Carid I paid $186 and never got what I order. Cranbury NJ

I order a driver side body fender for my 2012 jeep. $186.31 including shipping. I try to cancel a hour after I made the purchased but there website was't responding when I clicked on the cancel link. I work in a area where don't get good cell service. So calling then is not a option. I so get a phone call from a shipping freight company and they can't deliver unless I'm at home to receive it.

The fender is not that big or heavy. I don't know why they would just ship it ups. I also new to this area where i live at. I don't know the neighbors yet. So I just told the shipping company to send it back. I'm also skeptical about the cheap price ($71.31) VS OEM ($604). after reading stories and my own experience.  I called 5/31/2018 about a refund and they said no refund. So I just got rip off $186. Very unprofessional. 

ORDER #25856991 . The part that order:     

Replace® CH1240257PP - Front Driver Side Fender