Complaint Review: The Shire Farms, Mike And Kathryn Smith - Vale North Carolina
- The Shire Farms, Mike And Kathryn Smith 6741 Colony Lane Vale, North Carolina U.S.A.
- Phone: 704-276-9010
- Web:
- Category: Animal Services
The Shire Farms, Mike And Kathryn SmithThe Shire Farms, Mike And Kathryn Smith, Ellen Or George Smith, Dixie Horseman Transport, Blue Ridge Outfitters, 7 Eagle Performance Horses Misrepresented horses, green horses being sold as dead broke child safe horses Ripoff Vale Crouse North Carolina
*Consumer Comment: Dishonest Horse Traders
*Consumer Comment: Mike and Kathryn Smith are liars and crooks-we have the proof!!!
*Consumer Comment: A question for Mike and Kathryn Smith of Shire Farms, etc.
*REBUTTAL Individual responds: Scammers
*REBUTTAL Owner of company: come ride with us and you be the judge
*Consumer Comment: Mike and Kathryn Smith are not victims but sociopathic con-artists
*REBUTTAL Owner of company: victim of rip off.com and a blackmailing woman
listed on other sites?
Those sites steal
Ripoff Report's
content.
We can get those
removed for you!
Find out more here.
Ripoff Report
willing to make a
commitment to
customer satisfaction
Click here now..
I bought a "quarter horse" from Ellen and George Smith aka Mike and Kathryn Smith in October of 2004 to pony my daughter and her new horse. I purchased this horse to tow my 6 yr old daughter on as well.
Ellen Smith told me I could ride this horse anywhere because she was as dead broke as they get. She told me that my mother in law could ride this horse. That I could put her on the yellow line in the highway with traffic on both sides and this horses would not blink.
Mrs. Smith was meeting with the unemployment agancy and couldn't meet with me the morning I picked the horse up. She told me she had a coggins for me but when I picked the horse up Walt Smith told me the horse didn't have a coggins. I never recieved the coggins.
Three days after I bought her I rode her and she was NOTHING like what I was supposed to have bought. She is a hot horse that even the most experienced rider would have a hard time handling. I'm thankful my daughter wasn't on with me.
I knew that I had been taken and I tried to contact them immediately to let them know I could not have this horse around my children. They didn't return my phone calls until I left a message that I had reported them to the FBI, IFCC, State Attorney Generals office, Charlotte Better Business Bureau, and The NC State Veternary Division. They would not give me my money back.
Finally when I found out who I was dealing with I reported my dealings on several websites ie. dreamhorse.com and nchorsenews.com. Both websites had great responses with several others coming forward that had been scammed by these people as well.
I have met probably 20 people who have been scammed and I cannot get any angency to pursue these people. Meanwhile they have filed bankruptcy to avoid this lawsuit against them and continue to sell horses. They are making a small fortune selling horses to people out of state and to people who are just starting out riding. The latest was to a woman who had a handicapped child, the horse was sold to her as child safe. It was not child safe.
They have been sued for this very same thing before and the person suing got her money back. Another woman and myself are determined to see this through and stop these people from their corrupt dealings. Since this lawsuit we have recieved death threats and harassments through the mail and through the internet. They have used the our email addresses to sign us up to less than desirable websites.
Just shows how low they will go.
Kamala
Wanchese, North Carolina
U.S.A.
This report was posted on Ripoff Report on 04/27/2005 11:54 AM and is a permanent record located here: https://www.ripoffreport.com/reports/the-shire-farms-mike-and-kathryn-smith/vale-north-carolina/the-shire-farms-mike-and-kathryn-smiththe-shire-farms-mike-and-kathryn-smith-ellen-or-g-140615. The posting time indicated is Arizona local time. Arizona does not observe daylight savings so the post time may be Mountain or Pacific depending on the time of year. Ripoff Report has an exclusive license to this report. It may not be copied without the written permission of Ripoff Report. READ: Foreign websites steal our content
If you would like to see more Rip-off Reports on this company/individual, search here:



#7 Consumer Comment
Dishonest Horse Traders
AUTHOR: Hilaire - (U.S.A.)
SUBMITTED: Sunday, January 29, 2006
Kathryn is smart enough not to comment on any of this, that's why she runs this little operation of hers. Mike on the other hand will need a dictionary to understand Kamalas rebuttal. Yes Mike, please tell us why you've found it neccessary to list out of a dozen or more different towns around NC (your physical address is in Vale, yet you list out of Cherryville.
You used to list out of Vale also), change phone numbers constantly, use the alias of George, Walt,Ellen, etc. Even one of the horse sale sites has banned you from listing with them for opening different accounts under different names, using differnt credit cards.
I don't know of an honest business that would that. And yes, how do you afford two ten acre pieces of property, a new 1 1/2 story house, a brand new Hummer, mercedes, ATV's, two brand new aluminum horse trailers, a new camper trailer, etc, etc, etc. on what you do? As for being trainers?????? What good trainer in his right mind would start riding a yearling or horse under 2 yrs.
Most horses knees aren't even closed at that age! And by your lack of round pen training equals a lack of respect on the horses part. Maybe that's why these horses you're selling don't have any respect, manners or training..because you're not trainers. You prey on beginners who don't know any better. I'm no beginner but fell for Kathryns outright lies and she's a pro!

#6 Consumer Comment
Mike and Kathryn Smith are liars and crooks-we have the proof!!!
AUTHOR: Hilaire - (U.S.A.)
SUBMITTED: Sunday, January 29, 2006
A warrant for my arrest huh, Mike??? Would that happen to be for the false police report that you filed on me for "threatning phone calls"? I already contacted that police dept. and spoke to a deputy who said it was totally unfounded on your part. You and your wife have made up so many lies that we can't keep track of them all, how do you keep track?? Again, where is your proof? Same question about your "satisfied customers". We tracked down a few of your so called "satisfied" customers who weren't as satisfied as you might think. Is that why you stopped putting their names and towns on your site? There is also speculation that many of these horses are drugged but everytime a buyer wants a vet check Kathryn either talks them out of it or can't find a vet for almost a month or until any drug is out of the system. Both you and Kathryn's public bankrupcty documents speak for themselves and clearly show what devious, manipulating, low-lifes you are.
Raising a daughter in this kind of life style should count as child abuse as she will learn from both of you how to lie, steal, manipulate and take advantage of people to make a quick buck.
We are looking into the IRS's part in your scheme as I doubt you reported the tens of thousands you made off your auction horses. I hope a judge lets you both rot in jail for what you've done and I for one won't quit until I see that happen! We can all counter any of your lies with all the paperwork and depositions from all your "dissatisfied" customers and the number is growing. Like I said, "the proof is in the paperwork and we have a ton". Isn't it time to go buy some old plugs at the auction to resell?

#5 Consumer Comment
A question for Mike and Kathryn Smith of Shire Farms, etc.
AUTHOR: Janice - (U.S.A.)
SUBMITTED: Sunday, January 29, 2006
If you are operating an honest business that sells good horses (not auction horses), why have you found it necessary over the past 3 1/2 years to advertise your horses under many different farm names, town names and use aliases for yourselves? What are you hiding?

#4 REBUTTAL Individual responds
Scammers
AUTHOR: Kamala - (U.S.A.)
SUBMITTED: Sunday, January 29, 2006
It is quite humorous to see how the both of you so distort,pervert,and misconstrue. You run with a shred of the truth and spin it into a web of lies and deceit. Even your trustee has found you to be a prevaricator(s).
A judge will have no quandary finding incongruities in your 'in'competent story. What was it, Channel 13 news, even had in on the air?.
You live in a relativly impecunious county, have no means of livelihood to speak of, [or so you say], and yet you drive a Hummer, Mercedes, and just built a new house worth how much? _ _ _k ? Or is it just Mike declaring all that? Your trustee is still trying to find the bottom of all that drollery. Yet it is plain in the county records, as a judge will see.
Incidentally YOU are the one(s) accused of the scam, fraud, why not exonerate yourselves instead of hurling malevolent denunciations at innocuous people?
In conclusion, you're not above the law, there will be justice.
"Oh what a tangled web we weave, when first we practice to deceive." pungent candor isn't it?

#3 REBUTTAL Owner of company
come ride with us and you be the judge
AUTHOR: Mike - (U.S.A.)
SUBMITTED: Saturday, January 28, 2006
We ask that anyone that has any questions how we do bussiness at the Shire farms...come ride and see for your selfs. Then and only then will the truth come out. Not from hilaire williams whom has a warrant for her arrest in Lincoln Co. North Carolina,who spread these falsehoods.

#2 Consumer Comment
Mike and Kathryn Smith are not victims but sociopathic con-artists
AUTHOR: Hilaire - (U.S.A.)
SUBMITTED: Saturday, January 28, 2006
Just to comment on Mike Smiths rebuttal that he and his wife are victims, where's your proof dude!!! I am also a victim of these "horse traders" and there is a ton of proof against them. I have ads posted by Kathryn going back 2 years where they have listed out of different towns in and around NC, with different farm names and dozens of different contact numbers. Another victim won a lawsuit against Mike Smith for misrepresenting a horse they sold her!
When the number of victims reached into the 20's both Mike and Kathryn filed seperate lawsuits to try and hide from us. Mike's lawsuit was recently thrown out because he couldn't or wouldn't comply to the payment plan set forth. Kathryn's Ch. 7 was thrown out because of the lies and deceit she pulled on the bankruptcy trustee appointed to her. According to the public document she: concealed, mutilated, falsified or failed to keep or preserve any recorded information on these horses or transactions. Sounds like a real upstanding, honest couple to me! That very same trustee has now filed a suit against her.
Unfortunately Mike isn't as smart as his wife, that's why she runs the business and he's just there for intimidation factor. He will inevitably be their downfall. As for his claims that these are all consignment horses, there is news footage of he and his wife at a few of the NC horse sales (more concrete evidence). One of "the shire farms" victims is a paralegal who was so intimidated by Mike and his low-end friends that she was afraid to come forward. Another victim is a women who's son has celebral palsey. Kathryn was informed of this but without blinking and eye sold her two "bombproof, trailmasters" anyway that were both green broke and 10 yrs. older then stated.

#1 REBUTTAL Owner of company
victim of rip off.com and a blackmailing woman
AUTHOR: Mike - (U.S.A.)
SUBMITTED: Friday, January 27, 2006
We are a victim of ripoff.com and Kamala Warren. The real truth is that Ms. warren contacted us about a horse for sale that we had for consignment. She drove over to see the horse, and right away wanted us to load it up without even riding the horse before taking it home. At that point we told her that the horse must be ridden to show her that the horse rode and performed as advertised. She refused,stating that her butt was sore from the ride over. She was driving a new Suburban SUV pulling a trailer - how could that plush SUV make anyone's butt sore? She also asked for direction to go pick up anyother horse, a 15hand pony??? that she had purchased as well. Now we relize that kamala warren misrepresented herself to us as an experienced rider - she could not ride a horse at all, that is why she refused repeatedly to try the horse out in front of us.
After repeated attempts to get Ms. Warren to ride the horse herself,I had a 16 yr kid that was present, saddle and ride the horse in front of her.Walk,trot,canter..walk through woods,ditch,weeds etc. Everything we said it would do. She stated that that was all she needed to see and to load the horse up.
A week later,she called complaining about how the horse would not ride like she expected and wanted her money back. Ms. Warren thinks a horse is a machine,you drop a coin in and it has no brain. We could not sell her riding lessons,which she badly needed.
After several malicious phone calls, threatening phone calls at all hours of the night, and to our young daughter in the home We told her to return the horse and we would re-sale it for her. First, Ms. Warren said he had canceled the check, but still wanted us refund her monies???? We still maintained that she needed to bring the horse back - therefore we could evaluate her ON the horse & see what the problem was since she had REFUSED to ride the horse before she purchased - even after repeated attempts on our part to encourage her to ride the horse and give us the opportunity to evaluate the two of the them together. We offered to take the horse back & resell the horse for her but she refused to return the horse & our offer. She has contined to harass us and our family and has enlisted others in her dirty work. Our references from satsified customers, several who are law enforcement individuals contradict all the slanderous and malicious, and the untruths that Ms. Warren has spread.


Advertisers above have met our
strict standards for business conduct.