Flagstar Bank - Mark Liley Unfairly removed from their approved appraiser's list Troy Michigan

Flagstar / Chase did the same thing to me.   

Here is the situation, 3 years after receiving my Certification, I receive a letter from them telling me I was being placed on their "Bad" list.  I was concerned, as I had never worked for either of them.  To be eligible, you must have at least 5 years certified.  After a year of occasional emails, I was finally told which appraisals were reviewed by them.  They said I had the option to refute the reviews, but the appraisals had been done years before and in very specific conditions, which they did not care to listen to.  They told me they would consider me again, if I took a site valuation class....and guess what...they still won't remove me.  5 years later now, and every year a client of mine keeps trying to get them to put me back on, and I have even taken that class again......but nope.  I have never been on a Blacklist, and they are the only thing tarnishing my record.  I laugh everytime I hear that the company loses in lawsuits of multi billion dollar settlements.....I just wish they would have some business sense and stop letting some idiot run their appraiser panel list into the ground.

Since you are apologizing to Mr Liley, did you get re-instated? If so how did you do it???

At the time of my original complaint, I was angry as I was being removed from an approved lender's list. This has never happened to me in 16 years of appraising. I made some personal comments regarding Mr Liley that should not have been said. I want to apologize to Mr Liley for making this personal. I must admit he has been nothing but professional in each conversation we have had, never once raised his voice nor made any personal comments and always treated me with respect. In hindsight, I wish I had been so professional also.

My fault is that I take most everything regarding my business personally. Mr Liley was just doing his job in protecting his company from what he thought was a poor appraisal.

I made some mistakes in my original report, never was anything done intentionally but, mistakes were made none the less. I am not "allowed" to remove this original complaint from this site or I would but I hope that all concerned see this message and take it as a genuine apology in the sincerity it is given.

Whatever the outcome, I am sorry Mr Liley...