http://www.pennyauctionwatch.com is a scam Don't Lose Your Money To There Scam filled Bot Shillbidder Filled Websites http://www.Bidcactus.com scam http://wwwquibids.com scam, http://wwwrockybid.com scam, http://www.zoozle.com scam

This report was posted on Ripoff Report on 01/30/2010 02:54 PM and is a permanent record located here: http://www.ripoffreport.com/reports/pennyauctionwatchcom/internet/pennyauctionwatchcom-penny-auctions-controlled-directly-or-indirectly-by-them-bidrodeoco-562294. The posting time indicated is Arizona local time. Arizona does not observe daylight savings so the post time may be Mountain or Pacific depending on the time of year.

Ripoff Report has an exclusive license to this report. It may not be copied without the written permission of Ripoff Report. READ: Foreign websites steal our content

Click Here to read other Ripoff Reports on PennyAuctionWatch.com

Search for additional reports

If you would like to see more Rip-off Reports on this company/individual, search here:

Search Tips
Report & Rebuttal
Respond to this report!
What's this?
Also a victim?
What's this?
Repair Your Reputation!
What's this?
0Author 11Consumer 3Employee/Owner
Updates & Rebuttals

#1 Consumer Suggestion

How to check a site AND "a ripoff by any other name.."

AUTHOR: pherd1 - (USA)

Come on folks,  rebuttals like "they are in different cities, they can't be two places at once.."

Solution:  Just use the "whois" tool, available by searching Google and other sites.


One of the more "real" looking fake sites is:


Which to the untrained eye seems to be a real website of a real news organization!  They even "fill"
the site with RSS news feeds, and have "stock art" pictures of "news reporters."

The site "reports" that it is a TV station from San Diego.  However, using the "whois" to check
the actual owner of the site and you get:


.. doesn't exactly sound like a TV station website, does it? (smile)

Just a personal though regarding ALL "penny auction" sites.

Even IF:

- they have an actual honestly run website
- they deliver promptly on every order
- they don't "shill" their own auctions

"Penny Auctions" are STILL ripoffs...  Most "sample pages" and "promos" list a 2011 car won
for "only" (in the example I saw) $1817.63.
Let's supposed the AVERAGE "cost per bid" is .25, some are more, some are less, some have
"bid sales," but STILL..
At .25 per "penny bid" they will make $45,440.75 + 1817.63 (the bid) + assume $0 taxes
+ 500.00 (shipping/handling) = $47,758.38

They could sell 2011 BMW's brand new all day long, being completely honest and upstanding,
and all you have is an "honest and upstanding ripoff!"
When you add the "mailing list" secondary income, onsite ads, reports of shilling and
what-not, it just makes a "ripoff site" a BIGGER "ripoff site."

It's very similar to the "putting lipstick on the pig" analogy..
It still smells badly, and just annoys the pig..
Respond to this report!
What's this?

#2 REBUTTAL Owner of company

Penny Auction Watch is not a scam, doesn't own any Penny Auction Site

AUTHOR: PennyAuctionWatch - (United States of America)

Seawall: You were banned from PAW because you were rude to other members and violated the rules continuously. I'll have you know, once again, that I the owner and operator of PENNY AUCTION WATCH do not own or operate any penny auction site nor do any penny auction sites own me or my site. 


Also, it's ironic how one of the sites you list that PAW is "owned by" is actually suing me right now because I stated my opinion.

Nick, you're wrong and you know it. I didn't SHILL anything, also I DO NOT get free bids for ads but monetary compensation, like any media outlet gets. No free bids, now stop spreading your lies about me because you know you're wrong. I

Feel free to join http://pennyauctionwatch.com/forum and see for yourself. 

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#3 UPDATE EX-employee responds

pennyauctionwatch.com(PAW) is 100% SCAM and ran by someone that owns SEVERAL Penny Auctions.

AUTHOR: seawall9 - (United States of America)

This Penny Auction Watch site is Major scam(pennyauctionwatch.com).  Also known as "PAW".

PAW is a front for these dishonest penny auction owners to make their sites look legit.  Penny Auction Owners plant positive experiences on here(Complaints Board) and on the Penny Auction Watch forums(PAW) to bait people into playing and buying bid packs.   Buying bid packs to bid on items?  What a joke and scam!

Go to (((Redacted))) and search "penny auctions for sale"

There you can see how these operates by the use of controlled bots on autobid to scam any real people into buying more and more bid packs until the reserve price has at least been met for that item that's bid on.  They aren't in the business to LOSE money and will never ACTUALLY sell an item below value.   If not enough real people are bidding on a particular item for a while, they will end the auction to a bot name.  They will then list the bots name in the "Auction History" section to make it look as if REAL people actually win and auction is honest+fair.  

You can buy your own Penny Auction from Flippa.com and start scamming also.  So easy to do.

Also. Google, "penny auction website script" and see how these scams operate.  The scripts are cheap to buy.

To build up traffic to your scam penny auction you must plant positive experiences on  forums such as PAW(PAW is a front).  You must also dispute ANY negativity or complaints on forums such as this.  For EX, tell the angry complainer that he must be crazy, use stupid bidding techniques and unlucky because you win all the time and just won a 52inch Plasma for 2 bucks.  People WILL start believing you if you plant enough fake postitive experiences/reviews.  

JUST make sure to use different names each time you fake post.  If you use same name over and over again telling everyone you win all the time, people will begin to catch on and realize it's just a fake post planted by the Penny Site operator/owner.

They cheat you and make a killing from people like you that bought into it. Some will even go as far as to advertise on social networking sites such as "FACEBOOK" and write stories of winning items for $4 and so on to get people to join the site.I call it their, "Fake Social Environment" where they ask and answer their own questions attempting to be perceived as an honest and fair auction.  For EX they will say, "I just won 12 Lap Tops for $40 and they all arrived today in factory sealed boxes! I love this site!"

Anyone can do this... so easy to make money.  

MAKE sure that the server that hosts your scam auction is located outside of the USA so you can get around federal gambling regulated laws.  If heat gets to much, then shut scam auction down and create a new one.  Repeat process.

Happy scammin'!!

I tried to post that on PAW(pennyauctionwatch[.]com) to warn good honest people BUT they wouldn't allow it to post..

 I wonder why? ;)

So i'll just post away on websites such as this.

You use to could post on PAW right away but now they have a Moderator that must approve your post first..

I wonder why that is? ;)

I think we ALL know why that is :)

****************Penny auction watch, penny auction traffic ran by the same owners as bidcactus, for10cents.com,  beezid and swipebids these are the real con man

 CLICK here to see why Rip-off Report, as a matter of policy, deleted either a phone number, link or e-mail address from this Report.
Respond to this report!
What's this?

#4 Consumer Comment

PAW fails to answer questions!

AUTHOR: PAWisAfrontFORanAUCTIONbusinessOFth - (United States of America)

Check this out!

Questions UNANSWERED by PAW owner!


Respond to this report!
What's this?

#5 Consumer Comment


AUTHOR: KSteven7 - (United States of America)

Before I found PAW I was a victim of several less than honest Penny Auction sites. I didn't know how to record auctions, watch for system issues or recognize shill bidders.  I took time to really read the threads before I ever joined the forum and it helped.  More than you can imagine.  I learned that bidders I had thought were bots were actually Power Bidders. 

I find it humorous that in one paragraph the forum is accused of being a co-owner of several sites but some of those same sites have threads where bidders questioned the integrity of the site.  If I had a monetary stake in those sites and I was running the forum the threads would have been promptly removed.  Instead PAW allows the users to provide their own insight about the auction. 

Anyone who believes that a forum which has provided a GENUINE service to the customers of penny auction sites is a bad thing has to have an ulterior motive.  I can think of several. Either you are a dishonest site or a competitor in the PA forum world.  In reality, this poser is really just giving PAW more attention and hopefully will direct even more users to PAW that can provide me with more information on other sites that are out there.  I want to Thank Amanda for taking the time to develop and moderate the site.  You have saved me hundreds of dollars..  Thank you.... Happy bidding to all..  

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#6 Consumer Comment

You've Got to be Kidding Me!

AUTHOR: outlander - (United States of America)

Penny Auction Watch maintains forums where players on many auction sites can comment on their experiences.  I have posted there a number of times, and recognize the names of other bidders I've met on various sites.  The original report is nothing less than slander and an attempt to discredit a service that protects bidders from the unscrupulous owners of dishonest auction sites.  It would appear that the original complaint was filed by an unhappy owner who got caught at his own game.
Respond to this report!
What's this?

#7 Consumer Comment



PAW accepts bids in return for advertising, and even admits to shilling her own site.  She now uses this site to boost her links to her site by spamming her links here
Respond to this report!
What's this?

#8 REBUTTAL Owner of company

Stop lying, please.

AUTHOR: PennyAuctionWatch - (United States of America)

What are your motives here? I suppose you're one of those guys that opened up one of the rip off sites of pennyauctionwatch.com that are trying to "destroy" and discredit me with your false accusations? Either that or you're a penny auction site that did have bot bidders or didn't ship items, or both? I do not and have not owned a penny auction site. I opened pennyauctionwatch.com after being a penny auction bidder that DID get scammed by penny auctions.

As for those who have common sense check out http://www.pennyauctionwatch.com/forum to learn more about penny auctions
And if you believe any penny auction site to be a scam please do not hesitate to email me and/or post in the forum.

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#9 UPDATE Employee

The report is true penny auction watch is misleading people

AUTHOR: Inside Informer - (United States of America)

The report is right on the owners of penny auction watch mislead people and have been doing it for awhile, penny auction watch has ruined the reputations of many penny auctions but what they fail to realize is that they only managed to ruin it for themselves hehehehe there like the kid at school who gos around telling people you have herpes, when you dont, penny auction watch has singlehandidly tainted the whole penny auction industry hehehe its so funny coz there plan backfired on them hehehehe. there losing so much money cause nobody bys there bidpkgs and there paying money for advertising hehhehehe. I hope they keep putting out there "scam" "red flag reports" each one is another nail in the coffin for them hehehe. they should be happy they got what the desrve




Respond to this report!
What's this?

#10 Consumer Comment

Reporter live2bids is a fake and Liar

AUTHOR: Stuff4me2Win - (United States of America)

to live2bids...

This comment was not from any employee of PennyAuctionWatch, or the website Live2bid.com.   There is only 1 employee of Live2bid.com, the owner.  I'm a close friend of the owner of Live2bid.com, and the poser who claims to be an employee is just plainly a liar.

This whole thread should be removed as it is totally mis-information about PennyAuctionWatch and the PennyAuction sites that were quoted.

Live2Bid.com is re-launching March 27th.

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#11 UPDATE Employee

Original report is false

AUTHOR: J4me - (United States of America)

The original author of this report should be rather embarrassed of his/her claim.  I work for QuiBids and can assure you PennyAuctionWatch has no ownership in our company.  Our boss and CEO is Matt Beckham - this was posted in our interview with PAW last month.

I have always found PAW to be an honset and reliable site.  They make it known, the owners of each penny auction, through their interviews, as well as depicting the more legitimate auction sites.  From reading the last rebuttal, I absolutely agree with and suggest checking the IP addresses to see where all these sites come from!  PAW is doing nothing wrong and everything right in doing their best to point penny auction participants to the more reliable auction sites.  I applaud PAW's owner!

Customer testimonials - people get excited when they get a good deal on a particular product and always want to tell others.  Those are our customers and we want them to tell us, as well as others!  It's human nature and how it goes.  Not only for penny auction sites, but you'll find testimonials for all different kinds of companies/services/etc. in other industries.  How is that really any different?

I can now only assume the original report was posted by a member of a dishonest penny penny auction site... or someone who has had a bad experience with participating on the sites that were mentioned.  If that's the case, I'm sorry to hear that.  I hate to make assumptions, but the report doesn't make sense in any aspect.  Claims like these are just silly and should be taken off.

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#12 Consumer Comment

Accusations by reporter are ridiculous

AUTHOR: angelducky - (USA)

The allegations by the original reporter are ridiculous and incorrect. The assumption that the person who owns the forum PennyAuctionWatch.com also owns multiple auction sites is absurd.

I have spoken personally with several of the auction owners of the sites that the reporter claims are owned by the same person who runs PennyAuctionWatch.com. Judging by my own impressions based on speech patterns of the auction owners as well as the owner of PennyAuctionWatch.com, I can assure everyone they are different people. 

As concrete evidence of this, looking purely at the IP address of the emails obtained by corresponding with auction owners of sites such as Zoozle.com, Dime-Divas.com, RockyBid.com, Live2Bid.com, BidCactus.com, and multiple other sites that I have bid on in the past, it is clear to see that unless any of the owners are capable of being in multiple cities within hours of sending me emails, each owner of the site is a unique individual with a unique IP address which is in NO WAY similar to that of emails obtained through corresponding with the owner of PennyAuctionWatch.com.

There is a thread on PennyAuctionWatch.com which asks users to post when they have good customer service experiences and those excerpts that the reporter used are drawn directly from that thread and are not the opinions of the owner of PennyAuctionWatch.com.

The PennyAuctionWatch.com forum gives users the opportunity to discuss penny auction sites and to decide for themselves whether they are legitimate or scams. The majority of the time, sites are not marked as scams unless there is concrete proof to back up allegations which are posted on the forum for auction owners to address and/or explain. Often the forum members are the ones that urge the owner of PennyAuctionWatch.com to move threads into the Red Flags section after members experience suspicious behavior on certain sites.

The original report gave no conclusive evidence supporting the claims that the owner of PennyAuctionWatch.com owns multiple penny auction sites. On the contrary, looking at the IP address of emails obtained through corresponding with auction owners proves definitively that these claims are false. 
Respond to this report!
What's this?

#13 UPDATE Employee

I Agree with the reporter

AUTHOR: live2bids - (United States of America)

This report is a valid report.  I happen to know someone that knows the Owner of PennyAuctionWatch and have heard from several people that the owner named Amanda does indirectly control some of the penny auction sites.  She owns a few sites herself and claims that she does not. This is a complete scam.  DO not believe everything you read on the forum as most of the members are part of the scam.

Now she is posting messages to PAW members asking for them to comment and back her up on this report.  


Respond to this report!
What's this?

#14 REBUTTAL Owner of company

I do NOT own ANY penny auctions!

AUTHOR: PennyAuctionWatch - (United States of America)


I am the founder of PennyAuctionWatch.com, the original report by "WolvesinSheepClothing-from Sacramento, California" is blatant slander/defamation/libel.

PennyAuctionWatch.com is an informative blog and forum for penny auctions. What is a penny auction? PennyAuctionWatch.com does not charge readers/users anything.

I started PennyAuctionWatch.com after being defrauded on penny auction sites and found that there was no discussion forum or clearinghouse for penny auctions, I had no way to determine whether or not I was bidding against real bidders or phony scam automated bot shill bidders, which are used by a number of sites and software developers. So I created the site to be a place for users of penny auction sites to come together and discuss their experiences for people to be able to form their own opinions, as well as a place to present what  we have found out about penny auction sites. Check out my site and you will see just how widespread the dishonest practices in penny auctions are. A few examples of this:  Penny auction site owner admitting to shill bidding, and another, to evidence of an auction owner(s) requesting  shill bot bidding scripts, to site owners posting fake testimonials in our forum and another, as well as what seems to be fake videos testimonials on YouTube. Also, first-hand observation of  shill bidding auto bots in the administrative consoles of penny auctions, to developers touting their penny auction Intelligent Investment Protector addon script as a solution sure to avert suspicion of fake bidders, to one software developer proudly proclaiming  that their autobots = your angels = protectors = body and business guards! Many more instances of unethical bidding practices have been posted on  PennyAuctionWatch.com and in our entertainment shopping forum.

Never once does PennyAuctionWatch.com claim to be an UNBIASED source. We point out the positives on penny auction sites that we have tested as well as the negative (shill bidders/scams) that we find, we cannot and do not know all auction sites out there, but if you do find some that seem to be legit we will tell people, same goes for the dishonest sites, but you still need to use your own discernment when bidding on any penny auction website.

I, the founder and sole owner of PennyAuctionWatch.com do not own or run any penny auction, reverse auction, pay-per-bid, bid-fee, or entertainment shopping auction websites.

The only income that I receive is from affiliate links and approved advertising (similar to RipOffReport.com). And this is disclosed.

PennyAuctionWatch.com is just like RipOffReport.com, but for Penny Auctions.

The comments that  "WolvesinSheepsClothing" posted in this original report were from my forum, they are not even comments made by myself (the founder and sole owner of PennyAuctionWatch.com), but were copy/pasted from the forum thread "Good Customer Support Experiences with Penny Auctions." They were then posted on my blog last week here: http://www.pennyauctionwatch.com/2010/01/good-customer-service-experiences-penny-auctions

Since PennyAuctionWatch.com is an open forum I cannot guarantee the accuracy of any post or comments, but I do investigate to the best of my ability when users post accusations of fraud/wrongdoing as well as when they post positive testimonials.

As to you ("WolvesinSheepsClothing") I do not know whether or not you are someone who has been exposed by way of my site,  PennyAuctionWatch.com or what your interests are, but if you are indeed running a penny auction site or developing software to outright scam people out of their money you will be found out and you will be exposed and hopefully prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law.

If you are interested in penny auctions please feel free to check out http://www.PennyAuctionWatch.com, where we give out information and provide a penny auction directory as well as forum, free of charge to all readers and forum members.

Thank you!

Respond to this report!
What's this?
Report & Rebuttal
Respond to this report!
What's this?
Also a victim?
What's this?
Repair Your Reputation!
What's this?