First American Home Warranty Dishonest, greedy and lousy service, Internet

Our dishwasher panel shorted out 3 times between Oct 2010 and Aug 2011 and was unsuccessfully repaired by their contractor each time but the last. I had paid $110 for two previous unsuccessful co-pay attempts to fix the dishwasher and then the final $55 for the last fix.  First American says the repairs were separate and distinctly different.  Not true!  Repairmen stated on the last 2 visits that the previous repairs were done improperly causing the panel to short out.  First American originally waived the last copay, then sent me to collections demanding payment, which I decided to pay to minimize a hit on our credit.   Contract # 10275944801.  More specifically, each time First American (FA) fixed the panel on the dishwasher, which is only two years old, within a few months the panel would short out again.  After the first fix, the repairmen each time stated the previous repair was done improperly causing the panel to overheat and shortout. I paid $110 copay for the two first visits, and was told by First American (per a Sept 2010 phone call with their representative) that the third $55 payment would be waived and the final repairman stated I did not need to pay the final $55.  Then, in December 2011, First American called me informing me that I owe them that last $55 copay.  I tried to explain the situation with the representative who stated none of my story was documented in their files, and that I must pay.  I refused.  In Jan 2011, I received a bill for the $55 and I called and talked with another rep who said he understood my frustration but had no power to make any changes. I asked for a manager, and he stated there were none, and there was nobody up his management chain I could talk to.  I was trying to work something out. They were completely inflexible and indifferent.  In addition, the last repair took 4 months to complete....that's 1/3rd of the contract life. Poor customer service, poor repair contractors. Shortly thereafter, I received a collection notice and paid the $55.