Ripoff Report Needs Your Help!
X  |  CLOSE
Report: #424322

Complaint Review: DUVAL INN KEY WEST - KEY WEST Florida

  • Submitted:
  • Updated:
  • Reported By: COLUMBUS Ohio
  • Author Confirmed What's this?
  • Why?
  • DUVAL INN KEY WEST 511 ANGELA ST KEY WEST, Florida U.S.A.
  • Phone: 305-295-9531
  • Web:
  • Category: Hotel

DUVAL INN KEY WEST SUPPORTS LOCAL CRIMINAL- SUBJECTS CUSTOMERS TO LOCAL CRIMINAL KEY WEST Florida

*Consumer Suggestion: The Liar continues his rants.

*Consumer Comment: Pot meet kettle.

*Consumer Comment: SAME TRASH PASTING AND COPYING....

*Consumer Comment: Still haven't been able to find anyone to extort money from eh? Hahaha

*Consumer Comment: Im sure everyone can see the truth

*Consumer Comment: I'm pretty sue court documents are much more thruthful

*Consumer Comment: Have your supporters READ the court filings as I have?

*Consumer Comment: AS IVE SAID THEY TRY TO DISCREDIT MY STORY BUT ITS EASILY PROVEN..

*Consumer Comment: The truth was already told in court against you.

*Consumer Comment: THE SUPPORT IS THERE FROM MANY....

*Consumer Comment: So why haven't you brought these alleged peole to court with you as witnesses?

*Consumer Comment: YEAH NOBODYS SUPPORTING ME.... HAHAHAHAHAHA

*Consumer Comment: But no one IS supporting you - the only criminal here.

*Consumer Suggestion: What part?

*Consumer Comment: CUSTOMERS OF HYDRO THUNDER HAVE BEEN SCAMMED....

*Consumer Comment: PEOPLE WANT TO KNOW WHO SUPPORTS A CRIMINAL...

*Consumer Comment: Still haven't been able to find anyone to extort money from eh? Hahaha

*Consumer Comment: NOT ALL BUSINESSES ARE BAD....

*Consumer Comment: Oh My...

*Consumer Comment: Ha ha ha. Still haven't been able to find anyone to extort money from eh? Hahaha

*Consumer Comment: PEOPLE WANT TO KNOW THE PLACE THEY ARE STAYING IS SUPPORTING LOCAL CRIMINALS

*Consumer Suggestion: Why?

*Consumer Comment: Ha ha ha. Still haven't been able to find anyone to extort money from eh? Hahaha

*Consumer Comment: Ha ha ha. Still haven't been able to find anyone to extort money from eh? Hahaha

*Consumer Comment: Ha ha ha. Still haven't been able to find anyone to extort money from eh? Hahaha

Show customers why they should trust your business over your competitors...

Is this
Report about YOU
listed on other sites?
Those sites steal
Ripoff Report's
content.
We can get those
removed for you!
Find out more here.
How to fix
Ripoff Report
If your business is
willing to make a
commitment to
customer satisfaction
Click here now..

THE DUVAL INN LOCALTED IN KEY WEST IS SUBJECTING CUSTOMERS TO A LOCAL CRIMINAL. ANYONE LOOKING TO DO BUSINESS WITH THEM MAY WANT TO RETHINK THEIR DECISION. JOHN EVANS OWNER OF HYDRO THUNDER KEY WEST A LOCAL WATERSPORTS BUSINESS IS THE MAN THEY ARE SENDING BUSINESS TO.

GOOGLE- HYDRO THUNDER KEY WEST

DO YOU WANT A LOCAL INN SUBJECTING YOU TO A LOCAL CRIMINAL?

THIS MAN IS A SCAMARTIST-LIAR-THIEF- AND LOCAL DRUNK. HE ALSO LIKES TO CHARGE CUSTOMERS CREDIT CARDS FOR BOGUS DAMMAGES AFTER THEY LEAVE.

FRONT DEST STAFF AT THE DUVAL INN -MARCI- IS VERY GOOD FRIENDS WITH EVANS AND IS STUPID ENOUGH TO SEND YOU TO HIM BECAUSE OF HER NICE CASH KICK BACK....

Criminal buster
COLUMBUS, Ohio
U.S.A.

This report was posted on Ripoff Report on 02/15/2009 08:56 AM and is a permanent record located here: https://www.ripoffreport.com/reports/duval-inn-key-west/key-west-florida-33040/duval-inn-key-west-supports-local-criminal-subjects-customers-to-local-criminal-key-west-424322. The posting time indicated is Arizona local time. Arizona does not observe daylight savings so the post time may be Mountain or Pacific depending on the time of year. Ripoff Report has an exclusive license to this report. It may not be copied without the written permission of Ripoff Report. READ: Foreign websites steal our content

Search for additional reports

If you would like to see more Rip-off Reports on this company/individual, search here:

Report & Rebuttal
Respond to this report!
What's this?
Also a victim?
What's this?
Repair Your Reputation!
What's this?

Updates & Rebuttals

REBUTTALS & REPLIES:
0Author
25Consumer
0Employee/Owner

#25 Consumer Suggestion

The Liar continues his rants.

AUTHOR: Robert - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Tuesday, May 26, 2009

Tell us Bob, when you were attempting to sell your boat did you bother to inform anyone, especially Captain McCarthy, that you were over $65 thousand in arrears for dockage and other fees to the resort where it was docked? Oh, we know how you claime to have told him he was on a 'stolen boat' but did you EXPLAIN to him the TRUE SITUATION-your business (and S/V Reefcat) OWED the resort back dockage and service fees? Did you make it clear to Captain McCarthy that you were going to fight the assessment of the over $65 THOUSAND that the resort claimed you owed?

No? Why not?

After all, the Judge did RULE AGAINST YOU that your mighty business WAS IN DEBT TO THE RESORT FOR OVER 65 THOUSAND DOLLARS!

Perhaps if you had told McCarthy that you owed such fees he wouldn't have wasted his time by trying to purchase your boat and getting all entwined in your FAILURE.

I believe McCarthy might have a cause of action against you, but that is up to him to decide whether to pursue that avenue or not. After all, even if he were to win a judgment against you and your 'businesses' we wouldn't collect anything would he, Bob? Just like all the RESORT didn't get the $65K your business owed.

Take your time and tell us all about it Bob. Let me know if I need to publish some of the text from the actual district court documents to refresh your memory.

YOU posted a LIE on ROR claiming I worked for United Yachts-I don't. I'm self-employed you twit. Unlike YOU, I'm GAINFULLY self-employed.

There are NO FORECLOSURES, failed business ventures, or LOST DISTRICT COURT cases on my resume. You can't say the same.

You are a proven liar and I will remind folks of this every time I see you posting your crap.

Let me know if you'd like me to post excerpts from the ACTUAL District Court filings to refresh your memory.

Would you like a posting of the written statement from the judge calling your evidentiary documents "highly suspicious" when he denied your silly motion to dismiss the case?

How about the filing from your attorney when he asked to be REMOVED as your counsel because you were not cooperating in your own defense?

Let me know what reminders you need. I'll be happy to oblige.

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#24 Consumer Comment

Pot meet kettle.

AUTHOR: Patrick - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Monday, May 18, 2009

That's funny coming from you Robert. You copy and paste the same CRAP all over the internet! How many reports have you filed just on here alone about your failed snorkling business? How many people could you have truly reported against, 2? Ocena Key House and Alan Eckstein. anything or anyone else is just BS from you.

Get a life and stop whining about something that happened to you over 3 years ago!

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#23 Consumer Comment

SAME TRASH PASTING AND COPYING....

AUTHOR: Robert - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Monday, May 18, 2009

DO NOT SUPPORT ANY COMPANY THAT SUPPORTS ANY CRIMINALS. THE DUVAL INN KEY WEST THINKS CUSTOMERS BEING SENT TO A LOCAL CRIMINAL IS OK.

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#22 Consumer Comment

Still haven't been able to find anyone to extort money from eh? Hahaha

AUTHOR: John - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Thursday, March 12, 2009

I'm pretty sue court documents are much more thruthful than the lies you post on the internet posing as anyone.

Why haven't you addressed the very simple questions asked of you instead of the usual deflection technique you use all the time?
Afraid the real truth will prove you to be the fraud you are?

Why haven't you sued them Why haven't you sued them and the alleged government officials that you continue to slander if you are right?

Why have you stopped slandering the government officials that deemed everything was done correctly? Threatened with a suit there too?

And why do you keep alleging that others agree with you when there is no one that does? Why do you talk to yourself through different screen names? When are you finally going to accept the summons and appear in court?

Please provide proof of your fraudulent allegations that I have different screennames (unlike your dumbass that does and signs 'robert' to them you loser) and that I post on sites all over the internet.

Much like your boyfriend, proven fraud, charles, you can't and is just one of your many, many lies on this site. You really are not as important in the scheme of life as you seem to think. That's why your bogus claims are unfounded and no one takes your lies seriously. I have no need to follow you over the internet....I debunk your claims right here.

Why does the price of the canoe in question keep changing? That's another lie you've been throwing around for awhile.

And why are you 'busting' yourself? When are you going to retract the false statement made about Robert from Buffalo? When am I going to finally get the subpoena you promised? Why are you making up stories about death threats again?

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#21 Consumer Comment

Im sure everyone can see the truth

AUTHOR: Robert - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Thursday, March 12, 2009

If you look at my posts exposing local key west scumbags you will see follow up paste and copy posts by several scumbags above. Do not stay with a compaqny like Duval Inn that supports and sends you the customer to a vendor they know is a criminal and crook.

Call kevin mc carthy owner of amelia river cruises and ask him about vendor john evans with hydro thunder key west. this is the same vendor the duval inn is sending to you....

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#20 Consumer Comment

I'm pretty sue court documents are much more thruthful

AUTHOR: John - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Tuesday, February 17, 2009

than the lies you post on the internet posing as anyone.

Why haven't you addressed the very simple questions asked of you instead of the usual deflection technique you use all the time?
Afraid the real truth will prove you to be the fraud you are?

Why haven't you sued them

Why haven't you sued them and the alleged government officials that you continue to slander if you are right?

Why have you stopped slandering the government officials that deemed everything was done correctly? Threatened with a suit there too?

And why do you keep alleging that others agree with you when there is no one that does? Why do you talk to yourself through different screen names? When are you finally going to accept the summons and appear in court?

Please provide proof of your fraudulent allegations that I have different screennames (unlike your dumbass that does and signs 'robert' to them you loser) and that I post on sites all over the internet.

Much like your boyfriend, proven fraud, charles, you can't and is just one of your many, many lies on this site. You really are not as important in the scheme of life as you seem to think. That's why your bogus claims are unfounded and no one takes your lies seriously. I have no need to follow you over the internet....I debunk your claims right here.

Why does the price of the canoe in question keep changing? That's another lie you've been throwing around for awhile.

And why are you 'busting' yourself?
When are you going to retract the false statement made about Robert from Buffalo?
When am I going to finally get the subpoena you promised?
Why are you making up stories about death threats again?

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#19 Consumer Comment

Have your supporters READ the court filings as I have?

AUTHOR: Robert - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Tuesday, February 17, 2009

Well, I finally downloaded the actual documents of the Federal District Court case that Robert the liar Krutko did not lose. LMAO.

August 3, 2006: Krutko signed for receipt of certified, return receipt requested letter to Laura Krutko (president, Reef Snorkeling Adventures Inc.) Letter demanded payment of dockage and other fees that are owed to Ocean Keys Resort (owned by Seaboard.) No payment by RSA for dockage fees for the period of December, 2005 through November 2006. Letter also informs RSA that if the billing isn't paid that the boat will be sold 60 days after receipt of the demand letter. Dockage agreement was signed by RSA representative and stipulates that month-to-month dockage is $4500.

NOTE: Krutko told the GCMA that he was a month-to-month at $3000 which was printed in their March 2007 Newsletter. IMO, this was a blatant LIE by Krutko. This makes 2 lies I can substantiate by this LIAR. The dockage agreement clearly states that if the yearly lease is not renewed (at $3000 per month for a one year lease) that the dockage goes to a month-to-month lease with monthly fees of $4500.) The first lie was his posting on ROR claiming that I was an employee of United Yachts.

What this fool should know is that when you buy a corporation, you acquire assets (such as the vessel) AND THE LIABILITIES (lease for dock space.) When this jerk purchased RSA he also purchased a valid lease for the dockage. Further, after the lease expired, he paid the $3000 (deposit per the lease contract) in November 2005. The boat was also SERVICED in November 2005.

Details of Federal District Court Case 0:07-cv-60001-JEM:

January 3, 2007: Complaint entered into docket: CASE NO: 07-60001 CIV MARTINEZ. Suit seeks enforcement of lien authorized by Florida statutes. Suit seeks $60,683.86 due to Seaboard (owner of Ocean Key Resort) for dockage and other fees owed.

July 9, 2007: The attorney representing RSA (KRUTKO) filed with the court a motion to withdraw as counsel. One of the reasons given was: There has been no cooperation or Response from the client in regards to the substance of his case for a while.

July 17, 2007: Judge Jose E. Martinez grants motions for defense counsel to withdrawal as attorney of record and orders defendant to obtain counsel or face default judgment.

July 17, 2007: Judge Jose E. Martinez grants motion to force sale of the vessel. It should be noted that RSA (Krutko) did not provide any defense to the motion to force a sale.

October 31, 2007: Judge Jose E. Martinez grants judgment for Seaboard ($65,230.87 plus pre-judgment and post-judgment.) This sure looks like a LOST THE CASE to me. Go ahead Robert! Please explain how this is a WIN for you! LOL!

November 5, 2007: Judge JOSE E. MARTINEZ orders award of custodial fees and credit bid ($16,320.50).

November 6, 2007: S/V REEF CAT sold at marshal's sale to Seaboard for $25,000.

November 21, 2007: Judge Jose E. Martinez orders amended final judgment in the principal amount of $65,230.87, plus $10,071.10 in prejudgment interest for a total award of $75, 301.97.

Please note that RSA Inc. is part of the mighty Special K Investments, Inc. (KRUTKO) empire.

July 30, 2008: U.S. Magistrate Judge Barry L. Garber orders additional relief to Seaboard; $2,855.08.

Special note: Articles of Dissolution of Reef Snorkeling Adventures, Inc., owned by Special K Investments, Inc., Laura Krutko, President (and wife of the proven liar Robert Krutko) were filed on 10/18/07.

Now Robert, please explain to us HOW this case was WON by you! Take your time.
Let me know when you're going to inform the Secretary of the Gulf Coast Mariners Association of your court VICTORY so they can publish a follow-up to their March 2007 article.

In a previous rebuttal I made a mistake in the email address for Captain McCarthy. The correct email is INFO@ameliarivercruises.com. Folks can email directly or they can send a message from the "CONTACT" link on the home page of his website.

It's bad enough McCarthy lost about $20K on this fiasco without you dragging his name all over the internet coupled to YOUR LIES and you telling folks to call him. You should be careful what you wish for - someone's is liable to do just that.

I have quite a few PDF files of the court filings that might be helpful to Captain McCarthy should he decide to attempt to recover his money.

Please refer to Report Report #0238480 which can be found here:
http://www.ripoffreport.com/reports/0/238/RipOff0238480.htm

""During this lawsuit i will be able to prove john evans of hydro thunder performance watersports not only lied to several individuals including state police officer but was involned in trying to cover it up. when court transcripts are available i will then prove my facts.""

The case was concluded MONTHS ago; YOU LOST. The court documents have been available for months so why haven't you used these documents to prove your allegations as you stated you would above?

Why don't you explain why the attorney for RSA Inc. (Reef Snorkeling Adventures Inc., Laura Krutko, President) withdrew from the case?

Why don't you explain why the judge WARNED you about your "highly suspicious" evidentiary documents when you moved for dismissal and release of the vessel? You know, your ridiculous claim that a "newly discovered" document that proved RSA Inc was dissolved on Aug 30 2005, but wasn't FILED until Oct 2007 on the same day you filed your motion to dismiss? The reality is the document states a dissolution approval date and the form is signed (but not dated) by Laura Krutko, but the EFFECTIVE DATE was left blank. Go ahead. Take all the time you need to explain this one.

When are you going to make these court documents available to Mr. McCarthy so he can read for himself what really transpired during the lawsuit against you? Don't' forget to include the evidentiary documents filed by the plaintiff that include the investigative reports and statements from the folks who were on the scene when the vessel was adrift.

When are you going to provide Mr. McCarthy a copy of the judge's order that denied your motion to dismiss so that he can read for himself what you attempted to do and the judge's STATEMENTS as to WHY your evidentiary documents were "HIGHLY SUSPICIOUS" and he denied your motion?

Perhaps if Mr. McCarthy would READ these documents, he might develop a more accurate opinion of the type of people he's dealing with (you and your wife) and re-assess his relationship with you.

When are you going to update the Secretary of the Gulf Coast Mariners Association with the FACTS of your case (as filed with the court), including the WARNING to you that the Judge stated, so he can write a follow-up article to the one he printed in their newsletter in March 2007?

When are you going to retract the lie you posted about me on RipOff Report?

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#18 Consumer Comment

AS IVE SAID THEY TRY TO DISCREDIT MY STORY BUT ITS EASILY PROVEN..

AUTHOR: Robert - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Tuesday, February 17, 2009

ANYONE READING THIS CAN GOOGLE- AMELIA RIVER CRUISES


THE SUPPORT IS THERE FROM MANY....
THE ABOVE LETTERS TELL THE TRUTH. INCOMPETENCY FROM THE MONROE COUNTY SHERIFFS AND STATE ATTORNEY ARE COMMON IN MONROE COUNTY.

ANYONE READING THIS CAN SEE THE SAME COWARDS UNDER FALSE NAMES AND LOCATIONS POSTING HERE. ALL YOU HAVE TO DO IS GOOGLE- AMELIA RIVER CRUISES

CALL THE OWNER KEVIN MC CARTHY AND ASK HIM...

YOU CAN SEE NONE OF THESE PEOPLE HAVE EVEN DONE THIS BECAUSE THEIR ONLY MISSION IS TRYING TO COVER UP THE TRUTH...

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#17 Consumer Comment

The truth was already told in court against you.

AUTHOR: John - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Tuesday, February 17, 2009

Why haven't you sued them

Why haven't you sued them and the alleged government officials that you continue to slander if you are right?

Why have you stopped slandering the government officials that deemed everything was done correctly? Threatened with a suit there too?

And why do you keep alleging that others agree with you when there is no one that does? Why do you talk to yourself through different screen names? When are you finally going to accept the summons and appear in court?

Please provide proof of your fraudulent allegations that I have different screennames (unlike your dumbass that does and signs 'robert' to them you loser) and that I post on sites all over the internet.

Much like your boyfriend, proven fraud, charles, you can't and is just one of your many, many lies on this site. You really are not as important in the scheme of life as you seem to think. That's why your bogus claims are unfounded and no one takes your lies seriously. I have no need to follow you over the internet....I debunk your claims right here.

Why does the price of the canoe in question keep changing? That's another lie you've been throwing around for awhile.

And why are you 'busting' yourself?
When are you going to retract the false statement made about Robert from Buffalo?
When am I going to finally get the subpoena you promised?
Why are you making up stories about death threats again?

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#16 Consumer Comment

THE SUPPORT IS THERE FROM MANY....

AUTHOR: Robert - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Tuesday, February 17, 2009

THE ABOVE LETTERS TELL THE TRUTH. INCOMPETENCY FROM THE MONROE COUNTY SHERIFFS AND STATE ATTORNEY ARE COMMON IN MONROE COUNTY.

ANYONE READING THIS CAN SEE THE SAME COWARDS UNDER FALSE NAMES AND LOCATIONS POSTING HERE. ALL YOU HAVE TO DO IS GOOGLE- AMELIA RIVER CRUISES

CALL THE OWNER KEVIN MC CARTHY AND ASK HIM...

YOU CAN SEE NONE OF THESE PEOPLE HAVE EVEN DONE THIS BECAUSE THEIR ONLY MISSION IS TRYING TO COVER UP THE TRUTH...

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#15 Consumer Comment

So why haven't you brought these alleged peole to court with you as witnesses?

AUTHOR: John - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Tuesday, February 17, 2009

Why haven't you sued them

Why haven't you sued them and the alleged government officials that you continue to slander if you are right?

Why have you stopped slandering the government officials that deemed everything was done correctly? Threatened with a suit there too?

And why do you keep alleging that others agree with you when there is no one that does? Why do you talk to yourself through different screen names? When are you finally going to accept the summons and appear in court?

Please provide proof of your fraudulent allegations that I have different screennames (unlike your dumbass that does and signs 'robert' to them you loser) and that I post on sites all over the internet.

Much like your boyfriend, proven fraud, charles, you can't and is just one of your many, many lies on this site. You really are not as important in the scheme of life as you seem to think. That's why your bogus claims are unfounded and no one takes your lies seriously. I have no need to follow you over the internet....I debunk your claims right here.

Why does the price of the canoe in question keep changing? That's another lie you've been throwing around for awhile.

And why are you 'busting' yourself?
When are you going to retract the false statement made about Robert from Buffalo?
When am I going to finally get the subpoena you promised?
Why are you making up stories about death threats again?

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#14 Consumer Comment

YEAH NOBODYS SUPPORTING ME.... HAHAHAHAHAHA

AUTHOR: Robert - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Tuesday, February 17, 2009

BESIDES THE NUMEROUS CONCIERGE SERVICES WHO WANT NOTHING NOW TO DO WITH EVANS THIS POSTER SAYS NOBODYS SUPPORTING ME.


Dear Dennis,
It has been brought to my attention that about a year ago a boat was stolen in Key West which I believe is grand theft and should be brought to trial or at the very least an investigation should be done. In this particular case it seems that neither was done. That it was called a civil case. I'm sure I don't have to tell you that stealing a boat is not a civil matter. It has caused great hardsh ip on the family that owned the boat. It was not just a boat for recreation but a boat that was used commercially to provide an income. The family that is the victim is from Ohio. This is the last thing that we need in the Keys is for justice not to be done. We rely on tourism down here and what we don't want is for these beautiful islands to get a bad reputation that when something happens everyone just looks the other way. I truly am urging you to conduct an investigation into the matter. If you have any questions please feel free to contact me.

Thank you,
Kim Bagnell Thaler
Coldwell Banker Schmitt Real Estate
Broker Associate
Cel . (305)393-2787
Direct . (305)289-6622
Office . (305)664-4470
Fax . (305)664-4111
Kim@KimBagnell.com

Mr. Krutko's boat (who I have never met) had been anchored in Cudjoe
Bay, broke anchor and was drifting towards my boat and dock. The phone
number printed on the side of the boat was not a working phone number. I
contacted the Coast Guard and the Marine Patrol/FWC. One o f the 2
agencies (I cant remember which) recognized the name of the boat and
told me it was usually docked at the Ocean Key Resort and I should
contact them. Both agencies stated if I towed the boat to deeper water
to secure it I would then be held responsible if it broke anchor again.
I called the Ocean Key House and was transferred to John Evans who was
very excited I had found His boat. He told me a disgruntled employee had
disappeared along with the boat. I left work early and when I arrived
home I believe there was a FWC boat, a Law Enforcement boat and a Sea
Tow Inflatable near my dock. The two larger vessels "escorted"/
"sandwiched" the vessel in question to deeper water minutes before the
vessel would have come in contact with mine. As they were reaching
deeper water I saw another boat with a driver and passenger approaching
the scene. One of the men boarded the vessel and eventually started the
engines. He yelled to me He was John Evans and He told me to come down
to the Ocean Key House for a free dinner on the resort as a reward for
finding the boat. I told Him there was no need for the reward I was just
happy He recovered His boat and there was no damage to my property. On
1/12/07 J ohn Evans contacted me again asking more information about the
incident saying the FWC stated they were never on the scene. I said that
was crazy and I had photo's proving it. I burned a disc and gave it to
John who then insisted my wife and I go and have a free dinner. We did
go have a great meal on 1/31/07. All my photo's have now been provided
to John Evans, Robert krutko and Charles Tunnicliff (850 4879656) of the
Dept. of Business and Professional Regulations.

V/R
Melvin J Herlehy
Engineering Technician
FEAD PWDKW
PO Box 9018 KW FL 33040
305 293 2566 office
305 797 1648 cell 305 293 2631 fax
melvin.herlehy@navy.mil
*************************************************************************************



-----Original Message-----
From: Lynn Goodwin
To: dennisward@aol.com
Cc: mizztribbles@aol.com
Sent: Sat, 3 Jan 2009 5:01 pm
Subject: Investigation of a theft


Dear Mr. Ward,
I have become aware of the theft of a 45 foot boat belonging to Robert Krutco, formerly of Cudjoe Key becaue of a notice he placed on Craigs List. I believe that by now you have become acquainted with the case that is now over 18 months old. For whatever reasons the case sounds to have been mishandled, I am asking you to open a formal invstigation in this matter. No one deserves to have their property stolen from them.
As a resident of this county for over 23 years, I love living here and do not intend to leave. The negative impact of these allegations is really a bad thing, and I hope there is a way to at least get this man's property restored to him.
The headline on Craigs List cast all members of my Realtor profession in the Keys in a very bad light, but worst of all, Mr. Krutco says that he has convinced several people not to move here b ecause of the "lawless" conditions. Please rectify this injustice, because you may be helping to save a major portion of our economy as well as putting the ofenders in jail, or better yet get them to pay restitution for their crimes.
Lynn O. Goodwin
E-mail: lynnogoodwin@yahoo.com
Website: lynngoodwin.com
Office: (305)289-0621
Tollfree: (800)766-5011
Cell: (305)923-9487


**************************************************************************************

other victim ...........

From: Kevin
To: dennisward@aol.com
Sent: Monday, December 22, 2008 1:44 PM
Subject: Key West nightmare


Dear Dennis
My name is Kevin McCarthy I own and operate Amelia River Cruises & Charters in Fernandina Beach, Florida. In the fall of 2006 my wife and I drove to Key West to look at20a few commercial tour boats that were for sale. We looked at a 45' 49 passenger U.S. Coast Guard Inspected vessel that was chained to the dock at the Ocean Key House Resort. The asking price was $110,000 the broker informed me that there were outstanding dock fees and that is why the vessel had been chained to the dock. I expressed an interest and told the broker that I would make an offer in a week or so. Two days latter the broker called to inform me that the vessel was to be auction off the very next morning at the Ocean Key House Resort and that the hotel had taken possession of the vessel for the delinquent dock fees and the starting bid would be $61,000. The next morning I called the Resort and spoke with the manager Mr. Steve Boswell I asked him if in fact the vessel was to be auctioned off that morning his response was yes and then he handed the phone to his attorney Allen Eckstein. I asked Mr. Eckstein if the Resort now owned the vessel and if there were any other outstanding leans on the vessel. Mr. Eckstein told me that the Resort did now own the vessel and that there were no other outstanding leans. I them called the broker to ask if he coul d attend the auction on my behalf, I authorized him to bid up to $71,000 plus a 10% broker fee for him. At 10:15 that morning I received a call form the broker that the boat was mine for $71,000. I received a bill of sale from attorney Eckstein and took possession of the vessel. After a month i n dry dock and with about $20,000 in repairs my wife and I were sailing our new tour boat from Marathon Key north to Amelia Island Florida. We stopped in Miami that first night and I received a phone call From Mr. Robert Krutko, Robert explained to me that I did not own the vessel and that it had been st olen from him. I then called Attorney Eckstein he assured me that the vessel was in fact mine and the everything had been done lawfully, My next call was to a Maritime Attorney in Miami I explained my situation to him,
his first question to me was did the Resort arrest the vessel and was there a U.S. Marshal at the auction my answer was no. The Attorney then told me that I in fact could not own the vessel and that the transaction in his opinion was not done poperly. By this time we were on our way to Ft. Lauderdale and I had made arraignments to stop at First Performance Marina for some engine repair. Just as we were pulling in to the marina we were boarded by the U.S.Coast Guard and then the Broward County Sheriffs Department they looked at my bill of sale they both told me th at the bill of sale was not worth the paper it was written on. I then made arraignments with the marina to leave the boat there and we returned to north Florida that was the last time I saw the boat and I was out $91,000. I then hired an attorney in Jacksonville and after about a month of haggling the r esort did return my purchase price of=2 0$71,000 and the broker did return his 10% fee.
I am out at lest $20,000 and the hole ordeal has been a nightmare. I am convinced that the Ocean Key House Resort ,Mr.Steve Boswell, Attorney Allen Eckstein and Mr. John Evens the young man that hot-wired and then removed the vessel from Cudjoe Bay and returned it back to the resort all participated in the Grand theft of this vessel. I am also convinced that had the Monroe County Sheriff's Department the F.W.C and the States Attorney's office in Key West had done there jobs I would not have had to endure this nightmare. Mr. Krutko and I do not have the financial were with all to go after this type of injustice and I am very disappointed in the way this has been handled by those governmental organization that are sworn to up hold the laws in this state.
Sincerely
Kevin McCarthy


**************************************************************** *********************




Dear Mr. Ward,
I realize that you have not taken office yet, but I have become painfully aware that an injustice may h ave taken place approximately 18 month ago.
Mr. Robert Krutko of Columbus, OH, formerly of Cudjoe Key has contacted me via the internet to help him get a formal investigation of the circumstances leading to the theft of his 45' boat, the subsequent sale of same, and the reversal of that sale.
I am a long time resident of the Keys and love them dearly. Certainly this man's claims of inside dealing, and poor law enforcement can be quelled by a proper investigation, which he claims never took place. Please make this case one of your first orders of business for the new year.

Sincerely,

Paula Nardone

Exit Realty





JUST A FEW OF MANY ...


YEAH LOOKS LIKE NO SUPPORT..... AND ALL THE CONCIERGE SERVICES SAYING BYE BYE TO EVANS... AGAIN NO SUPPORT


HAHAHAHAHAHAHA

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#13 Consumer Comment

But no one IS supporting you - the only criminal here.

AUTHOR: John - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Monday, February 16, 2009

Why haven't you sued them

Why haven't you sued them and the alleged government officials that you continue to slander if you are right?

Why have you stopped slandering the government officials that deemed everything was done correctly? Threatened with a suit there too?

And why do you keep alleging that others agree with you when there is no one that does? Why do you talk to yourself through different screen names? When are you finally going to accept the summons and appear in court?

Please provide proof of your fraudulent allegations that I have different screennames (unlike your dumbass that does and signs 'robert' to them you loser) and that I post on sites all over the internet.

Much like your boyfriend, proven fraud, charles, you can't and is just one of your many, many lies on this site. You really are not as important in the scheme of life as you seem to think. That's why your bogus claims are unfounded and no one takes your lies seriously. I have no need to follow you over the internet....I debunk your claims right here.

Why does the price of the canoe in question keep changing? That's another lie you've been throwing around for awhile.

And why are you 'busting' yourself?
When are you going to retract the false statement made about Robert from Buffalo?
When am I going to finally get the subpoena you promised?
Why are you making up stories about death threats again?

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#12 Consumer Comment

CUSTOMERS OF HYDRO THUNDER HAVE BEEN SCAMMED....

AUTHOR: Robert - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Monday, February 16, 2009

0.5
out of 5

Horrible 1 reviews with a budget, traveling for leisure

HERE IS A POST IN TRIP ADVISOR. JOHN EVANS IS KNOWN FOR CHARGING PEOPLE FOR BOGUS FEES. THIS MAN IS TRASH AND IS A THIEF...

Jet Skiing, Key West beware!!?

Old Town Tours

KANEY1979

3/3 found this review helpful

I have just arrived home from a great trip to Key West, FL, but feel obliged to tell you all, at all costs avoid the jet skiing which can be found at 0 Duval Street, (Old Town Tours).

The jet skiing was fun and fast, however be warned that you may be conned in to paying for damages that you have not caused. My party of four were accused of having a collision that DEFINITELY DID NOT OCCUR. We obviously refuted the claim, however the staff were rude and ignorant, basically accusing us of lying, although they have no proof of a collision and who may have been involved. They charged $200 to a credit card of one of my party, and not even the credit card of the person riding the specific ski they found fault with. This was after telling us, one of us should 'FESS UP'. We only found out who rode that ski when later looking at photos and camera footage. There was also no communication in relation to how much would be charged. We had to challenge them for that information.

The fault, apparently, was a very small patch of flakey paint above the thick rubber bumper at a rear corner. NO SCUFF MARKS, NO DENTS AND NO CRACKS, and NO damage to any other ski. The damage could not have been caused by a collision, it was nothing more than wear and tear. This was exacerbated by the staff who began picking at it and who also rode the skis very fast themselves around the small docking area in order to dock them once we had handed them over.

There are plenty of other jet skiing locations, I suggest you try one of them.

This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#11 Consumer Suggestion

What part?

AUTHOR: Kim - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Monday, February 16, 2009

The part I do not understand is how someone like yourself that has so many different screen names, (do you have to keep a book close by to remember them all), can say that everyone that responds to your crap is a friend of the person you are flaming. All that does is reinforce the inane behavior you display on this and every other board you pollute with your so called facts.
Which you have never proved or attempt to prove.
Just for the record, I know you will not believe me anyway, but for the record.
I have not been farther east than Oklahoma and have no desire to go to Florida, Santee is by San Diego get Google it.
As it has been asked so many times.
Why do you scream so loud but never back anything up in court?
You have had your chances so many times.
Why should we believe you when you, are the only one screaming about these different companies and individuals.

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#10 Consumer Comment

PEOPLE WANT TO KNOW WHO SUPPORTS A CRIMINAL...

AUTHOR: Robert - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Monday, February 16, 2009

PEOPLE WANT TO KNOW THE PLACE THEY ARE STAYING IS SUPPORTING LOCAL CRIMINALS
YOU KNOW HOW IT IS KIM. YOUR OBVIOUSLY FRIENDS WITH MR JOHN EVANS. I WOULD BET YOUR FALSIFYING YOUR LOCATION ALSO. MOST TRAVERLERS WONT SUPPORT ANY COMPANY WHO SUPPORTS LOCAL CRIMINALS.

TELL US WHAT PART OF THE ABOVE YOU DONT UNDERSTAND..........

DO NOT SUPPORT ANYONE LIKE THE DUVAL INN WHO THINKS SUBJECTING THEIR CLIENTS TO A CRIMINAL FOR A CASH KICKBACK IS MORE IMPORTANT THAN THEIR SAFETY.....

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#9 Consumer Comment

Still haven't been able to find anyone to extort money from eh? Hahaha

AUTHOR: John - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Monday, February 16, 2009

Why haven't you sued them

Why haven't you sued them and the alleged government officials that you continue to slander if you are right?

Why have you stopped slandering the government officials that deemed everything was done correctly? Threatened with a suit there too?

And why do you keep alleging that others agree with you when there is no one that does? Why do you talk to yourself through different screen names? When are you finally going to accept the summons and appear in court?

Please provide proof of your fraudulent allegations that I have different screennames (unlike your dumbass that does and signs 'robert' to them you loser) and that I post on sites all over the internet.

Much like your boyfriend, proven fraud, charles, you can't and is just one of your many, many lies on this site. You really are not as important in the scheme of life as you seem to think. That's why your bogus claims are unfounded and no one takes your lies seriously. I have no need to follow you over the internet....I debunk your claims right here.

Why does the price of the canoe in question keep changing? That's another lie you've been throwing around for awhile.

And why are you 'busting' yourself? When are you going to retract the false statement made about Robert from Buffalo? When am I going to finally get the subpoena you promised? Why are you making up stories about death threats again?
When are you going to address the loss you experienced in court after you assured your slam dunk victory?

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#8 Consumer Comment

NOT ALL BUSINESSES ARE BAD....

AUTHOR: Robert - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Monday, February 16, 2009

IN FACT MANY ARE VERY GOOD...

JUST A SMALL AND I MEAN VERY SMALL HANDFUL OF SCUMBAG BUSINESSES THISNK ITS OK TO SEND CUSTOMERS TO A LOCAL CRIMINAL. DUVAL INN AND THEIR TRASHY STAFF ARE JUST ONE OF THEM.

YOU SEE MANY PEOPLE WONT SUPPORT A LOCAL DRUND-SCUMBAG-SCAMARTIST LIKE JOHN EVANS OWNER OF HYDRO THUNDER KEY WEST.

WE ASK ANYONE LOOKING TO STAY HERE TO SUPPORT A LOCAL COMPANY IN KEY WEST WHO DOESNT SUPPORT LOCAL CRIMINALS.

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#7 Consumer Comment

Oh My...

AUTHOR: Robert - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Sunday, February 15, 2009

Mr. Krutko not every one who posts here are friends with the entire city of Key West. In fact like me I doubt anyone who has ever commented on any of your mutiple complaints(and I am using that term very loosely) know any of these businesses or business people at all. The only thing that has been proven post after post is YOUR multiple aliases, lies, and contradictions.

And yes it does appear you just grabbed the Key West Phone book and are going to write a report on every single business in Key West. I can't wait for a report on how the local McDonalds and Taco Bell supports criminals.

If you really do think you are right why haven't you continued your ranting against United Yachts?

Oh yea you can't because they sued you because of your lies and you LOST. But to someone who thinks they are right why are you letting something as simple as a court order stand in your way? I mean after all what's a little jail time or fine to stand up for what you believe in.

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#6 Consumer Comment

Ha ha ha. Still haven't been able to find anyone to extort money from eh? Hahaha

AUTHOR: John - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Sunday, February 15, 2009

Why haven't you sued them

Why haven't you sued them and the alleged government officials that you continue to slander if you are right?

Why have you stopped slandering the government officials that deemed everything was done correctly? Threatened with a suit there too?

And why do you keep alleging that others agree with you when there is no one that does? Why do you talk to yourself through different screen names? When are you finally going to accept the summons and appear in court?

Please provide proof of your fraudulent allegations that I have different screennames (unlike your dumbass that does and signs 'robert' to them you loser) and that I post on sites all over the internet.

Much like your boyfriend, proven fraud, charles, you can't and is just one of your many, many lies on this site. You really are not as important in the scheme of life as you seem to think. That's why your bogus claims are unfounded and no one takes your lies seriously. I have no need to follow you over the internet....I debunk your claims right here.

Why does the price of the canoe in question keep changing? That's another lie you've been throwing around for awhile.

And why are you 'busting' yourself?
When are you going to retract the false statement made about Robert from Buffalo?
When am I going to finally get the subpoena you promised?
Why are you making up stories about death threats again?
When are you going to address the loss you experienced in court after you assured your slam dunk victory?

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#5 Consumer Comment

PEOPLE WANT TO KNOW THE PLACE THEY ARE STAYING IS SUPPORTING LOCAL CRIMINALS

AUTHOR: Robert - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Sunday, February 15, 2009

YOU KNOW HOW IT IS KIM. YOUR OBVIOUSLY FRIENDS WITH MR JOHN EVANS. I WOULD BET YOUR FALSIFYING YOUR LOCATION ALSO. MOST TRAVERLERS WONT SUPPORT ANY COMPANY WHO SUPPORTS LOCAL CRIMINALS.

TELL US WHAT PART OF THE ABOVE YOU DONT UNDERSTAND..........

DO NOT SUPPORT ANYONE LIKE THE DUVAL INN WHO THINKS SUBJECTING THEIR CLIENTS TO A CRIMINAL FOR A CASH KICKBACK IS MORE IMPORTANT THAN THEIR SAFETY.....

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#4 Consumer Suggestion

Why?

AUTHOR: Kim - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Sunday, February 15, 2009

What did you do bring the phone book with you when you left,
and are just going down each page and picking names?

You sir a pathetic individual that i would not like to do business with, where as I would gladly do business with all of the companies and individuals that you have posted here.

Why does the pip off staff allow you to post this crap when they should know it is all false.
That goes for Charles also.

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#3 Consumer Comment

Ha ha ha. Still haven't been able to find anyone to extort money from eh? Hahaha

AUTHOR: John - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Sunday, February 15, 2009

Why haven't you sued them

Why haven't you sued them and the alleged government officials that you continue to slander if you are right?

Why have you stopped slandering the government officials that deemed everything was done correctly? Threatened with a suit there too?

And why do you keep alleging that others agree with you when there is no one that does? Why do you talk to yourself through different screen names? When are you finally going to accept the summons and appear in court?

Please provide proof of your fraudulent allegations that I have different screennames (unlike your dumbass that does and signs 'robert' to them you loser) and that I post on sites all over the internet.

Much like your boyfriend, proven fraud, charles, you can't and is just one of your many, many lies on this site. You really are not as important in the scheme of life as you seem to think. That's why your bogus claims are unfounded and no one takes your lies seriously. I have no need to follow you over the internet....I debunk your claims right here.

Why does the price of the canoe in question keep changing? That's another lie you've been throwing around for awhile.

And why are you 'busting' yourself?
When are you going to retract the false statement made about Robert from Buffalo?
When am I going to finally get the subpoena you promised?
Why are you making up stories about death threats again?

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#2 Consumer Comment

Ha ha ha. Still haven't been able to find anyone to extort money from eh? Hahaha

AUTHOR: John - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Sunday, February 15, 2009

Why haven't you sued them

Why haven't you sued them and the alleged government officials that you continue to slander if you are right?

Why have you stopped slandering the government officials that deemed everything was done correctly? Threatened with a suit there too?

And why do you keep alleging that others agree with you when there is no one that does? Why do you talk to yourself through different screen names? When are you finally going to accept the summons and appear in court?

Please provide proof of your fraudulent allegations that I have different screennames (unlike your dumbass that does and signs 'robert' to them you loser) and that I post on sites all over the internet.

Much like your boyfriend, proven fraud, charles, you can't and is just one of your many, many lies on this site. You really are not as important in the scheme of life as you seem to think. That's why your bogus claims are unfounded and no one takes your lies seriously. I have no need to follow you over the internet....I debunk your claims right here.

Why does the price of the canoe in question keep changing? That's another lie you've been throwing around for awhile.

And why are you 'busting' yourself?
When are you going to retract the false statement made about Robert from Buffalo?
When am I going to finally get the subpoena you promised?
Why are you making up stories about death threats again?

Respond to this report!
What's this?

#1 Consumer Comment

Ha ha ha. Still haven't been able to find anyone to extort money from eh? Hahaha

AUTHOR: John - (U.S.A.)

POSTED: Sunday, February 15, 2009

Why haven't you sued them

Why haven't you sued them and the alleged government officials that you continue to slander if you are right?

Why have you stopped slandering the government officials that deemed everything was done correctly? Threatened with a suit there too?

And why do you keep alleging that others agree with you when there is no one that does? Why do you talk to yourself through different screen names? When are you finally going to accept the summons and appear in court?

Please provide proof of your fraudulent allegations that I have different screennames (unlike your dumbass that does and signs 'robert' to them you loser) and that I post on sites all over the internet.

Much like your boyfriend, proven fraud, charles, you can't and is just one of your many, many lies on this site. You really are not as important in the scheme of life as you seem to think. That's why your bogus claims are unfounded and no one takes your lies seriously. I have no need to follow you over the internet....I debunk your claims right here.

Why does the price of the canoe in question keep changing? That's another lie you've been throwing around for awhile.

And why are you 'busting' yourself?
When are you going to retract the false statement made about Robert from Buffalo?
When am I going to finally get the subpoena you promised?
Why are you making up stories about death threats again?

Respond to this report!
What's this?
Featured Reports

Advertisers above have met our
strict standards for business conduct.

X
What do hackers,
questionable attorneys and
fake court orders have in common?
...Dishonest Reputation Management Investigates Reputation Repair
Free speech rights compromised

WATCH News
Segment Now