Bill me later paypal billed for fradulent account- they will provide no info on product supposedly shipped and billed to me Internet, Internet

   Bill Me Later send my wife a bill for $969.75 for something we were supposed to have purchased in July 2012.    We probally threw the first couple bills away thinking it was junk mail.  We have no active accounts with paypal or bill me later.   My wife had used paypal to make a ebay purchace a few years back.

  I called bill me later to get more info on purchace. They basically said that was internal information- just pay bill or make police report.  My wife made a police report to state police saying we got this bill- but dont know if something was supposed to be shipped to us (bill me later has that info i think but wont share)

  My wife also sent a complaint to WV State Attorney General.  We have not been able to get copy of police report yet (we have busy schedule during week and they want $20 for copy) and I dont think it will provide any info to anyone.

  If bill me later had helped me in any way to track this fradulent billing I would not be so furious about the situation. I would rather pay twice the amount above to a lawyer than pay anything to them. What options do I have?