Church of Scientology Church of Scientology money fraud toronto ontario

Four women who accused the actor Danny Masterson of rape can move forward with a harassment lawsuit against the Church of Scientology, a California appeals court ruled Wednesday.

The suit was filed by women who said they were stalked and harassed by agents of the church after they reported to police that they had been raped by Masterson — a Scientologist who has been criminally charged. The husband of one of the women is also a plaintiff.

Masterson, who was a star on the sitcom “That ’70s Show,” faces charges of raping three women between 2001 and 2003. He has denied the charges and a criminal trial is pending.

The plaintiffs are suing the church, alleging that after going to the police, they were subjected to a campaign of harassment carried out by its agents.

The plaintiffs said agents of the Church of Scientology surveilled them, hacked their security systems, filmed them, chased them, killed or attempted to kill their pets, set fires outside their homes, and posted ads purporting to be from them soliciting anal sex from strangers. The church has denied any harassment.

The Times generally does not identify victims of alleged sexual assault unless they choose to fully identify themselves.

The church argued that the case should remain out of the courts because the women who are suing signed agreements forfeiting their right to sue the church and agreeing to arbitrate any claims against it before a panel of Scientologists in a process known as religious arbitration.

CALIFORNIA

Can former Scientologists take the church to court? Or are religious tribunals the only recourse?

Nov. 28, 2021

Religious arbitration has been used for centuries in the United States by Christians, Jews and Muslims, said Michael A. Helfand, a professor at Pepperdine University’s Caruso School of Law.

“At its best, it allows people who share a commitment to a certain set of rules and values to resolve their disputes in accordance with those rules and values,” he said.

The practice has long been upheld by secular courts, which by law cannot interfere with religious doctrinal matters.

A trial court and a panel of the state 2nd District Court of Appeal in Los Angeles previously ruled that the arbitration agreement could be enforced. However, the case returned to the appeals court in early November after the California Supreme Court ordered the judges to reconsider.

In a 39-page ruling released Wednesday, the panel of judges concluded that the case could move forward in a court of law because the harassment had occurred after the plaintiffs had left the church.