Report: #1135060

Complaint Review: American Coin & Stamp Brokerage, Inc

  • Submitted: Mon, March 31, 2014
  • Updated: Wed, June 18, 2014
  • Reported By: Alan K — Jefferson Wisconsin
  • American Coin & Stamp Brokerage, Inc

    Merrick, New York

American Coin & Stamp Brokerage, Inc A.C.S.B.American Coin and Stamp Brokerage Beware of this company's offerings, grading claims, and false advertising! Merrick New York

*Author of original report: I stand by my original report.

*Consumer Comment: Surprised!

Show customers why they should trust your business over your competitors...

Is this
Ripoff Report
About you?
Ripoff Report
A business' first
line of defense
on the Internet.
If your business is
willing to make a
commitment to
customer satisfaction
Click here now..

Beware of this company's offerings and rigged "Mail Bid Sale," which they offer monthly via catalog. I purchases TWICE from them, and my last order was for well over $350. They claim to run a mail bid sale, however, you have no idea who is winning any "bids," and you can be assured that it's not like a real auction or bidding situation, because you will only "win" the item if your bid/offer assures them of a hefty profit.

In my case, I purchased numerous coins, and was new to the hobby. In my first purchase, I "won" a half-dime that they graded "MS-62," but when I took it to several local dealers, they assured me that the coin was not only dipped, it had been cleaned harshly with an abrasive. However, I did not find this out until I sent in my SECOND bid form. In that sale, shortly after the first, I "won" numerous items, all at inflated prices. One particular lot was a pair of Washington quarters they graded as "Gem Unc," which I paid $49 for. When I got the coins, they TOO had been cleaned, only this time it was very apparent to the naked eye!!! Any collector anywhere could have seen that these were harshly cleaned coins, and you didn't need a loupe to see the scratches and unnatural hue.

In this lot I purchased ("won") several certified coins. Most of their coins back then were certified by lower rated-companies, and very, very few were PCGS or NGC. They will even list the numerical grades on slabs of certification companies KNOWN to overgrade coins, and they then list the "WHOLESALE/TRENDS" price next to this, which is not wholesale at all, but regular retail prices. Even though they use the word "WHOLESALE" in their price/value column, they NEVER list a true wholesale price! This is nothing short of FALSE ADVERTISING.

At the time, Richard, Allen, and Mark were featured on the cover. Apparently Allen is now gone from the company. Do not fall for the trap if they try to blame Allen for the problems. They are ALL in on this, and if you are new to the hobby, be assured you will get CLEANED or DAMAGED coins in your lots, that will be hard to return because of their lack of integrity and honesty. Allen was not my assigned dealer, and the entire company is suspect of selling cleaned or damaged coins for high, retail prices, thereby ripping off collectors for whatever they can take them for. In one of my situations above, I paid $49 for what was about $4.50 in scrap silver value at the time, and at today's inflated silver price of $19/oz is still only worth around $7.50. I paid over $120 for the half-dime, which too is basically worthless to true collectors and is valued at little more than scrap silver due to the coin's damage.

My complaints went ignored, and I didn't know how to deal with a mail order rip-off back then. All they had to do was claim the coin I returned was not the original sent, so I still have this junk. Each time I see them, I am reminded of how badly I got ripped off by ACSB! Worse, even though I've not purchased from them in YEARS, I still get the catalogs. I have tried TWICE, the last time as recently as March 2014, to have my name REMOVED from their mailing list. Guess what? They refuse to do so claiming that they "rent lists" and have no control of whose names are on these lists. My old apartment number is still on these recent catalogs, and there is no current list that has this old address. There is only ONE company mailing to this old address, and that is THIS one, who apparently loves and practices falsehood, and then wants to keep reminding you of what a sucker they think of you by keeping you on their mailing list and REFUSING TO REMOVE YOUR NAME FROM IT.

Beware! Beware! Beware! They specialize in unloading cleaned and damaged coins at premium prices that you will never recover in a thousand years. They falsely advertise these coins as "gem state", "a full MS-65 grade", "choice uncirculated", and the like. If it's a raw coin, you are taking a huge chance at being ripped off and getting cleaned or damaged junk coins.

Another recent scam they've been running (but which I did not see on this most recent catalog - 3/31/2014) is a supposed web site which praises their honesty and integrity. It LOOKS like a valid site that does reviews of businesses, however, theirs is the only "review" on the site and it appears to be a product of their own promotion and deceptive work. Again, this was not on the recent catalog (which is the only one I'm looking at while typing this) and it appears that they've removed this deceptive "review" and/or maybe were ordered to do so by authorities. My opinion is that it is the latter case, though once you got to the site to read the so-called "review," it was clear it was not a legitimate business review site.

Avoid this company and its dishonest operators like the plague.

Alan K

This report was posted on Ripoff Report on 03/31/2014 10:49 AM and is a permanent record located here: The posting time indicated is Arizona local time. Arizona does not observe daylight savings so the post time may be Mountain or Pacific depending on the time of year. Ripoff Report has an exclusive license to this report. It may not be copied without the written permission of Ripoff Report. READ: Foreign websites steal our content

Search for additional reports

If you would like to see more Rip-off Reports on this company/individual, search here:

Report & Rebuttal
Respond to this report!
Also a victim?
Repair Your Reputation!

Updates & Rebuttals


#1 Author of original report

I stand by my original report.

AUTHOR: - ()

I am very grateful to RIPOFFREPORT for being out here. I got an email alerting me that my report had gotten a "rebuttal." That notification give the consumer a chance to keep on top of the issue and make a difference so that others don't get ripped off, or at least not taken as badly.

I stand by my original report, and everyone "in the back room" (meaning the coin operation as far as what is being prepared for sale) knows darn well that they are selling junk and taking a lot of money from newbies and "suckers." I still have my original purchases in the original flips and holders, and the only coins that I can be sure were not tampered with, dipped, cleaned, or polished are the certified ones, which often are listed way, way above general market prices. Just check their offerings and go to eBay or Teletrade and do a comparison. You will be going elsewhere for the certified coins. As for the "raw" ones, I will just restate "BUYER BEWARE." Many of the coins are tampered with or would never certify in the grade that they claim it is. Many, like my purchase of hundreds of dollards worth, would NEVER even certify! That means PCGS or NGC or another reputable independent grader would not accept it unless it's simply stated as "genuine," or unless it listed the type of damage to the coin, such as you will see ANACS do with their net grading (not sure if they still offer this service).

Anyway, I'm still alive and well, and would gladly go to any court of law and stand before any judge to show this company as nothing more than a bunch of crooks. They know EXACTLY what they are offering, so when they list a coin as "MS-65" and it is actually a CLEANED coin, THEY KNOW IT! The cleaning was obvious even without a loup in many cases. I just needed to tilt the coin to see the scratch marks from whatever was used to do the cleaning. (And no, they are/were not die polishing lines.)

The only good news I can report since filing THIS RipOffReport is that I no longer get their monthly mailings. It took me half a dozen calls to their staff to get removed from their mailing list. There are THOUSANDS of honest dealers out there, and your money is better spent with THEM!

Thank you for reading my expose. This company is deceptive in their business practices and that makes what they do fraudulent and downright theft. Simply stated.

Respond to this report!

#2 Consumer Comment


AUTHOR: Xbuyer - (USA)

I'm no longer an active buyer of coins or stamps, but in the early 2000's did work with these people.  Over all I was pleased with what I purchased from them, either by bid or at the stated non-bid price.  Just once I had to return an item, and it was handled quite professionally.   I experienced nothing but cooperative and efficeint service from these people. 

That stated, it was the early 2000's and since then they may have had some operational changes in people and methods, but since my experience is dated, I'm only speaking of experience that is dated.

It helped that I could directly contact and speak to a principal of the company.  We had a good discussion about my disappointment, the reasons for my displeasure, and the request for return of the item and the purchase price.  In about five business days the matter was settled to my satisfaction, and can only suppose it was fine with the company.



Respond to this report!
Ripoff Report Recommends
ZipBooks Accounting Software

Advertisers above have met our
strict standards for business conduct.